I have decided to use Ransac's idea and see how it works.
The two bottles that Daggertooth was still missing were 10 and 93. Here are the results:
Crazy Cannibals
Rasac(10 and 93, 83 points)
nodnarb24(10 and 93, 83 points)
Teferi(34 and 36, 2 points)
Total score: 168 points
Stupid Smellies
Gerode(41 and 94, 51 points)
magicman_moe(10 and 93, 83 points)
Extra Stupid Smelly(9 and 65, 46 points)
Total score: 180 points
Sorry to the Crazy Cannibals, but it was random. So, one of the Crazy Cannibal must be voted out of the Burger King. Votes must be received by Monday, March 5 by 3:00 Eastern Time.