B
BigBlue
Guest
What? I have to play it... And I have to pull the counter... 
I'm not surprised by it...
Done.
I'm not surprised by it...
Done.
BYOS, Round 1: DarthFerret vs BigBlue
- Thread starter Spiderman
- Start date
D
DarthFerret
Guest
UUD, Island, done.
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 50
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 6
Library: 49
Play:
(T) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(T) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(T) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(T) Forest
GY:
RFG:Nevinyrral's Disk
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 50
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 6
Library: 49
Play:
(T) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(T) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(T) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(T) Forest
GY:
RFG:Nevinyrral's Disk
B
BigBlue
Guest
UUD
Underground Sea
Done.
(Wouldn't you like it if it was RfG instead of GY...)
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 50
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 6
Library: 49
Play:
(U) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(U) Forest
GY: Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
Underground Sea
Done.
(Wouldn't you like it if it was RfG instead of GY...)
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 50
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 6
Library: 49
Play:
(U) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(U) Forest
GY: Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
D
DarthFerret
Guest
But of course...
UUD, Karma, done.
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 49
Play:
(T,U) Tundra
(T,T) Plains
(T) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
Enchant: Karma (on opponent's upkeep ~ deals 1 damage to him for each Swamp in play
GY: Counterspell
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 6
Library: 49
Play:
(U) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(U) Forest
GY: Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
UUD, Karma, done.
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 49
Play:
(T,U) Tundra
(T,T) Plains
(T) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
Enchant: Karma (on opponent's upkeep ~ deals 1 damage to him for each Swamp in play
GY: Counterspell
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 6
Library: 49
Play:
(U) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(U) Forest
GY: Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
B
BigBlue
Guest
Counter it w/ Mystic Snake
UU Draw
Attack w/ Snake (assume you pay)
Play Bayou
Play Regrowth on Disk
Play Disk
Done.
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 49
Play:
(T,T) Tundra
(T,T) Plains
(T) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
Enchant: Karma (on opponent's upkeep ~ deals 1 damage to him for each Swamp in play (Countered?)
GY: Counterspell, Karma
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 4
Library: 48
Play:
(T) Nevinyrral's Disk (1,T: Destroy all Enchantments, Artifacts, and Creatures)
(TT) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(T) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(TT) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(T) Forest
(T) Mystic Snake (2/2; Flash; When ~ cip, I may counter target spell)
GY: Regrowth
RFG:
UU Draw
Attack w/ Snake (assume you pay)
Play Bayou
Play Regrowth on Disk
Play Disk
Done.
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 49
Play:
(T,T) Tundra
(T,T) Plains
(T) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
Enchant: Karma (on opponent's upkeep ~ deals 1 damage to him for each Swamp in play (Countered?)
GY: Counterspell, Karma
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 4
Library: 48
Play:
(T) Nevinyrral's Disk (1,T: Destroy all Enchantments, Artifacts, and Creatures)
(TT) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(T) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(TT) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(T) Forest
(T) Mystic Snake (2/2; Flash; When ~ cip, I may counter target spell)
GY: Regrowth
RFG:
D
DarthFerret
Guest
UUD, Done.
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 3
Library: 48
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
Enchant: Karma (on opponent's upkeep ~ deals 1 damage to him for each Swamp in play (Countered?)
GY: Counterspell, Karma
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 4
Library: 48
Play:
(T) Nevinyrral's Disk (1,T: Destroy all Enchantments, Artifacts, and Creatures)
(TT) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(T) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(TT) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(T) Forest
(T) Mystic Snake (2/2; Flash; When ~ cip, I may counter target spell)
GY: Regrowth
RFG:
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 3
Library: 48
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U) Island
Enchant: CoP: Green (1, prevent damage from a green source)
Enchant: CoP: Black (1, Prevent damage from a black source)
Enchant: Warmth (When opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
Enchant: Karma (on opponent's upkeep ~ deals 1 damage to him for each Swamp in play (Countered?)
GY: Counterspell, Karma
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 4
Library: 48
Play:
(T) Nevinyrral's Disk (1,T: Destroy all Enchantments, Artifacts, and Creatures)
(TT) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(T) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(TT) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(T) Forest
(T) Mystic Snake (2/2; Flash; When ~ cip, I may counter target spell)
GY: Regrowth
RFG:
B
BigBlue
Guest
UU - Activate Disk
Responses?
EDIT - my Hand size was 3 pre this turn... I thought it looked off..
Responses?
EDIT - my Hand size was 3 pre this turn... I thought it looked off..
D
DarthFerret
Guest
No responses....grrr...
B
BigBlue
Guest
Draw (for whatever reason I was forgetting I'd countered Karma didn't have to be during upkeep...)
Play Forest
Play Dauthi Horror
Done.
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 3
Library: 48
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U) Island
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 47
Play:
(TU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TT) Forest
(S) Dauthi Horror (2/1; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
Play Forest
Play Dauthi Horror
Done.
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 3
Library: 48
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U) Island
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 47
Play:
(TU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TT) Forest
(S) Dauthi Horror (2/1; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
D
DarthFerret
Guest
UUD, Island, Done.
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 3
Library: 47
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U,U) Island
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 47
Play:
(TU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TT) Forest
(S) Dauthi Horror (2/1; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
DarthFerret: 20
Hand: 3
Library: 47
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U,U) Island
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 47
Play:
(TU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TT) Forest
(S) Dauthi Horror (2/1; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
B
BigBlue
Guest
What, No circle?
UUD
Swing for 2 w/ the horror
Play Underground Sea
Done.
DarthFerret: 20 18?
Hand: 3
Library: 47
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U,U) Island
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 46
Play:
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UUU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(UU) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (2/1; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
UUD
Swing for 2 w/ the horror
Play Underground Sea
Done.
DarthFerret: 20 18?
Hand: 3
Library: 47
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(U,U) Island
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 46
Play:
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UUU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(UU) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (2/1; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
D
DarthFerret
Guest
UUD, Warmth, done.
DarthFerret: 20 18?
Hand: 3
Library: 46
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(T,T) Island
Enchant: Warmth (When an opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 46
Play:
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UUU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(UU) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (2/1; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
DarthFerret: 20 18?
Hand: 3
Library: 46
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(T,T) Island
Enchant: Warmth (When an opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 46
Play:
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UUU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(UU) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (2/1; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
B
BigBlue
Guest
UUD
Play Rancor on Horror
Attack for 4
Done.
DarthFerret: 18 14?
Hand: 3
Library: 46
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(T,T) Island
Enchant: Warmth (When an opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 45
Play:
(Ench) Rancor (Ench creature gains +2/+0 and trample. If ~ goes to a gy from play, it goes to my hand instead) On Horror
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UUU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TU) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (4/1;Trample; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures) ~ Rancored
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
Play Rancor on Horror
Attack for 4
Done.
DarthFerret: 18 14?
Hand: 3
Library: 46
Play:
(U,U) Tundra
(U,U) Plains
(T,T) Island
Enchant: Warmth (When an opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 45
Play:
(Ench) Rancor (Ench creature gains +2/+0 and trample. If ~ goes to a gy from play, it goes to my hand instead) On Horror
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(UUU) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TU) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (4/1;Trample; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures) ~ Rancored
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
D
DarthFerret
Guest
In response to playing your Rancor, snap the horror back to your hand (rancor goes to gy for lack of target right?)
B
BigBlue
Guest
Play Mystic Snake in response to Snap. (which means you won't get to untap your lands)
If no responses, attack for 4, Done.
DarthFerret: 18 14?
Hand: 2
Library: 46
Play:
(T,U) Tundra
(T,U) Plains
(T,T) Island
Enchant: Warmth (When an opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth, Snap
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 1
Library: 45
Play:
(Ench) Rancor (Ench creature gains +2/+0 and trample. If ~ goes to a gy from play, it goes to my hand instead) On Horror
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(TTT) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TT) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (4/1;Trample; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures) ~ Rancored
(S) Mystic Snake (2/2; Flash; When ~ cip, I may counter target spell)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
If no responses, attack for 4, Done.
DarthFerret: 18 14?
Hand: 2
Library: 46
Play:
(T,U) Tundra
(T,U) Plains
(T,T) Island
Enchant: Warmth (When an opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth, Snap
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 1
Library: 45
Play:
(Ench) Rancor (Ench creature gains +2/+0 and trample. If ~ goes to a gy from play, it goes to my hand instead) On Horror
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(TTT) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TT) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (4/1;Trample; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures) ~ Rancored
(S) Mystic Snake (2/2; Flash; When ~ cip, I may counter target spell)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
D
DarthFerret
Guest
Sheesh, UUD, Island (finally) Tap out to Play a Volcanic Erruption, Use Spectral Shift to change it to Swamp, and target your two Bayous. Responses? (Creatures take 2, we take 2, and your lose both the Bayous...)
DarthFerret: 14
Hand: 0
Library: 45
Play:
(T,T) Tundra
(T,T) Plains
(T,T,T) Island
Enchant: Warmth (When an opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth, Snap
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 1
Library: 45
Play:
(Ench) Rancor (Ench creature gains +2/+0 and trample. If ~ goes to a gy from play, it goes to my hand instead) On Horror
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(TTT) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TT) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (4/1;Trample; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures) ~ Rancored
(S) Mystic Snake (2/2; Flash; When ~ cip, I may counter target spell)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
DarthFerret: 14
Hand: 0
Library: 45
Play:
(T,T) Tundra
(T,T) Plains
(T,T,T) Island
Enchant: Warmth (When an opponent plays a red spell, I gain 2 life)
GY: Counterspell, Karma, CoP: Green, CoP: Black, Warmth, Snap
RFG:
--------------------------------------
BigBlue: 20
Hand: 1
Library: 45
Play:
(Ench) Rancor (Ench creature gains +2/+0 and trample. If ~ goes to a gy from play, it goes to my hand instead) On Horror
(UU) Bayou (T: G or B; Swamp Forest)
(U) Tropical Island (T: U or G; Forest Island)
(TTT) Underground Sea (T: U or B; Island Swamp)
(TT) Forest
(T) Dauthi Horror (4/1;Trample; Shadow; Can't be blocked by white creatures) ~ Rancored
(S) Mystic Snake (2/2; Flash; When ~ cip, I may counter target spell)
GY: Regrowth, Mystic Snake, Nevinyrral's Disk
RFG:
B
BigBlue
Guest
Don't you have to have target mountains to play the eruption?
D
DarthFerret
Guest
Not if I use the Spectral Shift to change it to Swamps....
BigBlue also asked this in the Rules forum. We believe that for Volcanic Eruption to be initially cast, it has to target Mountains, since all targets have to be declared when casting a spell. Once the spell is on the stack, you can respond with Spectral Shift and change Mountains to Swamps, but the Eruption needs Mountains to be initially cast.