Vote for Lands

Discussion in 'CPA Voting Forum' started by Killer Joe, May 16, 2000.

  1. Killer Joe Active Member

    Do you like non-basic lands?
    Do you hate some of the non-basic lands that Wiz Co. has produced?
    Would you like to see some of the classic non-basic lands come back or added to 7th. Edition?
    Well, I can't help you, but you might take some comfort in voting on this topic:

    1.) List the top three of your favorite non-basic lands.

    2.) List the top three of your LEAST favorite non-basic lands.

    3.) And finally, list three non-basic lands you would like to see return or added to the next basic set (7th Ed.).

    my list:
    Favorite non-basic lands:
    City of Brass
    Undiscovered Paradise
    Reflecting Pool

    Least favorite non-basic lands:
    Rainbow Vale
    Ancient Tomb
    Teferi's Isle

    7th edition:
    City of Brass
    Gemstone Mine
    ALL 10 of the Tempest 2 color producing lands.
  2. Spiderman CPA Man in Tights, Dopey Administrative Assistant

    Tag Guard

    1) City of Brass
    Gemstone Mine
    Thawing Glaciers

    2) hard to say, maybe the depletion lands

    3) don't know; have no idea what's in 6th right now without checking, so I guess my favorites from above
  3. Istanbul Sucker MCs call me sire.

    1) Favorite non-basic lands:
    Yavimaya Hollow
    Soldevi Excavations
    FE Sac-Lands

    2) Least favorite non-basic lands:
    Homelands tri-color lands
    Urza's Lands
    Teferi's Isle

    3) NBLs I want to see in 7th:
    Yavimaya Hollow
    FE Sac-Lands
    The Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale (Rebels? Stompy? Where?)
  4. Apollo Bird Boy

    fav- City of Brass, Thawing Glaciers, and Taiga

    least fav- hrm, Storage Lands and really the tri-lands... shudder

    In general, I love the non-basics, but there's a lot of useless stuff they printed.

    Apollo
  5. TomB Administrative Assistant

    Favorites:
    Painless Duals
    Maze of Ith
    Mishra's Workshop

    Least Favorites:
    Another vote for the trylands
    The Ice Age depletion lands
    Glacial Chasm

    7th?
    Well, if I can't have my painless duals back, I'll vote for the Tempest cross-color duals to go with the Ice Age allied colors painlands.
    Thawing Glaciers
    Gemstone Mine

    There ya' go!
  6. Child of Gaea Phantom CPA Founder

    Favorites would be:
    Original Incredibly Brutal Duals!
    Thawing Glaciers
    Reflecting Pool

    Least Favorite would be:
    Storage Lands
    TRI LANDS! BLEH!
    Sorrows Path

    I cant believe no one has mentioned Gaea's Cradle yet!

    Child
  7. Multani Treetrunk Guy

    Tag Guard

    Fav Lands:
    Creature Lands from UL
  8. Apollo Bird Boy

    Child of Gaea? CPA founder? I don't think I've even seen hime post before recently. Was he away for awhile and came back or something? This is making my head hurt.

    Apollo
  9. Child of Gaea Phantom CPA Founder

    For quite awhile I have not been able to post due to a compatibility with webtv problem :( Before the new boards I have been one of the busiest people alive... Working 150 hours every 2 weeks.. Now I have more time on my hands for the important things such as Magic... And yes, I have not posted since the last century or so LOL
  10. Captain Caveman New Member

    1.) Gemstone Mine
    Soldevi Excavations (known as the TV Guide in my old
    play group)
    Maze of Ith

    2.) Teferi's Isle
    Ice Age depletion lands
    Sorrows Path

    3.) Wasteland
    Gemstone Mine
    Manlands from UL
  11. Seeker of Truth New Member

    1) Gaea's Cradle
    Treetop Village
    Karplusan Forest (!)

    2) Homelands triple lands
    Crystal Vein
    Blasted Landscape

    3) Gemstone Mine
    Urza's Saga Legendary Lands (including the Academy,
    but keep the "free" spells and creatures out)
    Urza's Legacy Animated Lands
  12. Spaceman Spiff New Member

    fav lands) masques depletion lands
    dual lands (taiga, savannah, etc)
    treetop village

    least fav lands) tri lands (again)
    ice age depletion lands
    raths edge

    land wanted to be reprinted) the legends lands (urborg, hammerhiem, etc.)
    dual lands (bayou, badlands, etc.)
    reflecting pool



    hope they DO get reprinted.
  13. Ura Feline Lord of the Pit

    Lets see

    Fav lands:
    1) Dual lands
    2) Reflecting Pool
    3) Gemstone Mine
    Thawing Glaciers, Maze of ith and Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale are all runners up

    Least fav lands:
    1) Ice Age depletion lands,
    2) Homelands Try-lands
    3) Rath's edge (its does what to who for how much!?! :eek: )

    Like to see in 7th ed:
    1) Gemstone Mine
    2) Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale (good bye critter beatdown)
    3) Reflecting Pool
    Dual lands should be #1 in this one, but I know it'll never happen. :D

    [Edited by Ura on May 19th, 2000 at 02:31 AM]

    [Edited by Ura on May 19th, 2000 at 02:33 AM]
  14. Chaos Turtle Demiurgic CPA Member, Admin Assistant

    note: the name in parentheses are my favorites in a group

    1) I dig

    Dual Lands (Bayou)
    Mega-mana lands (Gaea's Cradle)
    Alliances non-basics (Soldevi Excavations*)

    2) I do not dig

    Triple Lands from Homelands
    Bounce Lands from Visions
    Depletion Lands from Ice Age

    3) I'd like to see (not including the ones in Classic that I assume will be reprinted anyway)

    Gemstone Mine
    Reflecting Pool
    off-color Pain Lands from Tempest
  15. Spaceman Spiff New Member

  16. Gizmo Composite: 1860

    Fave
    1. City Of Brass
    2. Wasteland
    3. Thawing Glaciers

    All three should be in 7th Edition, IMHO.

    Un-Fave
    1. Sorrow`s Path (has to take the #1 slot)
    2. Teferi`s Isle (like an Island, but worse)
    3. Tolarian Academy (No, really? - in the set that untaps land for fun? Doh!)

    7th Edition
    (See above)
  17. arhar Member

    Favorite

    1) Island of Wak Wak
    2) Diamond Valley
    3) Urborg


    Least favorite

    1) RISHADAN PORT ( I HAAAAAATE this card)
    2) Tolarian Academy - have to agree with Gizmo
    3) Gaea's Cradle - totally broken

    Reprinted in 6th:

    See above for favorites
  18. garfobosonfire New Member

    Favorite
    City of Brass
    Thran Quarry
    Pendalhaven(dont ask why)

    Least FAvorite
    Rishadan Port
    Dust Bowl
    Tolarian Acadsemy

    7th
    Raths Edge
    City of Brass
    Brushland

Share This Page