Yeah, but that other guy was fishing and lost his spear head, so I don't know if Rupert going to restrict all fishing just to him and maybe alienate some people on the tribe or they'll go along with it... I can't figure out what the other tribe bought since they're beat up so bad.
I know the other members (not Ryan and Lily) think his strength is an asset so that's probably why they didn't vote him off. That or like I said, the whole thing is a sham to get Ryan and Lily off-guard (especially since he was catching the football and running around like Lily noted).