Top Five Planeshift

L

Landkiller

Guest
Vote for your favorite five Planeshift cards!

1. Terminate
2. Orim's Chant
3. Hull Breach
4. Cloud Cover
5. Shivan Wurm
 
D

Daggertooth

Guest
1) terminate
2) gaea's might
3) Stormscape Battlemage
4) Sunscape Battlemage
5) Silver Drake

I've used all these in limited tournys. I know there are better cards, but these are my favorite.


Daggertooth.
 

Ransac

CPA Trash Man
My top five:

1:phyrexian Scuta(better than Juzam)
2:Meddling Mage
3:Orim's Chant
4:Doomsday Specter
5:Shivan Wurm


Ransac, cpa trash man
 
O

olwen

Guest
My top five is:

1. Terminate
2. Flametongue Kavu
3. Lashknife Barrier
4. Confound
5. Mana Cylix
 
B

Baskil

Guest
Mine are:

1 Orim's Chant
2 Flametongue Kavu
3 Rushing River
4 Terminate
5 Planar Overlay
 
C

Cateran Emperor

Guest
1. Rushing River
2. Meddling Mage
3. Terminate
4. Lord of the Undead
5. Flametongue Kavu

Special Awards go to Lava Zombie, for the hilarious little goblin that's entering the planar gate, and Mogg Sentry's flavor text.
 
N

NeuroDeus

Guest
1. Meddling Mage
2. Terminate
3. Warped Devotion
4. Orim's Chant
5. Phyrexian Scuta
 
Z

Zadok001

Guest
1. Terminate
2. Dromar's Charm
3. Doomsday Spectere
4. Rushing River
5. Cloud Cover

And the worst card in Planeshift goes to...

ROOT GREEVIL!

Why? Because the flavor text makes me puke. They've done bad puns before, but "The root of all greevils" takes the maggot-covered cake. I mean, ouch. I was literally in pain when I read that for the first time. Make it go away!
 
E

ErinPuff

Guest
the puns hurt.. another bad one is "I never metamorphosis I didn't like".. and then there's the cleverly named card "Apes of Rath".. *hurls*

anyway..

5. Quirion Dryad
4. Flametongue Kavu
3. Doomsday Specter
2. Terminate
1. Shivan Wurm
 
L

Lotus Mox

Guest
The PS flavour text is probably the worst ever. :mad:
Also Planeshift cards are really weak IMO and I dislike gating because it is too conditional and sets you back a turn...

Invasion is a bad Ice Age
Planeshift is a bad Homelands
and hopefully Apocalypse will be a good Alliances, :)

my top 5 picks:

5.Eladamri's Call
4.Draco
3.Sunken Hope
2.The Battlemages
1.Flametongue Kavu
 
T

Thallid Ice Cream Man

Guest
5. Rushing River
4. Terminate
3. Flametongue Kavu
2. Orim's Chant
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
And the winner.......
1. Goblin Game! This card ROCKS!


The worst card is Magnigoth Treefolk. That was the first rare I opened. But then I got a Goblin Game!
 

Ransac

CPA Trash Man
Okay, why are there only two that have Scuta in their top five? That card is THE best!!!



Ransac, cpa trash man
 
F

fuzzy510

Guest
For once, TICM and I agree. Go figure. But seriously, Goblin Game is awesome.
 
G

Gizmo

Guest
Interestingly, my IBC deck uses only Terminates from Planeshift, all the other cards are Invasion.

1. Meddling Mage
2. Questing Pheldagriff
3. Thornscape Familiar
4. Rushing River
5. Terminate

Hightly commended: Magma Burst, the best card everybody else seems to have forgotten existed (LotusMox might want to pay attention to that).
 
M

Mr_Pestilence

Guest
1. Doomsday Specter - I still don't think you can build a good deck around it, but I like it nonetheless.
2. Flametongu Kavu - great power/ability to casting cost ratio, great flavor text. Might even be useful in Standard someday.
3. Rith's Grove - gives me a R/W dual land!
4. Terminate - (almost) never a dead card.
5. Nemata, Grove Guardian - tougher than Deranged Hermit, faster than Verdant Force, and doesn't require a land sacrifice like Squirrel Wrangler. Makes a ridiculous combo w/ Gaea's Cradle.

Why Phyrexian Scuta doesn't make the cut - cast it with kicker and get Undermined - then you'll understand!
 
A

Azreal the Soulmaster

Guest
1 doomsday specter( it can be used in a good deck, I remember when I played it at the prerelease, and when I play it now, when it hits the table, unless there is a way to deal with it the game is usually over)
2 Ertai the corrupted( I love Ertai, especially with nether spirit out)
3 orim's chant
4 shivan wurm
5 terminate

honorable mention
Lord of the Undead(I just like this card)
 
X

xreemer

Guest
1. Fleetfoot panther - instant blocker, instant recall
2. Shivan Worm - more big meat for cheap
3. Hull breach - very versatile
4. terminate - finally a KTC usable against black
5. Nemata Grove Guardian - pumps out some tough saprolings

honorable mention:
battle mages and flametounge kavu
 
A

arhar

Guest
Surprisingly enough, three of the set's best cards are commons!

1. Hubble Breach
2. Terminate
3. Horned Kavu
4. Phyrexian Scuta
5. Shivan Wurm
 
S

superguy

Guest
Favourite, eh?

1. Phyrexian Scuta - Juzam is my favourite card from Arabian Nights. This is a lot like Juzam.

2. Terminate - I HATE playing with Terrors and Snuff Outs - for the mere fact that my opponent might be playing black creatures. Not anymore.

3. Shivan Wurm - I hate the art, but a 7/7 trampler for 5 mana is way too tempting. Not, I don't play Fires. But this dude's BIG.

4. Hull Breach - 2 for 1 - I like those odds! (or something)

5. Flametongue Kavu.
 
Top