Commander: Mooseman v SealTeamBill v Oversoul

U,U gain 2 life, D
island
Crawl space - Artifact no more than two creatures can't attack you each turn
Wall of Reverence
End step gain 4 life off the Phyrexian Gargantua
DONE

Mooseman: 38
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 4
Library: 78
Command Zone (0): 2URW Sevinne, the Chronoclasm (URW) (Human Wizard, 2/2, Prevent all damage that would be dealt to Sevinne, the Chronoclasm. Whenever you cast your first instant or sorcery spell from your graveyard each turn, copy that spell. You may choose new targets for the copy)
Battlefield:

(T) Plains
(U) Island
(T) Mountain
(T) Azorius Chancery (L, ETB tapped.When ~ ETB, return a land you control to its owner's hand. T: Add WU to your mana pool.)
(U) Wind-Scarred Crag (L, ETB tapped. When ~ ETB, you gain 1 life.Tap: Add R or W.)
(T) Izzet Guildgate (Gate, L, ETB Tapped. T: U or R)
(U) Boros Garrison (, L, ETB Tapped. When~ ETB, return a land you control to its owner's hand.T: Add RW to your mana pool.)
(T) Sol Ring (, A, T:2)
(T) Commander's Sphere (, A, {T}: Add to your mana pool one mana of any color in your commander's color identity.
Sacrifice Commander's Sphere: Draw a card.)

(U) Talrand, Sky Summoner (LC Merfolk Wizard, 2/2, Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 2/2 blue Drake creature token with flying.)
(S) Drake Token (U) (2/2, Flying)
(S) Ramses Overdark (UB Legendary Creature — Human Assassin) (4/3; T: Destroy target enchanted creature.) ~Clever Impersonator~

Graveyard: Sevinne's Reclamation, Increasing Devotion, Increasing Vengeance, Divine Reckoning, Mass Diminish
Exile:

===================================================================================

SealTeamBill: 60
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 4
Library: 77
Command Zone (0): 3WUB Oloro, Ageless Ascetic (WUB) ( legendary creature - Giant Soldier; 4/5. At the beginning of your upkeep you gain two life. Whenever you gain life, you may pay (1) if you do, draw a card and each opponent loses one life.
At the beginning of your upkeep, if Oloro, Ageless Ascetic is in your commander Zone you gain two life.

Battlefield:
(TT) Island x2
(T) Swamp
(TTTT) Plains x4
(U) Orzhov Basilica (L, EBT tapped,- When ETB return a land you control to your hand. T: add WB to your mana pool.)
Darksteel Mutation (Enchant creature, Enchanted creature is a 0/1 insect artifact creature with indestructible and loses all other abilities.)

(U) Obelisk of Esper (Artifact)( T: add W, U, or B to your mana pool.)
(U) Tidehollow Strix (Artifact creature-Insect)(0/1)(indestructible)~ *Enchanted with Despondency.~ Darksteel Mutation
(U) Raven Familiar (U creature-bird)(1/2)(Flying, Echo paid...When Raven Familiar enters the battlefield, look at the top 3 cards of your library. Put one into your hand and the rest on the bottom in any order.)
(U) Augury Adept (WU Creature- Kithkin Wizard)(2/2)(whenever Augury Adept deals combat damage to a player, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. You gain life equal to its converted mana cost.)
(U) Phyrexian Gargantua (B)(4/4)
Crawl Space (No more than two creatures can attack you each combat.)
(S) Wall of Reverence (W)(1/6)(Defender; Flying. at the beginning of your end step you may gain life equal to the power of a Target creature you control.)

Graveyard: Marrow Bats, Dromar's Charm
Exile:

===================================================================================

Oversoul: 39
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 7
Library: 78
Command Zone (1): 2BBUU

Battlefield:

(T,U,U) Snow-Covered Island x3
(T,U,U,U) Snow-Covered Swamp x4

(U) Arcane Signet (T: adds one mana of any color in my commander's color identity to my mana pool.)

(T) Shadowmage Infiltrator (UB human wizard) (1/3; Fear. Whenever ~ deals combat damage to a player, I may draw a card.)
(U) Ramses Overdark (UB Legendary Creature — Human Assassin) (4/3; T: Destroy target enchanted creature.)
(S) Stinging Licid (U licid) (1/1; 1U, T: ~ loses this ability and become an aura enchanting a creature. I may pay U to end this effect. Whenever enchanted creature becomes tapped, ~ deals 2 damage to that creature's controller.)

Despondency (B aura) (Enchanted creature gets -2/-0. When ~ dies, return it to my hand.) *enchanting Tidehollow Strix.*

Graveyard: Arcane Denial, Knight of the Ebon Legion, River's Rebuke
Exile
 

Oversoul

The Tentacled One
End of turn, I'll flash in Minion's Return on Phyrexian Gargantua. I'll tap Ramses Overdark to destroy Phyrexian Gargantua. Responses?
 
Nice play, Minions Return goes to the graveyard, when Phyrexian Gargantua comes back into play, you lose two life and draw two cards.
Question: were do those minion cards go if either of us leave play?
 
Last edited:

Oversoul

The Tentacled One
If you leave the game, Phyrexian Gargantua leaves with you. If I leave the game while I control Phyrexian Gargantua, it goes into your exile zone.
 

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
"In a multiplayer game, if a player leaves the game, all cards that player owns leave as well. If you leave the game, the creature you control from Minion’s Return is exiled if you don’t own it. "
Can we keep the rules text on cards on the battlefield. I had to look up the Phyrexian Gargantua to see where the 2 life lose and card draw came from.
 

Oversoul

The Tentacled One
UUD, Arcane Lighthouse, Claws of Gix. I'll sac Despondency to the Claws, then replay Despondency on Augury Adept. I'll cast Launch on Raven Familiar. Done after that.

Mooseman: 38
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 4
Library: 78
Command Zone (0): 2URW Sevinne, the Chronoclasm (URW) (Human Wizard, 2/2, Prevent all damage that would be dealt to Sevinne, the Chronoclasm. Whenever you cast your first instant or sorcery spell from your graveyard each turn, copy that spell. You may choose new targets for the copy)
Battlefield:

(T) Plains
(U) Island
(T) Mountain
(T) Azorius Chancery (L, ETB tapped.When ~ ETB, return a land you control to its owner's hand. T: Add WU to your mana pool.)
(U) Wind-Scarred Crag (L, ETB tapped. When ~ ETB, you gain 1 life.Tap: Add R or W.)
(T) Izzet Guildgate (Gate, L, ETB Tapped. T: U or R)
(U) Boros Garrison (, L, ETB Tapped. When~ ETB, return a land you control to its owner's hand.T: Add RW to your mana pool.)
(T) Sol Ring (, A, T:2)
(T) Commander's Sphere (, A, {T}: Add to your mana pool one mana of any color in your commander's color identity.
Sacrifice Commander's Sphere: Draw a card.)

(U) Talrand, Sky Summoner (LC Merfolk Wizard, 2/2, Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 2/2 blue Drake creature token with flying.)
(S) Drake Token (U) (2/2, Flying)
(S) Ramses Overdark (UB Legendary Creature — Human Assassin) (4/3; T: Destroy target enchanted creature.) ~Clever Impersonator~

Graveyard: Sevinne's Reclamation, Increasing Devotion, Increasing Vengeance, Divine Reckoning, Mass Diminish
Exile:

===================================================================================

SealTeamBill: 60
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 4
Library: 77
Command Zone (0): 3WUB Oloro, Ageless Ascetic (WUB) ( legendary creature - Giant Soldier; 4/5. At the beginning of your upkeep you gain two life. Whenever you gain life, you may pay (1) if you do, draw a card and each opponent loses one life.
At the beginning of your upkeep, if Oloro, Ageless Ascetic is in your commander Zone you gain two life.

Battlefield:
(TT) Island x2
(T) Swamp
(TTTT) Plains x4
(U) Orzhov Basilica (L, EBT tapped,- When ETB return a land you control to your hand. T: add WB to your mana pool.)
Darksteel Mutation (Enchant creature, Enchanted creature is a 0/1 insect artifact creature with indestructible and loses all other abilities.)

(U) Obelisk of Esper (Artifact)( T: add W, U, or B to your mana pool.)
(U) Tidehollow Strix (Artifact creature-Insect)(0/1)(indestructible) ~ Darksteel Mutation
(U) Raven Familiar (U creature-bird)(1/2)(Flying, Echo paid...When Raven Familiar enters the battlefield, look at the top 3 cards of your library. Put one into your hand and the rest on the bottom in any order.) *Enchanted with Launch*
(U) Augury Adept (WU Creature- Kithkin Wizard)(0/2)(whenever Augury Adept deals combat damage to a player, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. You gain life equal to its converted mana cost.) *Enchanted with Despondency*
Crawl Space (No more than two creatures can attack you each combat.)
(S) Wall of Reverence (W)(1/6)(Defender; Flying. at the beginning of your end step you may gain life equal to the power of a Target creature you control.)

Graveyard: Marrow Bats, Dromar's Charm
Exile:

===================================================================================

Oversoul: 38
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 6
Library: 75
Command Zone (1): 2BBUU

Battlefield:

(T,U,U) Snow-Covered Island x3
(T,T,T,U) Snow-Covered Swamp x4
(T) Arcane Lighthouse (T: adds C to my mana pool. 1,T: ueot, creatures my opponents control lose hexproof and shroud and can't have hexproof or shroud.)

(U) Arcane Signet (T: adds one mana of any color in my commander's color identity to my mana pool.)
(U) Claws of Gix (1, sac a permanent: I gain 1 life.)

(U) Shadowmage Infiltrator (UB human wizard) (1/3; Fear. Whenever ~ deals combat damage to a player, I may draw a card.)
(U) Ramses Overdark (UB Legendary Creature — Human Assassin) (4/3; T: Destroy target enchanted creature.)
(U) Stinging Licid (U licid) (1/1; 1U, T: ~ loses this ability and become an aura enchanting a creature. I may pay U to end this effect. Whenever enchanted creature becomes tapped, ~ deals 2 damage to that creature's controller.)
(U) Phyrexian Gargantua (B horror) (4/4; When ~ etb, I draw 2 cards and lose 2 life.)

Despondency (B aura) (Enchanted creature gets -2/-0. When ~ dies, return it to my hand.) *enchanting Augury Adept.*
Launch (U aura) (Enchanted creature has flying. When ~ dies, return it to my hand.) *enchanting Raven Familiar*

Graveyard: Arcane Denial, Knight of the Ebon Legion, River's Rebuke, Minion's Return
Exile:
 

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Everyone check you hand and Library totals.

Okay R u ready, you know it's coming.
UUD
Stone Quarry
Runic Repetition targeting Divine Reckoning
Responses?

Mooseman: 38
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 3
Library: 77
Command Zone (0): 2URW Sevinne, the Chronoclasm (URW) (Human Wizard, 2/2, Prevent all damage that would be dealt to Sevinne, the Chronoclasm. Whenever you cast your first instant or sorcery spell from your graveyard each turn, copy that spell. You may choose new targets for the copy)
Battlefield:

(T) Plains
(U) Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Azorius Chancery (L, ETB tapped.When ~ ETB, return a land you control to its owner's hand. T: Add WU to your mana pool.)
(U) Wind-Scarred Crag (L, ETB tapped. When ~ ETB, you gain 1 life.Tap: Add R or W.)
(U) Izzet Guildgate (Gate, L, ETB Tapped. T: U or R)
(U) Boros Garrison (, L, ETB Tapped. When~ ETB, return a land you control to its owner's hand.T: Add RW to your mana pool.)
(T) Sol Ring (, A, T:2)
(U) Commander's Sphere (, A, {T}: Add to your mana pool one mana of any color in your commander's color identity.
Sacrifice Commander's Sphere: Draw a card.)
(T) Stone Quarry (, L, ETB tapped. T:R or W)

(U) Talrand, Sky Summoner (LC Merfolk Wizard, 2/2, Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 2/2 blue Drake creature token with flying.)
(S) Drake Token (U) (2/2, Flying)
(S) Ramses Overdark (UB Legendary Creature — Human Assassin) (4/3; T: Destroy target enchanted creature.) ~Clever Impersonator~

Graveyard: Sevinne's Reclamation, Increasing Devotion, Increasing Vengeance, Divine Reckoning, Mass Diminish, Divine Reckoning
Exile:

===================================================================================

SealTeamBill: 60
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 4
Library: 77
Command Zone (0): 3WUB Oloro, Ageless Ascetic (WUB) ( legendary creature - Giant Soldier; 4/5. At the beginning of your upkeep you gain two life. Whenever you gain life, you may pay (1) if you do, draw a card and each opponent loses one life.
At the beginning of your upkeep, if Oloro, Ageless Ascetic is in your commander Zone you gain two life.

Battlefield:
(TT) Island x2
(T) Swamp
(TTTT) Plains x4
(U) Orzhov Basilica (L, EBT tapped,- When ETB return a land you control to your hand. T: add WB to your mana pool.)
Darksteel Mutation (Enchant creature, Enchanted creature is a 0/1 insect artifact creature with indestructible and loses all other abilities.)

(U) Obelisk of Esper (Artifact)( T: add W, U, or B to your mana pool.)
(U) Tidehollow Strix (Artifact creature-Insect)(0/1)(indestructible) ~ Darksteel Mutation
(U) Raven Familiar (U creature-bird)(1/2)(Flying, Echo paid...When Raven Familiar enters the battlefield, look at the top 3 cards of your library. Put one into your hand and the rest on the bottom in any order.) *Enchanted with Launch*
(U) Augury Adept (WU Creature- Kithkin Wizard)(0/2)(whenever Augury Adept deals combat damage to a player, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. You gain life equal to its converted mana cost.) *Enchanted with Despondency*
Crawl Space (No more than two creatures can attack you each combat.)
(S) Wall of Reverence (W)(1/6)(Defender; Flying. at the beginning of your end step you may gain life equal to the power of a Target creature you control.)

Graveyard: Marrow Bats, Dromar's Charm
Exile:

===================================================================================

Oversoul: 38
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 6
Library: 75
Command Zone (1): 2BBUU

Battlefield:

(T,U,U) Snow-Covered Island x3
(T,T,T,U) Snow-Covered Swamp x4
(T) Arcane Lighthouse (T: adds C to my mana pool. 1,T: ueot, creatures my opponents control lose hexproof and shroud and can't have hexproof or shroud.)

(U) Arcane Signet (T: adds one mana of any color in my commander's color identity to my mana pool.)
(U) Claws of Gix (1, sac a permanent: I gain 1 life.)

(U) Shadowmage Infiltrator (UB human wizard) (1/3; Fear. Whenever ~ deals combat damage to a player, I may draw a card.)
(U) Ramses Overdark (UB Legendary Creature — Human Assassin) (4/3; T: Destroy target enchanted creature.)
(U) Stinging Licid (U licid) (1/1; 1U, T: ~ loses this ability and become an aura enchanting a creature. I may pay U to end this effect. Whenever enchanted creature becomes tapped, ~ deals 2 damage to that creature's controller.)
(U) Phyrexian Gargantua (B horror) (4/4; When ~ etb, I draw 2 cards and lose 2 life.)

Despondency (B aura) (Enchanted creature gets -2/-0. When ~ dies, return it to my hand.) *enchanting Augury Adept.*
Launch (U aura) (Enchanted creature has flying. When ~ dies, return it to my hand.) *enchanting Raven Familiar*

Graveyard: Arcane Denial, Knight of the Ebon Legion, River's Rebuke, Minion's Return
Exile:
 
let me see if I understand the mechanics of this... you cast runic reputation 2+U, that returns Divine Reckoning back to your hand can you cast it for 2+WW? Then each player including yourself choose 1 creature to keep on the field and the rest are destroyed? Commander's go to the commander field? Because they can't go to your hand or the graveyard anymore? Everything else goes to the graveyard except for Despondency which goes back to "oversoul's" hand? then Divine Reckoning goes back into the graveyard and can be cast once again for 5+WW?
You still need to tap 2 + U...
 

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
let me see if I understand the mechanics of this... you cast runic reputation 2+U, that returns Divine Reckoning back to your hand can you cast it for 2+WW? Then each player including yourself choose 1 creature to keep on the field and the rest are destroyed? Commander's go to the commander field? Because they can't go to your hand or the graveyard anymore? Everything else goes to the graveyard except for Despondency which goes back to "oversoul's" hand? then Divine Reckoning goes back into the graveyard and can be cast once again for 5+WW?
You still need to tap 2 + U...
It should be the Island not the plains tapped. The Sol Ring gives me the other 2.
Yes I can cast the returned card for 2WW. Commanders always get the replacement effect of may go to the command zone if the player so chooses.
Yes Despondency will go back to his hand.
 
Oh my that changes everything Oversoul. Nice call.
That means Mooseman has to cast Divine Reckoning for 5+WW and then Runic Repetition at another time to retrieve it from exile??
 
Last edited:

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Read the F'ng Card.... the 1st rule of judging.... and I missed it
I'll flash it back then.
Response?

Mooseman: 38
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 4
Library: 77
Command Zone (0): 2URW Sevinne, the Chronoclasm (URW) (Human Wizard, 2/2, Prevent all damage that would be dealt to Sevinne, the Chronoclasm. Whenever you cast your first instant or sorcery spell from your graveyard each turn, copy that spell. You may choose new targets for the copy)
Battlefield:

(T) Plains
(U) Island
(T) Mountain
(T) Azorius Chancery (L, ETB tapped.When ~ ETB, return a land you control to its owner's hand. T: Add WU to your mana pool.)
(U) Wind-Scarred Crag (L, ETB tapped. When ~ ETB, you gain 1 life.Tap: Add R or W.)
(T) Izzet Guildgate (Gate, L, ETB Tapped. T: U or R)
(U) Boros Garrison (, L, ETB Tapped. When~ ETB, return a land you control to its owner's hand.T: Add RW to your mana pool.)
(T) Sol Ring (, A, T:2)
(U) Commander's Sphere (, A, {T}: Add to your mana pool one mana of any color in your commander's color identity.
Sacrifice Commander's Sphere: Draw a card.)
(T) Stone Quarry (, L, ETB tapped. T:R or W)

(U) Talrand, Sky Summoner (LC Merfolk Wizard, 2/2, Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 2/2 blue Drake creature token with flying.)
(S) Drake Token (U) (2/2, Flying)
(S) Ramses Overdark (UB Legendary Creature — Human Assassin) (4/3; T: Destroy target enchanted creature.) ~Clever Impersonator~

Graveyard: Sevinne's Reclamation, Increasing Devotion, Increasing Vengeance, Divine Reckoning, Mass Diminish, Divine Reckoning
Exile:

===================================================================================

SealTeamBill: 60
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 4
Library: 77
Command Zone (0): 3WUB Oloro, Ageless Ascetic (WUB) ( legendary creature - Giant Soldier; 4/5. At the beginning of your upkeep you gain two life. Whenever you gain life, you may pay (1) if you do, draw a card and each opponent loses one life.
At the beginning of your upkeep, if Oloro, Ageless Ascetic is in your commander Zone you gain two life.

Battlefield:
(TT) Island x2
(T) Swamp
(TTTT) Plains x4
(U) Orzhov Basilica (L, EBT tapped,- When ETB return a land you control to your hand. T: add WB to your mana pool.)
Darksteel Mutation (Enchant creature, Enchanted creature is a 0/1 insect artifact creature with indestructible and loses all other abilities.)

(U) Obelisk of Esper (Artifact)( T: add W, U, or B to your mana pool.)
(U) Tidehollow Strix (Artifact creature-Insect)(0/1)(indestructible) ~ Darksteel Mutation
(U) Raven Familiar (U creature-bird)(1/2)(Flying, Echo paid...When Raven Familiar enters the battlefield, look at the top 3 cards of your library. Put one into your hand and the rest on the bottom in any order.) *Enchanted with Launch*
(U) Augury Adept (WU Creature- Kithkin Wizard)(0/2)(whenever Augury Adept deals combat damage to a player, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. You gain life equal to its converted mana cost.) *Enchanted with Despondency*
Crawl Space (No more than two creatures can attack you each combat.)
(S) Wall of Reverence (W)(1/6)(Defender; Flying. at the beginning of your end step you may gain life equal to the power of a Target creature you control.)

Graveyard: Marrow Bats, Dromar's Charm
Exile:

===================================================================================

Oversoul: 38
Dmg from commander: 0/21
Hand: 6
Library: 75
Command Zone (1): 2BBUU

Battlefield:

(T,U,U) Snow-Covered Island x3
(T,T,T,U) Snow-Covered Swamp x4
(T) Arcane Lighthouse (T: adds C to my mana pool. 1,T: ueot, creatures my opponents control lose hexproof and shroud and can't have hexproof or shroud.)

(U) Arcane Signet (T: adds one mana of any color in my commander's color identity to my mana pool.)
(U) Claws of Gix (1, sac a permanent: I gain 1 life.)

(U) Shadowmage Infiltrator (UB human wizard) (1/3; Fear. Whenever ~ deals combat damage to a player, I may draw a card.)
(U) Ramses Overdark (UB Legendary Creature — Human Assassin) (4/3; T: Destroy target enchanted creature.)
(U) Stinging Licid (U licid) (1/1; 1U, T: ~ loses this ability and become an aura enchanting a creature. I may pay U to end this effect. Whenever enchanted creature becomes tapped, ~ deals 2 damage to that creature's controller.)
(U) Phyrexian Gargantua (B horror) (4/4; When ~ etb, I draw 2 cards and lose 2 life.)

Despondency (B aura) (Enchanted creature gets -2/-0. When ~ dies, return it to my hand.) *enchanting Augury Adept.*
Launch (U aura) (Enchanted creature has flying. When ~ dies, return it to my hand.) *enchanting Raven Familiar*

Graveyard: Arcane Denial, Knight of the Ebon Legion, River's Rebuke, Minion's Return
Exile:
 

Oversoul

The Tentacled One
I remain surprised that you'd boardwipe now, but I guess I'll roll with it. In response to the Divine Reckoning, I'll activate Stinging Licid, enchanting Mooseman's Clever Impersonator (which is copying my Ramses Overdark).
 
My guess you're going to do it more than one time. No response until it resolves.
OVERSOUL@ despondency will go to your hand if I choose let Augury die? Hmmm
 
Last edited:

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
No response. Just so I'm clear, after my spell resolves, state based effects will put any Aura's not enchanting anything in to the GY. Then Despondency's effect will trigger to return it to Oversoul's hand.
 
I will retain Wall of Reverence. Tidehollow Strix was turned into a 0/1 Insect Artifact with Indestructible, so it remains until the Aura is destroyed.
Raven Familiar and Augury Adept go to thr GY and despondency goes back to Oversoul's hand.
 

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Despondency will not return to Oversoul's hand until the spell resolves, state based effects are resolved and the Despondency trigger resolves.
I of course choose the sky summoner.
 
Top