Mindmaster Weatherlight Chaos: Spidey vs Limited vs Mooseman

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Untap, upkeep,
attack Spidey with knight for 2.
Responses?

Spidey: 11
Hand: 3
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(T,T,T,U) Swamp x4
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U,U) Island x2

Graveyard: Choking Vines, Relearn, Spinning Darkness, Bogardan Firefiend, Fatal Blow, Benalish Knight, Guided Strike, Hurloon Shaman, Mountain, Striped Bears, Ophidian, Tendrils of Despair, Urborg Justice

Mooseman: 13
Hand: 0
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(TTT) Plains
(UU) Swamp


Strands of Night (BB, Pay 2 life, Sacrifice a swamp: Put target creature card from your graveyard into play.)

(T) Benalish Knight (2/2, first strike)

Graveyard:Guided Strike, Argivian Find, Phantom Wings, Swamp, Soul Shepherd, Benalish Infantry, Island, Swamp, Ardent Militia, Shadow Rider, Mischievious Poltergeist, Rogue Elephant, Kithkin Armor
RFG: Dwarven Berserker, Sage Owl

Limited: 5
Hand: 1
In Play:

(UU) 2x Plains
(UU) 2x Island
(U) Swamp
(UU) 2x Mountain
(UU) 2x Forest

(U) Goblin Vandal (1/1 if unblocked, I may pay R to destroy an artifact instead of dealing damage)
(T) Mischievous Poltergeist (1/1 flying; pay 1 life: regenerate)

Graveyard: Sawtooth Ogres, Angelic Renewal, Coils of the Medusa, Redwood Treefolk, Mwonvuli Ooze, Choking Vines, Gemstone Mine, Chimeric Sphere, Merfolk Trader, Benalish Knight, Fog Elemental, Striped Bears
RFG:
 

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Done

Spidey: 9
Hand: 3
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(T,T,T,U) Swamp x4
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U,U) Island x2

Graveyard: Choking Vines, Relearn, Spinning Darkness, Bogardan Firefiend, Fatal Blow, Benalish Knight, Guided Strike, Hurloon Shaman, Mountain, Striped Bears, Ophidian, Tendrils of Despair, Urborg Justice

Mooseman: 13
Hand: 0
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(TTT) Plains
(UU) Swamp


Strands of Night (BB, Pay 2 life, Sacrifice a swamp: Put target creature card from your graveyard into play.)

(T) Benalish Knight (2/2, first strike)

Graveyard:Guided Strike, Argivian Find, Phantom Wings, Swamp, Soul Shepherd, Benalish Infantry, Island, Swamp, Ardent Militia, Shadow Rider, Mischievious Poltergeist, Rogue Elephant, Kithkin Armor
RFG: Dwarven Berserker, Sage Owl

Limited: 5
Hand: 1
In Play:

(UU) 2x Plains
(UU) 2x Island
(U) Swamp
(UU) 2x Mountain
(UU) 2x Forest

(U) Goblin Vandal (1/1 if unblocked, I may pay R to destroy an artifact instead of dealing damage)
(T) Mischievous Poltergeist (1/1 flying; pay 1 life: regenerate)

Graveyard: Sawtooth Ogres, Angelic Renewal, Coils of the Medusa, Redwood Treefolk, Mwonvuli Ooze, Choking Vines, Gemstone Mine, Chimeric Sphere, Merfolk Trader, Benalish Knight, Fog Elemental, Striped Bears
RFG:
 
L

Limited

Guest
Untap, upkeep,

Done :(

Spidey: 9
Hand: 3
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(T,T,T,U) Swamp x4
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U,U) Island x2

Graveyard: Choking Vines, Relearn, Spinning Darkness, Bogardan Firefiend, Fatal Blow, Benalish Knight, Guided Strike, Hurloon Shaman, Mountain, Striped Bears, Ophidian, Tendrils of Despair, Urborg Justice

Mooseman: 13
Hand: 0
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(TTT) Plains
(UU) Swamp


Strands of Night (BB, Pay 2 life, Sacrifice a swamp: Put target creature card from your graveyard into play.)

(T) Benalish Knight (2/2, first strike)

Graveyard:Guided Strike, Argivian Find, Phantom Wings, Swamp, Soul Shepherd, Benalish Infantry, Island, Swamp, Ardent Militia, Shadow Rider, Mischievious Poltergeist, Rogue Elephant, Kithkin Armor
RFG: Dwarven Berserker, Sage Owl

Limited: 5
Hand: 1
In Play:

(UU) 2x Plains
(UU) 2x Island
(U) Swamp
(UU) 2x Mountain
(UU) 2x Forest

(U) Goblin Vandal (1/1 if unblocked, I may pay R to destroy an artifact instead of dealing damage)
(U) Mischievous Poltergeist (1/1 flying; pay 1 life: regenerate)

Graveyard: Sawtooth Ogres, Angelic Renewal, Coils of the Medusa, Redwood Treefolk, Mwonvuli Ooze, Choking Vines, Gemstone Mine, Chimeric Sphere, Merfolk Trader, Benalish Knight, Fog Elemental, Striped Bears
RFG:
 

Spiderman

Administrator
Staff member
Same here.

Untap, upkeep,

Done.

Spidey: 9
Hand: 3
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(T,T,T,U) Swamp x4
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U,U) Island x2

Graveyard: Choking Vines, Relearn, Spinning Darkness, Bogardan Firefiend, Fatal Blow, Benalish Knight, Guided Strike, Hurloon Shaman, Mountain, Striped Bears, Ophidian, Tendrils of Despair, Urborg Justice

Mooseman: 13
Hand: 0
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(TTT) Plains
(UU) Swamp


Strands of Night (BB, Pay 2 life, Sacrifice a swamp: Put target creature card from your graveyard into play.)

(T) Benalish Knight (2/2, first strike)

Graveyard:Guided Strike, Argivian Find, Phantom Wings, Swamp, Soul Shepherd, Benalish Infantry, Island, Swamp, Ardent Militia, Shadow Rider, Mischievious Poltergeist, Rogue Elephant, Kithkin Armor
RFG: Dwarven Berserker, Sage Owl

Limited: 5
Hand: 1
In Play:

(UU) 2x Plains
(UU) 2x Island
(U) Swamp
(UU) 2x Mountain
(UU) 2x Forest

(U) Goblin Vandal (1/1 if unblocked, I may pay R to destroy an artifact instead of dealing damage)
(U) Mischievous Poltergeist (1/1 flying; pay 1 life: regenerate)

Graveyard: Sawtooth Ogres, Angelic Renewal, Coils of the Medusa, Redwood Treefolk, Mwonvuli Ooze, Choking Vines, Gemstone Mine, Chimeric Sphere, Merfolk Trader, Benalish Knight, Fog Elemental, Striped Bears
RFG:
 
L

Limited

Guest
Exciting game :(

Perhaps Mindmaster isn't suitable for multiplayer.
 

Spiderman

Administrator
Staff member
Well, I think it'd be okay, just in this case the cards didn't go my way. I got few creatures to start with and okay removal spells, but of course they had to be spread out between the two of you :)

Mooseman got the best with his Phantom Wings and Strands of Night, IMO. So his best creature can keep coming back. And neither of us had enchantment removal.

It's just how the cards go :) I'd play all of the other expansions before making a decision whether Mindmaster is good for MP :)
 

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
End of Spiderman's turn
pay 2, BB and sac a swamp
put Rider into play
untap upkeep
Attack spiderman with the knight and Limited with the Rider

Spidey: 9
Hand: 3
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(T,T,T,U) Swamp x4
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U,U) Island x2

Graveyard: Choking Vines, Relearn, Spinning Darkness, Bogardan Firefiend, Fatal Blow, Benalish Knight, Guided Strike, Hurloon Shaman, Mountain, Striped Bears, Ophidian, Tendrils of Despair, Urborg Justice

Mooseman: 11
Hand: 0
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(UUU) Plains
(T) Swamp


Strands of Night (BB, Pay 2 life, Sacrifice a swamp: Put target creature card from your graveyard into play.)

(T) Benalish Knight (2/2, first strike)
(T) Shadow Rider (3/3, flanking)

Graveyard:Guided Strike, Argivian Find, Phantom Wings, Swamp, Soul Shepherd, Benalish Infantry, Island, Swamp, Ardent Militia, , Mischievious Poltergeist, Rogue Elephant, Kithkin Armor, Swamp
RFG: Dwarven Berserker, Sage Owl

Limited: 5
Hand: 1
In Play:

(UU) 2x Plains
(UU) 2x Island
(U) Swamp
(UU) 2x Mountain
(UU) 2x Forest

(U) Goblin Vandal (1/1 if unblocked, I may pay R to destroy an artifact instead of dealing damage)
(U) Mischievous Poltergeist (1/1 flying; pay 1 life: regenerate)

Graveyard: Sawtooth Ogres, Angelic Renewal, Coils of the Medusa, Redwood Treefolk, Mwonvuli Ooze, Choking Vines, Gemstone Mine, Chimeric Sphere, Merfolk Trader, Benalish Knight, Fog Elemental, Striped Bears
RFG:
 
L

Limited

Guest
I'll take three :( and assume you're done.

Untap, Upkeep

Done

Spidey: 7
Hand: 3
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(T,T,T,U) Swamp x4
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U,U) Island x2

Graveyard: Choking Vines, Relearn, Spinning Darkness, Bogardan Firefiend, Fatal Blow, Benalish Knight, Guided Strike, Hurloon Shaman, Mountain, Striped Bears, Ophidian, Tendrils of Despair, Urborg Justice

Mooseman: 11
Hand: 0
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(UUU) Plains
(T) Swamp


Strands of Night (BB, Pay 2 life, Sacrifice a swamp: Put target creature card from your graveyard into play.)

(T) Benalish Knight (2/2, first strike)
(T) Shadow Rider (3/3, flanking)

Graveyard:Guided Strike, Argivian Find, Phantom Wings, Swamp, Soul Shepherd, Benalish Infantry, Island, Swamp, Ardent Militia, , Mischievious Poltergeist, Rogue Elephant, Kithkin Armor, Swamp
RFG: Dwarven Berserker, Sage Owl

Limited: 2
Hand: 1
In Play:

(UU) 2x Plains
(UU) 2x Island
(U) Swamp
(UU) 2x Mountain
(UU) 2x Forest

(U) Goblin Vandal (1/1 if unblocked, I may pay R to destroy an artifact instead of dealing damage)
(U) Mischievous Poltergeist (1/1 flying; pay 1 life: regenerate)

Graveyard: Sawtooth Ogres, Angelic Renewal, Coils of the Medusa, Redwood Treefolk, Mwonvuli Ooze, Choking Vines, Gemstone Mine, Chimeric Sphere, Merfolk Trader, Benalish Knight, Fog Elemental, Striped Bears
RFG:
 

Spiderman

Administrator
Staff member
You know I gots nothing to do.

Untap, Upkeep

Done

Spidey: 7
Hand: 3
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(T,T,T,U) Swamp x4
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U,U) Island x2

Graveyard: Choking Vines, Relearn, Spinning Darkness, Bogardan Firefiend, Fatal Blow, Benalish Knight, Guided Strike, Hurloon Shaman, Mountain, Striped Bears, Ophidian, Tendrils of Despair, Urborg Justice

Mooseman: 11
Hand: 0
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(UUU) Plains
(T) Swamp


Strands of Night (BB, Pay 2 life, Sacrifice a swamp: Put target creature card from your graveyard into play.)

(T) Benalish Knight (2/2, first strike)
(T) Shadow Rider (3/3, flanking)

Graveyard:Guided Strike, Argivian Find, Phantom Wings, Swamp, Soul Shepherd, Benalish Infantry, Island, Swamp, Ardent Militia, , Mischievious Poltergeist, Rogue Elephant, Kithkin Armor, Swamp
RFG: Dwarven Berserker, Sage Owl

Limited: 2
Hand: 1
In Play:

(UU) 2x Plains
(UU) 2x Island
(U) Swamp
(UU) 2x Mountain
(UU) 2x Forest

(U) Goblin Vandal (1/1 if unblocked, I may pay R to destroy an artifact instead of dealing damage)
(U) Mischievous Poltergeist (1/1 flying; pay 1 life: regenerate)

Graveyard: Sawtooth Ogres, Angelic Renewal, Coils of the Medusa, Redwood Treefolk, Mwonvuli Ooze, Choking Vines, Gemstone Mine, Chimeric Sphere, Merfolk Trader, Benalish Knight, Fog Elemental, Striped Bears
RFG:
 

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
rinse, repeat.....
Knight at Spiderman, Rider at Limited

Done

Spidey: 7
Hand: 3
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(T,T,T,U) Swamp x4
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U,U) Island x2

Graveyard: Choking Vines, Relearn, Spinning Darkness, Bogardan Firefiend, Fatal Blow, Benalish Knight, Guided Strike, Hurloon Shaman, Mountain, Striped Bears, Ophidian, Tendrils of Despair, Urborg Justice

Mooseman: 11
Hand: 0
In Play:

(U) Mountain
(UUU) Plains
(T) Swamp


Strands of Night (BB, Pay 2 life, Sacrifice a swamp: Put target creature card from your graveyard into play.)

(T) Benalish Knight (2/2, first strike)
(T) Shadow Rider (3/3, flanking)

Graveyard:Guided Strike, Argivian Find, Phantom Wings, Swamp, Soul Shepherd, Benalish Infantry, Island, Swamp, Ardent Militia, , Mischievious Poltergeist, Rogue Elephant, Kithkin Armor, Swamp
RFG: Dwarven Berserker, Sage Owl

Limited: 2
Hand: 1
In Play:

(UU) 2x Plains
(UU) 2x Island
(U) Swamp
(UU) 2x Mountain
(UU) 2x Forest

(U) Goblin Vandal (1/1 if unblocked, I may pay R to destroy an artifact instead of dealing damage)
(U) Mischievous Poltergeist (1/1 flying; pay 1 life: regenerate)

Graveyard: Sawtooth Ogres, Angelic Renewal, Coils of the Medusa, Redwood Treefolk, Mwonvuli Ooze, Choking Vines, Gemstone Mine, Chimeric Sphere, Merfolk Trader, Benalish Knight, Fog Elemental, Striped Bears
RFG:
 

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
I'm done.
I got no cards in hand or enough swamps left to use the emchantment, so it's fairly straight forward for me.
 

Ransac

CPA Trash Man
Yeah, I was afraid that something like that would happen. Mindmaster is incredibly tough to play in multiplayer. After this game, if more multi-master occurs, maybe players can only attack particular player?


Ransac, cpa trash man
 
Top