I don't really think it'd liven up the place that much. You can discuss other games already in the General Gaming and Off Topic forumus. I think if all of these new forums were created, there might be a flurry of posting in the new games forums, and then they'd just sort of die off to nothing after a while. I still believe that this won't attract any new members. And for those of us that are still here, we all play a bunch of games, but do we play the same games? For instance, I play the Showdown card games, but I doubt anybody else does or wants to discuss them with me. And a person that is a hard-core showdown fan will go to a site dedicated to the Showdown games, not here where we have one Showdown player and a bunch of Magic players. The same goes for the Cheapass Games (well, maybe there are a couple other than theorgg, but not enough to sustain conversation), and a bunch of other games (Spidey plays Warhammer, and maybe one or two others do, but again there won't be enough to sustain discussion). So I think we'd end up with a bunch of brand spanking new forums--filled with cobwebs.
And finally, even if there were somehow a unanimous vote to do this, could we? I'm not sure we could convince Mike to come and redo all that stuff, changing the entire nature of the site. And do we have anyone else that could do it?