Keep in mind that this thread was one of the first ones to undergo "thread necromancy" in this particular spell of digging up old threads. I did it only because this thread was very old and I thought the content was funny.
The others are usually with a a bit more reason. The nuke deck one is a...
Not true...
Vintage has a few good decks with first turn kill potential. It is not decided by coin toss. Most of the best decks are control decks anyway, with only the most finely tuned and well piloted combo decks actually pulling off those insanely fast kills.
Other formats have decks that...
At this point, I think that the top 25 for each category would suit my purposes. I've already trimmed black a bit thanks to DÛke, but I've still got quite a bit more cutting to do. Artifacts could use some more suggestions still.
If you have any suggestions that you think deserve to be in the...
The Republic of Cascadia website is pretty funny. I don't still have the address, but I could find it again. I guess it wouldn't be as cool to all of you living outside of Cascadia (Washington, Oregon, and British Columbia).
I don't have so many in the red category, so I'm going to get to that one and add some of your suggestions...
Edit: Dwarven Pony? You misunderstand. I'm trying to make this thing completely serious. Okay, I'll get rid of Saprazzan Heir, just to avoid being too much of a hypocrite. :( It's just...
It's no Scroll Rack, but some decks only use Scroll Rack for very limited purposes, rather than with large amounts of cards. It is here that the Divining Top could shine casually...
IF the deck had Mogg Maniac, something like Blazing Effigy would be considerably better, but it doesn't...
Incinerate does have a nice advantage of Chain Lightning (especially against River Boa or Masticore). But early game it is a lot less appealing to cast it...