Well, usually when something unexpected happens like that, you say wait, back up, during your attacker's step, I'm casting Turnabout. When we start expecting possible responses to spells, we start saying Pass priority.
Yeah, that sucked big time. I'm hoping to draw some
Untap, Draw, Mt, Yotian Soldier, Done even if you use the Replica.
Mikeymike: 20
Mana: Mountain (T), 2x Island (T, U), U/B Talisman (T)
Permanents: Bonesplitter (Equip 1: +2/+0), Wizard Replica (1/3, flying, U, sac this: counter spell unless controller pays 2)
Graveyard: Nada
RFG: My dignity
Cards in Hand: 4
Spidey: 20
Mana: Plains(T), Mtx2(all T)
Permanents: Atog (1/2, sac an artifact: +2/+2 EOT), Yotian Soldier (1/4, does not tap when attacking)?
Graveyard:
RFG:
Cards In Hand: 5