I agree. I think giving Homestar until Wednesday morning is more than reasonable and in the future, I think everyone should have one full week to make their pick. If someone knows they'll be gone for a week or more, they'll need to PM someone with their preferences. Perhaps the Orgg or TomB would be willing to assume the duties of unbiased arbitrator. I don't think it would be fair to have people PM their picks to someone in the game.
Also, I think we should leave Homestar in the game with his current picks, but for all intents and purposes, skip over him until he comes back. So if he finally decides to show up in the middle of round 37, he can pick up 35 cards in a row (after notifying us, first) and be considered up to speed.
EDIT: On second thought, I agree more with Spidey. Homestar has had plenty of time to pick and it's highly unlikely he'll be on before tomorrow morning. Motion to move on without him?