Yet MORE Planeshift, rare info!

[Chaos Turtle]

Actually, it's not identical at all. The abilites are all different.

In case anyone cares... the original:

Phelddagrif
1GWU
Creature - Legend
4/4

G: Phelddagrif gains trample until end of turn. Put a 1/1 green Hippo creature token into play under an opponent's control.

W: Phelddagrif gains flying until end of turn and an opponent gains 2 life.

U: Return Pheldagrif to its owner's hand and an opponent may draw a card.

 

[Duel]

He's right. I like the other one better. That way they tradea a removal spell for a spell whcih has no guarentee of being good.

 

[Chaos Turtle]

Huh?

 

[Duel]

Look, make it clear:

They: Terror pheldagriff
You: Return it to your hand, they draw a card.

Now: They gain 2 life instead, better.


They: wrath of god
You: Return it to your hand, they draw a card

Now: Nothing.

 

[Istanbul]

Let me translate that into English.

They: Play Terror.
Old Pheldagriff: You bounce it to your hand. They draw a card.
New Pheldagriff: You give it protection from black in response. They gain 2 life.

Advantage: New Pheldagriff.

They: Play Wrath of God.
Old Pheldagriff: You bounce it to your hand. They draw a card.
New Pheldagriff: Dies.

Advantage: Old Pheldagriff.

 

[arhar]

As always, I was WRONG!!! All the way!! Arrrrrgh.

Terminate IS real. Check out http://www.sideboard.com

On the good note, I know what my first pick's going to be in 95% of the packs that have it

 

[Chaos Turtle]

Oh, so Duel means the "old" Phelddagrif is better than the "new" one when it comes to global destruction, but the "new" one can handle being targetted by red and black stuff for a better price.

Well, I certainly wouldn't argue with that.