Search results

  1. Oversoul

    Magic Memories: Karmic Guide

    Interesting. I noticed it when I was going through the full set of Visions for setting up my collection binders, but I haven't ever played Miraculous Recovery and honestly can't recall seeing someone else use it against me. As Magic cards go, it's decent. It was reprinted in Ultimate Masters, so...
  2. Oversoul

    Magic Memories: Karmic Guide

    Perhaps you're thinking of Miraculous Recovery?
  3. Oversoul

    Eternal Apprenticeship [EDH]

    Tawnos seems really good. I am surprised that this commander isn't more popular. Mostly built this one with Sands of Time in mind, but it's experimental. Commander: 1 Tawnos, Urza's Apprentice 1 Academy Ruins 1 Arcane Denial 1 Arcane Signet 1 Arcbound Ravager 1 Basalt Monolith 1 Brainstorm 1...
  4. Oversoul

    Magic Memories: Karmic Guide

    I talked about this in the Tolarian Academy thread, but Karmic Guide was an unfortunate casualty of a reaction to the "Combo Winter" of 1998 and 1999. In the case of Karmic Guide, this happened in a roundabout way, so I should explain.... Karmic Guide came out in Urza's Legacy, which was...
  5. Oversoul

    Magic Memories: Karmic Guide

    There's that too! I was going to bring that up at some point. It's worth mentioning. The use of the "Echo" mechanic on this card has its pros and cons, but having to pay for the creature twice gets mitigated because you get the value of two creatures: the one you brought back from your graveyard...
  6. Oversoul

    An Elephant Never Forgets [EDH]

    So this deck and the Haunt of Hightower deck were both new decks I brought to EDH night at the LGS on Wednesday. It was a frustrating experience and I'm back to considering stepping the power level up with these decks. I still have misgivings. Seems like every once in a while I get too many...
  7. Oversoul

    The Haunt of Discardtower [EDH]

    Only played this one once so far, and it went poorly. I had bad topdecks and one opponent had poor threat assessment, leading to my stuff getting targeted when there was a much bigger threat to deal with. I have further thoughts on that day as a whole, but this deck only got one game itself, and...
  8. Oversoul

    Wave Function Collapse [EDH]

    So I took this deck apart. My overall analysis is that it was OK and that I could certainly return to the concept again. I don't know whether I'll revisit any of my 2022 decks later this year, or just keep trying to churn out new decks instead. If I were to revisit them, this deck would be high...
  9. Oversoul

    The Haunt of Discardtower [EDH]

    Twenty years ago, I took apart my casual U/B Discard deck and replaced it with a mono-black Discard deck. I guess I've just repeated this feat. Now discard your hands. Commander 1 The Haunt of Hightower 1 Animate Dead 1 Anvil of Bogardan 1 Archfiend of Ifnir 1 Archon of Cruelty 1...
  10. Oversoul

    An Elephant Never Forgets [EDH]

    Put cards in graveyard. Take cards back out of graveyard. Get spirits. Kill opponents. Seems easy enough. Commander: 1 Quintorius, Field Historian 1 Academy Rector 1 Ao, the Dawn Sky 1 Argivian Find 1 Arid Mesa 1 Ashnod's Altar 1 Aura of Silence 1 Boreas Charger 1 Breath of Life 1 Cathartic...
  11. Oversoul

    Magic Memories: Karmic Guide

    Yep, its biggest spike in tournament usage would definitely have been in Flash decks. Karmic Guide has made other appearances in Legacy, to a lesser extent. The other big Legacy application was in Cephalid Breakfast decks. Flash was a much bigger deal over its short window, but Karmic Guide was...
  12. Oversoul

    Magic Memories: Karmic Guide

    When it comes to graveyard recursion, black and green are the two most prominent colors. But white has some excellent tools of its own. I've covered some green cards in this area. Black graveyard recursion and reanimation effects haven't really been a subject I've deliberately tackled in Magic...
  13. Oversoul

    Wave Function Collapse [EDH]

    I want to take another shot at this some day, but I need to give it time. For one thing, I see some elements of this deck that work well and others that do not. I don't really have a critical mass of ways to make my commander pay off, but I'm also running a few cards for Mishra synergies that I...
  14. Oversoul

    Doctor Claw [EDH]

    Haha, this deck is great. I'll have to pull parts from it at some point next month probably, but I am going to stall on that if possible. It's just a really fun deck.
  15. Oversoul

    Naming Cards, Destroying Nations [EDH]

    Nebuchadnezzar finally won a game, and now I can retire this deck. I had tentatively intended to run The Haunt of Hightower as one of the creatures here, but didn't find it because I forgot that it was a buy-a-box exclusive foil and not stored with my other cards from Ravnica Allegiance. Oops...
  16. Oversoul

    Wave Function Collapse [EDH]

    This is my Mishra Stax deck. It locks the game up with artifacts. It is pretty bad, but I will not be likely to refine it anytime soon. Oh well. It's a starting point if I change my mind. Commander: 1 Mishra, Artificer Prodigy 1 Academy Ruins 1 Arcane Laboratory 1 Arcane Signet 1 Badlands 1...
  17. Oversoul

    Magic Memories: Enduring Ideal

    Last August, I started regularly playing EDH on Wednesday nights at the LGS that opened up in my old hometown (it's just down the highway from where I live now). At that time, I had two long-term decks from 2019 that were still assembled and ready to play. "Epic" was one of them. So I got to do...
  18. Oversoul

    Naming Cards, Destroying Nations [EDH]

    I was a little worried that this deck would be underpowered. Well, it has yet to win a game, but it's made a pretty big splash every time, and I think a couple of my losses were just rotten luck. I hadn't used cards like Geth's Grimoire and Waste Not in a couple of years, and they are pretty great.
  19. Oversoul

    Doctor Claw [EDH]

    Played three games with this one. It's a little slow, but also packs more of a punch than I might have guessed. First game, I was getting force-fed poison counters by a player that had a Fynn, the Fangbearer deck. When I finally got some blockers out, another player wiped the board with...
  20. Oversoul

    Spikes, and Horns, and Tusks, Oh My! [EDH]

    After getting some more games in with this deck, I really like how explosive it can be, but I also see that I set it up to have a pretty narrow range of options sometimes. In my last game, my opponents couldn't kill Serra Ascendant before I started stacking +1/+1 counters on it, so I wiped the...
Top