Mindmaster Time Spiral: Shoe vs Spiderman

[Shoe]

Take it

Shoe: 14
Hand: 12
Battlefield:

(T, U) 2 Swamp, (T) Island, (T) mountain


(T) Deathspore Thallid (Flying, 1/1; At the beginning of your upkeep, put a spore ctr on ~; Remove three spore ctrs from ~: Put a 1/1 green Saproling creature token into play; Sac a Saproling: Target creature gets -1/-1 ueot) (2 Spore Counter)

enchanted with Fallen Ideal
Enchant creature
Enchanted creature has flying and “Sacrifice a creature: This creature gets +2/+1 until end of turn.”
When Fallen Ideal is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, return Fallen Ideal to its owner’s hand.

Graveyard: Nether Traitor (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)
Exile: Mindstab (1 counters)
=============================================================
Spiderman: 16
Hand: 12
Battlefield:

(U) Swamp
(U) Plains
(U) Forest

(T,A) Benalish Cavalry (2/2; Flanking)
(T,A) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG)

Graveyard:
Exile: Mindstab (1 time ctr)

 

[Spiderman]

Yeah. I didn't want to update in case you had responses.

Ah. I thought my post was saying I didn't have responses so I was taking it. Plus I'm tapped out anyways.

I also believe you're taking 5 so you should be down to 13 since you started at 18 before the attack.

After the attack,

Mt
Tendrils of Corruption on your Thallid
Responses?


Shoe: 14 13?
Hand: 12
Battlefield:

(T, U) 2 Swamp, (T) Island, (T) mountain


(T) Deathspore Thallid (Flying, 1/1; At the beginning of your upkeep, put a spore ctr on ~; Remove three spore ctrs from ~: Put a 1/1 green Saproling creature token into play; Sac a Saproling: Target creature gets -1/-1 ueot) (2 Spore Counter)

enchanted with Fallen Ideal
Enchant creature
Enchanted creature has flying and “Sacrifice a creature: This creature gets +2/+1 until end of turn.”
When Fallen Ideal is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, return Fallen Ideal to its owner’s hand.

Graveyard: Nether Traitor (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)
Exile: Mindstab (1 counters)
=============================================================
Spiderman: 16
Hand: 11
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(T) Benalish Cavalry (2/2; Flanking)
(T) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption
Exile: Mindstab (1 time ctr)

 

[Shoe]

Yeah my bad, I flipped the p/t of the nantuko in my head

 

[Shoe]

No response but I will pay for the nether traitor trigger when thallid dies and fallen ideal also returns to my hand


Shoe: 13
Hand: 13

Battlefield: Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(T, t) 2 Swamp, (t)1 island, (t) 1 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid
Exile: Mindstab (1 counters)
=============================================================
Spiderman: 17
Hand: 11
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(T) Benalish Cavalry (2/2; Flanking)
(T) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption
Exile: Mindstab (1 time ctr)

 

[Spiderman]

Done

 

[Shoe]

Ok, untap, upkeep, cast the Mindstab targeting you.

Shoe: 13
Hand: 13

Battlefield: Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(Uu) 2 Swamp, (u)1 island, (u) 1 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 17
Hand: 11
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(T) Benalish Cavalry (2/2; Flanking)
(T) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption
Exile: Mindstab (1 time ctr)

 

[Spiderman]

Wait, you sure not you?

Discard Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice , and Greenseeker

Shoe: 13
Hand: 13

Battlefield: Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(Uu) 2 Swamp, (u)1 island, (u) 1 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 17
Hand: 8
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(T) Benalish Cavalry (2/2; Flanking)
(T) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker
Exile: Mindstab (1 time ctr)

 

[Shoe]

The set DOES have madness

Play a mountain and Swing with nether traitor and pass the turn.

Shoe: 13
Hand: 13

Battlefield: Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(Uu) 2 Swamp, (u)1 island, (uu) 2 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 16
Hand: 8
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(T) Benalish Cavalry (2/2; Flanking)
(T) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker
Exile: Mindstab (1 time ctr)

 

[Spiderman]

Untap, upkeep - remove time ctr, cast Mindstab targeting you... your turn... and you probably have those madness spells

Shoe: 13
Hand: 13

Battlefield: Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(Uu) 2 Swamp, (u)1 island, (uu) 2 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 16
Hand: 8
Battlefield:

(U) Swamp
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U) Mt

(U) Benalish Cavalry (2/2; Flanking)
(U) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker, Mindstab
Exile:

 

[Shoe]

Indeed I do, discard Grinning Totem, Dark Withering and Psychotic Episode, Casting the latter 2

Dark Withering (Targeting the Knight)
Destroy target nonblack creature.
Madness {B}

Psychotic Episode
Target player reveals their hand and the top card of their library. You choose a card revealed this way. That player puts the chosen card on the bottom of their library.
Madness {1}{B}


Shoe: 13
Hand: 13

Battlefield: Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(TT) 2 Swamp, (u)1 island, (T,u) 2 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab, Grinning Totem
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 16
Hand: 8
Battlefield:

(U) Swamp
(U) Plains
(U) Forest
(U) Mt

(U) Benalish Cavalry (2/2; Flanking)
(U) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker, Mindstab
Exile:

 

[Spiderman]

LOL, well, that worked out much better for you.

Hand:

Saw it

 

[Shoe]

LOL, well, that worked out much better for you.

Hand:

Screeching Sliver
Coral Trickster
Fathom Seer
Fallen Ideal
Spirit Loop
Firewake Sliver
Greater Gargadon
Spitting Slug

gonna go with Greater Gargadon to the library

 

[Spiderman]

Well, that was terrible.

Spirit Loop on my Shaman
Responses?

Shoe: 13
Hand: 9

Battlefield:

(S) Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(TT) 2 Swamp, (u)1 island, (T,u) 2 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab, Grinning Totem, Dark Withering, Psychotic Episode
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 16
Hand: 6
Library: 1
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(U) Forest
(U) Mt

Spirit Loop (Whenever enchanted creature deals dmg, I gain that much life.; When ~ is put in a graveyard from play, return it to its owner's hand)

(U) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG) *Spirited?*

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker, Mindstab, Benalish Cavalry
Exile:

 

[Shoe]

Nope, continue. Sorry my family life just got awful so I might be slow to respond

 

[Spiderman]

Oh man, I'm sorry to hear that. Take your time, that's the good thing about forum games.

Attack
Responses/blocks/take it?

Shoe: 13
Hand: 9

Battlefield:

(S) Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(TT) 2 Swamp, (u)1 island, (T,u) 2 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab, Grinning Totem, Dark Withering, Psychotic Episode
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 16
Hand: 6
Library: 1
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(U) Forest
(U) Mt

Spirit Loop (Whenever enchanted creature deals dmg, I gain that much life.; When ~ is put in a graveyard from play, return it to its owner's hand)

(T,A) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG) *Spirited*

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker, Mindstab, Benalish Cavalry
Exile:

 

[Shoe]

Take it

Shoe: 10
Hand: 9

Battlefield:

(S) Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(TT) 2 Swamp, (u)1 island, (T,u) 2 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab, Grinning Totem, Dark Withering, Psychotic Episode
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 16
Hand: 6
Library: 1
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(U) Forest
(U) Mt

Spirit Loop (Whenever enchanted creature deals dmg, I gain that much life.; When ~ is put in a graveyard from play, return it to its owner's hand)

(T,A) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG) *Spirited*

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker, Mindstab, Benalish Cavalry
Exile:

 

[Spiderman]

Added 3 life to me because of Spirit Loop.

Forest
Spitting Slug

Done

Shoe: 10
Hand: 9

Battlefield:

(S) Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(TT) 2 Swamp, (u)1 island, (T,u) 2 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab, Grinning Totem, Dark Withering, Psychotic Episode
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 19
Hand: 5
Library: 1
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x2
(T) Mt

Spirit Loop (Whenever enchanted creature deals dmg, I gain that much life.; When ~ is put in a graveyard from play, return it to its owner's hand)

(T) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG) *Spirited*
(S) Spitting Slug (2/4; Whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked, I may pay 1G. If I do, ~ gains first strike ueot. Otherwise, each creature blocking or blocked by ~ gains first strike ueot)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker, Mindstab, Benalish Cavalry
Exile:

 

[Shoe]

Untap, upkeep. Play an island

Cast temporal eddy, targeting the nantuko
2uu sorcery
Put target creature or land on top of its owner’s library.

Shoe: 10
Hand: 9

Battlefield:

(S) Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(Uu) 2 Swamp, (tt)2 island, (tt) 2 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab, Grinning Totem, Dark Withering, Psychotic Episode
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 19
Hand: 5
Library: 1
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x2
(T) Mt

Spirit Loop (Whenever enchanted creature deals dmg, I gain that much life.; When ~ is put in a graveyard from play, return it to its owner's hand)

(T) Nantuko Shaman (3/2; When ~ ETB, if I control no tapped lands, draw a card; Suspend 1-2GG) *Spirited*
(S) Spitting Slug (2/4; Whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked, I may pay 1G. If I do, ~ gains first strike ueot. Otherwise, each creature blocking or blocked by ~ gains first strike ueot)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker, Mindstab, Benalish Cavalry
Exile:

 

[Spiderman]

No response - Spirit Loop returns to my hand.

 

[Shoe]

Swing with nether traitor and done

Shoe: 10
Hand: 8

Battlefield:

(S) Nether Traitor 1/1 shadow haste (Whenever another creature is put into your graveyard from the battlefield, you may pay {B}. If you do, return Nether Traitor from your graveyard to the battlefield.)

(Uu) 2 Swamp, (tt)2 island, (tt) 2 mountain


Graveyard: Deathspore thallid, Mindstab, Grinning Totem, Dark Withering, Psychotic Episode
Exile:
=============================================================
Spiderman: 18
Hand: 6
Library: 1
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x2
(T) Mt

(S) Spitting Slug (2/4; Whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked, I may pay 1G. If I do, ~ gains first strike ueot. Otherwise, each creature blocking or blocked by ~ gains first strike ueot)

Graveyard: Tendrils of Corruption, Sage of Epityr, Gaze of Justice, Greenseeker, Mindstab, Benalish Cavalry
Exile: