Oversoul's Drafting Challenge: Limited v. Melkor

Discussion in 'Games Run By CPA Members' started by Melkor, Sep 18, 2006.

  1. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    No responses, no blocks.
  2. Melkor Active Member

    Cast Memory Jar

    Done

    Limited: 18 (13?)
    Handsize: 5
    Library: 49
    In Play:

    (TU) 2x Island
    (UU) 2x Swamp
    (U) Thawing Glaciers

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (U) Undertaker(1/1 B, discard a card, T: Return target creature card from your grave to your hand).

    Graveyard:

    Melkor: 12
    Handsize: 4
    Library: 53
    In Play:

    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Island
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot)
    (T) Ogre Warrior (3/3)
    (U) Memory Jar

    Graveyard:
  3. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Eot, I'll play Whispers of the Muse and use Thawing Glaciers to get an Island

    Untap, Upkeep (paying U), waiting for draw..

    Limited: 18 (13?)
    Handsize: 4 > 7
    Library: 49 > 46
    In Play:

    (TUU) 2x Island
    (UU) 2x Swamp

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (U) Undertaker(1/1 B, discard a card, T: Return target creature card from your grave to your hand).

    Graveyard:

    Melkor: 12
    Handsize: 4
    Library: 53
    In Play:

    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Island
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot)
    (T) Ogre Warrior (3/3)
    (U) Memory Jar

    Graveyard:
  4. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Oversoul? I'm still waiting for my draws..
  5. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Untap, Upkeep (paying U), Draw

    Island

    Attack with Spindrift Drake (you take two?)

    Done.

    Limited: 13
    Handsize: 5
    Library: 46
    In Play:

    (TUUU) 4x Island
    (UU) 2x Swamp

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (U) Undertaker(1/1 B, discard a card, T: Return target creature card from your grave to your hand).

    Graveyard: Whispers of the Muse

    Melkor: 12
    Handsize: 4
    Library: 53
    In Play:

    (T) Swamp
    (T) Island
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot)
    (T) Ogre Warrior (3/3)
    (U) Memory Jar

    Graveyard:
  6. Melkor Active Member

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Island

    Attack with Ogre and Mercenary

    Responses?

    Limited: 13
    Handsize: 5
    Library: 46
    In Play:

    (TUUU) 4x Island
    (UU) 2x Swamp

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (U) Undertaker(1/1 B, discard a card, T: Return target creature card from your grave to your hand).

    Graveyard: Whispers of the Muse

    Melkor: 10
    Handsize: 5
    Library: 53
    In Play:

    (U) Swamp
    (U) Island
    (U) Island
    (U) Mountain
    (U) Mountain
    (U) Mountain

    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot)
    (T) Ogre Warrior (3/3)
    (U) Memory Jar

    Graveyard:
  7. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    No responses.

    No blockers.
  8. Melkor Active Member

    I'll Soul Burn you for 3

    Done

    Limited: 8 (5?)
    Handsize: 5
    Library: 46
    In Play:

    (TUUU) 4x Island
    (UU) 2x Swamp

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (U) Undertaker(1/1 B, discard a card, T: Return target creature card from your grave to your hand).

    Graveyard: Whispers of the Muse

    Melkor: 10
    Handsize: 5
    Library: 53
    In Play:

    (T) Swamp
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot)
    (T) Ogre Warrior (3/3)
    (U) Memory Jar

    Graveyard:Soul Burn
  9. Oversoul The Tentacled One

    Melkor, is your hand size correct?

    Tag Guard
  10. Melkor Active Member

    No, my hand should be three cards and when Liminted is done I'll need my next draw.
  11. Oversoul The Tentacled One

    Okay. Just making sure I had your hand right. I'll send you your next draw...

    Tag Guard
  12. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Untap, upkeep *U*, Draw

    Thawing Glaciers

    Control Magic on Dauthi Mercenary

    Attack with Drake.

    Limited: 8
    Handsize: 3
    Library: 45
    In Play:

    (TTTU) 4x Island
    (TT) 2x Swamp
    (T) Thawing Glaciers

    Control Magic (You control enchanted creature) *on Mercenary*

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (U) Undertaker(1/1 B, discard a card, T: Return target creature card from your grave to your hand).
    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot) *Controlled*

    Graveyard: Whispers of the Muse, Rewind

    Melkor: 8?
    Handsize: 3
    Library: 53
    In Play:

    (T) Swamp
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (T) Ogre Warrior (3/3)
    (U) Memory Jar

    Graveyard:Soul Burn
  13. Melkor Active Member

    I assume that you cast Rewind on my Soul Burn

    Untap, upkeep, Draw

    I'll activate Memory Jar

    Limited: 8
    Handsize: 3
    Library: 45
    In Play:

    (TTTU) 4x Island
    (TT) 2x Swamp
    (T) Thawing Glaciers

    Control Magic (You control enchanted creature) *on Mercenary*

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (U) Undertaker(1/1 B, discard a card, T: Return target creature card from your grave to your hand).
    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot) *Controlled*

    Graveyard: Whispers of the Muse, Rewind

    Melkor: 8
    Handsize: 4
    Library: 53
    In Play:

    (U) Swamp
    (U) Island
    (U) Island
    (U) Mountain
    (U) Mountain
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Ogre Warrior (3/3)

    Graveyard:Soul Burn, Memory Jar
  14. Melkor Active Member

    Cast Goblin War Buggy, attack with War Buggy and Ogre, responses?



    Limited: 8
    Handsize: 3
    Library: 45
    In Play:

    (TTTU) 4x Island
    (TT) 2x Swamp
    (T) Thawing Glaciers

    Control Magic (You control enchanted creature) *on Mercenary*

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (U) Undertaker(1/1 B, discard a card, T: Return target creature card from your grave to your hand).
    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot) *Controlled*

    Graveyard: Whispers of the Muse, Rewind

    Melkor: 8
    Handsize: 4
    Library: 53
    In Play:

    (U) Swamp
    (U) Island
    (U) Island
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (U) Mountain

    (T) Ogre Warrior (3/3)
    (T) Goblin War Buggy (2/2; Haste, Echo)

    Graveyard:Soul Burn, Memory Jar[/QUOTE]
  15. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Block Ogre Warrior with Undertaker.

    I take two damage?
  16. Melkor Active Member

    Cast Lim-Duls Vault, done


    Limited: 6
    Handsize: 3
    Library: 45
    In Play:

    (TTTU) 4x Island
    (TT) 2x Swamp
    (T) Thawing Glaciers

    Control Magic (You control enchanted creature) *on Mercenary*

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot) *Controlled*

    Graveyard: Whispers of the Muse, Rewind

    Melkor: 8
    Handsize: 4
    Library: 53
    In Play:

    (T) Swamp
    (T) Island
    (U) Island
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (U) Mountain

    (T) Ogre Warrior (3/3)
    (T) Goblin War Buggy (2/2; Haste, Echo)

    Graveyard:Soul Burn, Memory Jar, Lim Dul's Vault
  17. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    What cards did you discard to the Jar?
  18. Melkor Active Member

    hmm, looks like I forgot to play a land, I'm also paying one life for the Lim-Dul's Vault to go down to the next 5 cards, I'm discarding Coercion, Mountainx2, Island, Swamp.
  19. Oversoul The Tentacled One

    Actually, you don't need to lose any life. I messed up. I thought five lands in a row seemed odd, so I checked to make sure I was grabbing cards off your library and not from in play. I was. But now that I look again, it turns out I was hallucinating or something earlier, because despite double checking, those lands really were supposed to be in play. Therefore, the cards you saw in that last PM were actually the top five of your library and not the next five down. Weird.

    Speaking of libraries, I can't figure out where the two of you are getting your numbers from, but they look way off to me...
  20. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Yes, the library sizes make no sense whatsoever. I'll update mine.

    After getting back my original hand, I'll cast Ray of Erasure to put Melkors top card of his library in his graveyard.

    Untap, Upkeep (U), Draw from Ray, Draw?

    ...

    Limited: 6
    Handsize: 4
    Library: 16
    In Play:

    (TUUU) 4x Island
    (UU) 2x Swamp
    (U) Thawing Glaciers

    Control Magic (You control enchanted creature) *on Mercenary*

    (T) Spindrift Drake (2/1 flying upkeep-U)
    (T) Dauthi Mercenary (2/1, Shadow, B1: +1/+0 ueot) *Controlled*

    Graveyard: Whispers of the Muse, Rewind, Undertaker, Barrin's Unmaking, Dream Thrush, Swamp, Urza's Bauble, Infuse, Island, Repulse, Ray of Erasure

    Melkor: 8
    Handsize: 4
    Library: ??
    In Play:

    (T) Swamp
    (T) Island
    (U) Island
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (U) Mountain

    (T) Ogre Warrior (3/3)
    (T) Goblin War Buggy (2/2; Haste, Echo)

    Graveyard:Soul Burn, Memory Jar, Lim Dul's Vault, Coercion, Mountain, Mountain, Island, Swamp, top card?

Share This Page