W
Wonka
Guest
What was the most broken card ever in Magic???????
Z
Zadok001
Guest
You missed Tolarian Academy, which would get my vote for powering the most overpowered combo deck of all time.
L
Lotus Mox
Guest
you also forgot the card which singlehandily can turn a game around: Yawgmoth's Will
D
Duel
Guest
and Mind Over Matter, also.
Nonetheless, I think that academy is the most overpowering combo card. Sorry.
Nonetheless, I think that academy is the most overpowering combo card. Sorry.
G
Gizmo
Guest
IMHO Wonka wouldnt know a good question to ask from a hole in the ground. He`d certainly have no idea what cards to put on the poll.
First card banned for being overpowered = Mind Twist.
By that point Ancestral Recall and Timetwister had already been removed from the equation.
Im not sure about what classes as most broken as people way of valuing brokenness varies so greatly. But my list would have very few of the cards from Wonka`s half-oinked attempt.
It'd look more like:
Balance
Mind Twist
Necropotence
Ancestral Recall
Time Spiral
Timetwister
Channel
Black Lotus (was Dark Ritual, but how can you possibly justify it as being better than the Lotus?)
Im personally a firm believer that Dark Ritual should never have been printed, surely Balance is the most powerful effect there in terms of the game, but it might well be that the card-drawing engines are 'more broken' although their power does depend on the cards you draw with them.
First card banned for being overpowered = Mind Twist.
By that point Ancestral Recall and Timetwister had already been removed from the equation.
Im not sure about what classes as most broken as people way of valuing brokenness varies so greatly. But my list would have very few of the cards from Wonka`s half-oinked attempt.
It'd look more like:
Balance
Mind Twist
Necropotence
Ancestral Recall
Time Spiral
Timetwister
Channel
Black Lotus (was Dark Ritual, but how can you possibly justify it as being better than the Lotus?)
Im personally a firm believer that Dark Ritual should never have been printed, surely Balance is the most powerful effect there in terms of the game, but it might well be that the card-drawing engines are 'more broken' although their power does depend on the cards you draw with them.
I
Istanbul
Guest
I can't believe nobody said Library of Alexandria.
That thing is a card-drawing MACHINE.
It's not a creature...there goes one class of permanent removal.
It's not a spell, so you can't counter it.
It's not an artifact or enchantment, so there go two more classes of permanent removal.
Having played years of Type 1, I've found one universal fact to be true when playing against Library of Alexandria: destroy it, or it will destroy you.
That thing is a card-drawing MACHINE.
It's not a creature...there goes one class of permanent removal.
It's not a spell, so you can't counter it.
It's not an artifact or enchantment, so there go two more classes of permanent removal.
Having played years of Type 1, I've found one universal fact to be true when playing against Library of Alexandria: destroy it, or it will destroy you.