I think he just scanned the list and saw the famous names and didn't fully read it.
Personally, I don't see what the big problem is with playing them, as it seems that just because they have looks and fame, they somehow have a strike against them. You want to play someone not-so-good looking and famous, like Courtney Love or something?
And it seems that because the people who have answered so far don't want to directlky answer the question, they put up female Magic players, which is fine and dandy although that should be another question altogether.
So I'll admit it: I put Jennifer Love Hewitt because she is sorta good-looking and looks like she has a level head on her shoulders, and she pretty much the best choice up there.