Second Singleton Draft, Round 2: Mooseman vs. BigBlue

Discussion in 'Games Run By CPA Members' started by Mooseman, Aug 7, 2008.

  1. BigBlue Magic Jones

    That's pretty much all this deck is.... pure annoyance... :) If it works, it's annoying as hell... If it doesn't work, it annoys me to death...

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Play Swamp
    Play Glimpse the Unthinkable (Mill the top 10 cards of your library to GY)
    Attack for 1
    Done.

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 4
    Library: 36
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (T) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (TU) Swamp x2

    (T) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 20
    Hand: 4
    Library: 32 22?
    In Play:

    (TT) Island
    (T) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)

    Graveyard: Force Spike
    RFG:Incinerate
  2. Mooseman Isengar Tussle

    Well, I'm going nowhere fast.... nice deck.....
    Umezawa's Jitte
    Island
    Intruder Alarm
    Island
    Mountain
    Mountain
    Miscalculation
    Thwart
    Mountain
    Lightning Bolt


    Untap, Upkeep, Draw
    Done

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 4
    Library: 36
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (T) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (TU) Swamp x2

    (T) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 20
    Hand: 5
    Library: 21
    In Play:

    (UU) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte
    Island
    Intruder Alarm
    Island
    Mountain
    Mountain
    Miscalculation
    Thwart
    Mountain
    Lightning Bolt
    RFG:Incinerate
  3. BigBlue Magic Jones

    I was cringing when I cast it figure you'd have misdirection... whew...

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Play Island
    Play Acquire (I search your deck for an artifact, which I put in play under my control - then you shuffle) Not even sure what's left if anything...
    Attack for another 1
    Done.


    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 3
    Library: 35
    In Play:

    (T) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (T) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (TT) Swamp x2
    (T) Island

    (T) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 19 18?
    Hand: 5
    Library: 21 20?
    In Play:

    (UU) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate
  4. Mooseman Isengar Tussle

    Elemental Mastery
    Mountain
    Mox Ruby
    Morphling
    Coretapper
    Blazing Salvo
    Silver Myr
    Island
    Tropical Island
    Blistering Firecat
    Mana Leak
    Force of Will
    Clone
    Boomerang
    R Shock
    Taiga
    Stuffy Doll
    Steam Vents
    Fabricate
    Mountain
    3 Mana Web
  5. BigBlue Magic Jones

    I'll take your Stuffy Doll.
  6. BigBlue Magic Jones

    Updated

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 3
    Library: 35
    In Play:

    (T) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (T) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (TT) Swamp x2
    (T) Island

    (T) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (S) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal it to Mooseman instead; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 18
    Hand: 5
    Library: 20
    In Play:

    (UU) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate
  7. Mooseman Isengar Tussle

    U,U,D,done

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 3
    Library: 35
    In Play:

    (T) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (T) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (TT) Swamp x2
    (T) Island

    (T) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (S) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal it to Mooseman instead; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 18
    Hand: 6
    Library: 19
    In Play:

    (UU) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate
  8. BigBlue Magic Jones

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Play Swamp
    Attack w/ Proctor for 1
    Play Hell's Caretaker
    Done.

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 2
    Library: 32
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (U) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (TTT) Swamp x3
    (T) Island

    (T) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (U) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal it to Mooseman instead; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)
    (S) Hell's Caretaker (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: return a creature from my gy to play - play this ability only during upkeep)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 18 17?
    Hand: 6
    Library: 19
    In Play:

    (UU) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate[/QUOTE]
  9. Mooseman Isengar Tussle

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Silver Myr
    Done

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 2
    Library: 32
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (U) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (TTT) Swamp x3
    (T) Island

    (T) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (U) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal it to Mooseman instead; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)
    (S) Hell's Caretaker (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: return a creature from my gy to play - play this ability only during upkeep)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 18 17?
    Hand: 6
    Library: 18
    In Play:

    (TT) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)
    (S) Silver Myr (1/1,{Tap}: Add {U} to your mana pool.)


    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate
  10. BigBlue Magic Jones

    At your eot, activate the doll.

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Attack w/ the Proctor for 1
    Play Cemetary Puca
    Done.

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 2
    Library: 31
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (U) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (UTT) Swamp x3
    (T) Island

    (T) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (U) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal that much to Mooseman; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)
    (U) Hell's Caretaker (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: return a creature from my gy to play - play this ability only during upkeep)
    (S) Cemetary Puca (1/2; When a creature goes to a gy, I may pay 1 to make ~ a copy of it w/ this ability)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 16 15?
    Hand: 6
    Library: 18
    In Play:

    (TT) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)
    (S) Silver Myr (1/1,{Tap}: Add {U} to your mana pool.)

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate
  11. Mooseman Isengar Tussle

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw
    Coretapper

    Done.

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 2
    Library: 31
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (U) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (UTT) Swamp x3
    (T) Island

    (T) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (U) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal that much to Mooseman; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)
    (U) Hell's Caretaker (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: return a creature from my gy to play - play this ability only during upkeep)
    (S) Cemetary Puca (1/2; When a creature goes to a gy, I may pay 1 to make ~ a copy of it w/ this ability)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 16 15?
    Hand: 6
    Library: 18
    In Play:

    (TT) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)
    (U) Silver Myr (1/1,{Tap}: Add {U} to your mana pool.)
    (S) Coretapper (1/1,T: Put a charge counter on target artifact. Sac ~: Put two charge counters on targetartifact. )


    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate
  12. BigBlue Magic Jones

    At your eot, activate Stuffy Doll.

    Untap, Upkeep (Activate Hell's Caretaker, sacrifice Proctor. Return Proctor to play, return Silver Myr to your hand when it cip.)

    Draw
    Attack w/ Cemetary Puca for 1.
    Done.

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 3
    Library: 30
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (U) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (UUU) Swamp x3
    (U) Island

    (S) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (U) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal that much to Mooseman; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)
    (T) Hell's Caretaker (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: return a creature from my gy to play - play this ability only during upkeep)
    (T) Cemetary Puca (1/2; When a creature goes to a gy, I may pay 1 to make ~ a copy of it w/ this ability)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 14 13?
    Hand: 6 7?
    Library: 18
    In Play:

    (TT) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)
    (U) Silver Myr (1/1,{Tap}: Add {U} to your mana pool.) Returned?
    (S) Coretapper (1/1,T: Put a charge counter on target artifact. Sac ~: Put two charge counters on targetartifact. )

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate
  13. Mooseman Isengar Tussle

    Untap, Upkeep

    Draw
    Silver Myr
    Done.

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 3
    Library: 30
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (U) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (UUU) Swamp x3
    (U) Island

    (S) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (U) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal that much to Mooseman; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)
    (T) Hell's Caretaker (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: return a creature from my gy to play - play this ability only during upkeep)
    (T) Cemetary Puca (1/2; When a creature goes to a gy, I may pay 1 to make ~ a copy of it w/ this ability)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 14 13?
    Hand: 7
    Library: 17
    In Play:

    (TT) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)
    (U) Silver Myr (1/1,{Tap}: Add {U} to your mana pool.)
    (S) Coretapper (1/1,T: Put a charge counter on target artifact. Sac ~: Put two charge counters on targetartifact. )

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate
  14. BigBlue Magic Jones

    Activate Stuffy doll at your eot to do 1 to you.

    Untap, Upkeep

    Activate Hell's Caretaker (Sacrifice Stern Proctor, return Stern Proctor, when it cip - return your silver myr back to your hand)

    Draw
    Attack w/ Puca for 1
    Done.

    (Land is not being friendly to you... sorry. :( )

    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 4
    Library: 29
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (U) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (UUU) Swamp x3
    (U) Island

    (S) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (U) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal that much to Mooseman; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)
    (T) Hell's Caretaker (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: return a creature from my gy to play - play this ability only during upkeep)
    (T) Cemetary Puca (1/2; When a creature goes to a gy, I may pay 1 to make ~ a copy of it w/ this ability)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 12 11?
    Hand: 7 8?
    Library: 17
    In Play:

    (TT) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)
    (U) Silver Myr (1/1,{Tap}: Add {U} to your mana pool.) Returned?
    (S) Coretapper (1/1,T: Put a charge counter on target artifact. Sac ~: Put two charge counters on targetartifact. )

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt RFG:Incinerate
  15. Mooseman Isengar Tussle

    Hell's Caretasker says:T, Sacrifice a creature: Return target creature card from your graveyard to play. Play this ability only during your upkeep.

    you can't target the Protector, since it's not in the graveyard, until the spell is paid for.
    Targeting come before payment when casting a spell....
  16. Ransac CPA Trash Man

    I was just about to ask about that...


    Ransac, cpa trash man
  17. BigBlue Magic Jones

    My bad. I thought I'd read in the rulings that you could do this... but you are correct.

    Without a legal target, I can't EVEN announce the ability...

    So, to be fair, we'll go back and for now assume I did NOT attack for 1 in post 92. Go ahead and replay your turn (post 93) - w/ your myr already in play. You are at 14 life.

    Sincere apologies.
  18. Mooseman Isengar Tussle

    There is no reason to rewind, We'll just keep the myr in play and your caretaker untapped. BTW - you can announce it and try to play the ability, but when you get to targets it will fail.......

    Untap, Upkeep , draw
    Bounce the stuffy doll with boomerrang
    response?


    BigBlue: 20
    Hand: 4
    Library: 29
    In Play:

    (U) Salt Marsh (T: Add U or B; cip tapped)
    (U) Sunken Ruins (T:1; (U/B),T: Add UU, UB, or BB)
    (UUU) Swamp x3
    (U) Island

    (U) Stern Proctor (1/2; When ~ cip, return target enchantment or Artifact to owners hand.
    (U) Stuffy Doll (0/1; Indestructible; When ~ is dealt damage, deal that much to Mooseman; T: Deal 1 dmg to ~)
    (U) Hell's Caretaker (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: return a creature from my gy to play - play this ability only during upkeep)
    (T) Cemetary Puca (1/2; When a creature goes to a gy, I may pay 1 to make ~ a copy of it w/ this ability)

    Graveyard:Memory Lapse, Glimpse the Unthinkable
    RFG:

    Mooseman: 11
    Hand: 7
    Library: 16
    In Play:

    (TT) Island
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Dragon Mask (3, tap: Target creature you control gets +2/+2 until end of turn. At end of turn, return that creature to its owner's hand.)
    (U) Silver Myr (1/1,{Tap}: Add {U} to your mana pool.)
    (U) Coretapper (1/1,T: Put a charge counter on target artifact. Sac ~: Put two charge counters on targetartifact. )

    Graveyard: Force Spike,Umezawa's Jitte, Island, Intruder Alarm, Island, Mountain, Mountain, Miscalculation, Thwart, Mountain, Lightning Bolt, Boomerang
    RFG:Incinerate
  19. BigBlue Magic Jones

    You are at 13 then... I wouldn't have attacked if you'd have had both blockers & mask available...

    And if I can announce it, then the proctor is in my gy...

    I'll complicate the boomerang (pay 3 or it's countered).
  20. Mooseman Isengar Tussle

    No, when a spell/ability has illegal targets when being played, it is rewound to before the spell/ability was attempted...... there is some rule out there..... the proctor would be returned to play and the caretaker would be untapped......

    Bounce is complicated

    I am done

Share This Page