I'm sure there's a "right" answer to this puzzle, but I have no idea what it is.
I had some possibilities mapped out, but this depended on the number of "wins" Throg had earlier in the contest. The more times he "won" a round, the less harmed he'd be and the more leeway he'd have if he messed up in the gin round. Throg did well enough that even drinking the gin undiluted would result in a "draw" and preclude him from
turning to page 23 winning the contest, but not get him killed. If he'd failed more times in earlier rounds, there were chances for him to get "cursed" by acquiring bad Chaos traits that I'd handpick from the table, but by this point, the only way for that to happen was if Throg had added ale to his own beverage and failed to add either ale or wine to the daemon's beverage. The gist of it is that you took the best option for Throg (brandy) and went neutral for the daemon (added nothing), but you were ahead from previous rounds, so you still came out ahead. That being said, here are results for adding beverages to the gin...
Infernal Heat Ale: increases harm from explosion.
Diamond Dust Wine: kills the drinker.
Roaring Thunder Rum: neutral.
Resplendent Frost Brandy: stabilizes the gin, preventing explosion.
Cold tends to stabilize explosives, especially if it's enough to solidify a normally liquid explosive, such as nitroglycerin. Whether you had such an effect in mind or whether you just guessed is up to you, but you got there.
