New Poison Mech

[Oversoul]

Metallic Anemone acting as an enchantment is weird, since it is colorless. But I guess that they already printed Transmogrifying Licid...

Now as far as Box Jelly, I'll try...

How about if its ability is worded like this...

TAP: Put a poison counter on attacking player. Use this ability only when an opponent is attacking you with at least one creature.

Or something like that...

 

[Captain Caveman]

Toxifera Dementia
GG
Enchant World

When Toxifera Dementia comes into, tap x target permanents.
Those permanents do not uptap as long as Toxifera Dementia
is in play. X is equal to the number of poison counters target
player has.

 

[Oversoul]

I don't know that it's powerful enough to weaken by making it an Enchant World...

Other than that, it's good...

 

[Istanbul]

I'd call it TOO powerful.

"Whoops, looks like you have eight poison counters. I think I'll permanently lock down EIGHT permanents for two green mana. You don't mind, do you?"

This needs something like Fading: 2 or something.

 

[Captain Caveman]

Is it strong or "I win more" card? If the cost was 2GG would it be
ok then. Does it need a re-done altogether?



Is it ok to add this to Toxic Venom?

You may play Toxic Venom any time you could play an instant
if you pay 2 more to play it.



EDIT:

Toxifera Dementia
GG
Enchantment
At the beginning of your upkeep sacrifice Toxifera Dementia.
When Toxifera Dementia comes into, tap x target permanents.
Those permanents do not uptap as long as Toxifera Dementia
is in play. X is equal to the number of poison counters target
player has.

 

[Oversoul]

Originally posted by Captain Caveman
EDIT:

Toxifera Dementia
GG
Enchantment
At the beginning of your upkeep sacrifice Toxifera Dementia.
When Toxifera Dementia comes into, tap x target permanents.
Those permanents do not uptap as long as Toxifera Dementia
is in play. X is equal to the number of poison counters target
player has.

Why would anyone ever use that? The other version was fine. If the opponent had so many poison counters, then you obviously had the advantage already, and this is used to finalize your victory or prevent an opponent from making a comeback. But it could also be used when you add counters to yourself. The new version is pretty much useless, since you limit it to a target player AND have the effect lasts only one turn...

 

[FoundationOfRancor]

Beat Knight
BB
Creature - Knight
First Strike, Fear
Whenever you have any poison counters, sacrifice Beat Knight.
2/2

Asps Antidote
2B
Sorcery
Target player loses two poison counters

Come to Terms
2R
Sorcery
Deal target player X damage, where X is equal to the number of poison counters that player has. Remove all poison counters from that player.
Draw a card.

Manic
2U
Instant
Draw a card for each poison counter you have.

Yellow Asp
1G
Creature - Snake
Trample
Whenever Yellow Asp deals combat damage to a player, that player recieves a poison counter.
X is equal to the amount of poison counters all players have.
1+X/1

Switcharoo
3G
Instant
You and target player switch the amount of poison counters you each have.

Med Web
WW
Enchantment
When Med Web comes into play, remove all poison counters from all players and put them on Med Web
When Med Web leaves play, return all poison counters to their owners.

Toxic Link
2G
Enchantment
2: All players recieve a poison counter

Mad Max
B
Creature -
Whenever Mad Max deals damage, target player loses a poison counter.
1/1

Sting Fire
4RR
Sorcery
Until end of turn, whenever you would deal damage to a player, instead give them a poison counter for each damage dealt.

Complexity
2W
Enchantment
Remove a poison counter from target player: your opponent gains 5 life.
Remove a poison counter from target opponent: Gain 5 life

Two-Headed Viper
1GG
Creature - Snake
Whenever Two-Headed Viper deals combat damage to a player, that player receives two poison counters.
2/2

Beacon of Casey
3WW
Instant
Target player receives 5 poison counters, their life total is reset to 20.

 

[Oversoul]

Switcharoo would be far too broken...

Sting Fire does nothing the way it is worded now...

Edit: Oh, and Beat Knight is too good probably...