Completely unnecessary. They could just be reprinted as a box set (like Anthologies or Beatdown). That type of reprint has been done in the past, and the cards are legal for Vintage (or Legacy) but are not a part of the card pool in rotating formats. I hope that is not what all of the fuss is about. I'm all for the people playing rotating formats being able to have a balanced metagame, but there is a world outside Standard/Extended. I think part of the issue is collectors and all that. Personally, I would love to see reprints. I'm all about availability in this game. I have eight copies of Force of Will. They keep going up in value, but I wouldn't care if they were reprinted (the same goes for the dual lands I have). That's not to say that I don't think WotC should be able to make money on cards. I've been willing to shell out some cash in the past to build a good deck, but the availability of these old cards can only shrink, and I like winning games because of deck-building/strategy and even a little luck a lot more than I like winning because I happen to have better cards than my opponents.