Oversoul's Drafting Challenge: Limited v. Melkor

Discussion in 'Games Run By CPA Members' started by Melkor, Sep 18, 2006.

  1. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Play Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)

    If you have no responses, I'll attack with Deepwood Ghoul

    (probably) done.

    Melkor 18?
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (U) Island
    (U) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (U) Mountain
    (U) Mountain

    (U) Foul Familiar: 3/1, Can't block; B, Pay 1 life: Return Foul Familiar to its owners hand

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault, Shard Phoenix
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 16

    Hand Size: 6
    Library: 25
    In Play:

    (T) Swamp
    (TTU) 3x Island
    (U) Thawing Glaciers

    (T) Deepwood Ghoul (2/1, 2 life: regenerate)
    (S) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse
    Removed from the Game:
  2. Melkor Active Member

    No Response

    Untap, Upkeep: Return Shard Phoenix from my Graveyard to my hand, Draw

    Island
    Cast Dauthi Mercenary

    Done

    Melkor 18
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (U) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (S) Dauthi Mercenary: 2/1; Shadow; B1: +1/+0 until end of turn
    (U) Foul Familiar: 3/1, Can't block; B, Pay 1 life: Return Foul Familiar to its owners hand

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault,
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 16

    Hand Size: 6
    Library: 25
    In Play:

    (T) Swamp
    (TTU) 3x Island
    (U) Thawing Glaciers

    (T) Deepwood Ghoul (2/1, 2 life: regenerate)
    (S) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse
    Removed from the Game:
  3. Oversoul The Tentacled One

    I'll hold off on sending Limited his draw until he informs me of any Glacierness or lack thereof...
  4. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    I'll use the Glaciers to get a Swamp
  5. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Attack with Deepwood Ghoul (you take two?)

    Swamp

    Play Brine Shaman

    Done.

    Melkor 16?
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (U) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (S) Dauthi Mercenary: 2/1; Shadow; B1: +1/+0 until end of turn
    (U) Foul Familiar: 3/1, Can't block; B, Pay 1 life: Return Foul Familiar to its owners hand

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault,
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 16

    Hand Size: 5
    Library: 23
    In Play:

    (UTT) 3x Swamp
    (UUU) 3x Island

    (S) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (T) Deepwood Ghoul (2/1, 2 life: regenerate)
    (U) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse
    Removed from the Game:
  6. Melkor Active Member

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Cast Shard Phoenix, if no reply
    Attack with Dauthi Mercenary and pump him once

    Done.

    Melkor 16
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (T) Dauthi Mercenary: 2/1; Shadow; B1: +1/+0 until end of turn
    (U) Foul Familiar: 3/1, Can't block; B, Pay 1 life: Return Foul Familiar to its owners hand
    (S) Shard Phoenix: 2/2, Flying; RRR: Return Shard Phoenix from the Graveyard to your hand, use this ability only during your upkeep; Sacrifice Shard Phoenix: Shard Phoenix deals 2 damage to each creature without flying

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault,
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 16 (13?)

    Hand Size: 5
    Library: 23
    In Play:

    (UTT) 3x Swamp
    (UUU) 3x Island

    (S) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (T) Deepwood Ghoul (2/1, 2 life: regenerate)
    (U) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse
    Removed from the Game:
  7. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    No responses, take the damage

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Attack with Deepwood Ghoul

    Blocks? Responses?

    (not done yet)

    Melkor 16
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (T) Dauthi Mercenary: 2/1; Shadow; B1: +1/+0 until end of turn
    (U) Foul Familiar: 3/1, Can't block; B, Pay 1 life: Return Foul Familiar to its owners hand
    (S) Shard Phoenix: 2/2, Flying; RRR: Return Shard Phoenix from the Graveyard to your hand, use this ability only during your upkeep; Sacrifice Shard Phoenix: Shard Phoenix deals 2 damage to each creature without flying

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault,
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 13
    Hand Size: 6
    Library: 22
    In Play:

    (UTT) 3x Swamp
    (UTT) 3x Island

    (S) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (U) Deepwood Ghoul (2/1, 2 life: regenerate)
    (U) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse
    Removed from the Game:
  8. Melkor Active Member

    I won't block
  9. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Damage on the stack?
  10. Melkor Active Member

    Sure, why not? Sounds like fun.
  11. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    You take two then

    Control Magic on the Phoenix

    Responses?

    Melkor 14
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    (T) Dauthi Mercenary: 2/1; Shadow; B1: +1/+0 until end of turn
    (U) Foul Familiar: 3/1, Can't block; B, Pay 1 life: Return Foul Familiar to its owners hand
    (S) Shard Phoenix: 2/2, Flying; RRR: Return Shard Phoenix from the Graveyard to your hand, use this ability only during your upkeep; Sacrifice Shard Phoenix: Shard Phoenix deals 2 damage to each creature without flying

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault,
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 13
    Hand Size: 6
    Library: 22
    In Play:

    (UTT) 3x Swamp
    (UTT) 3x Island

    (U) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (T) Deepwood Ghoul (2/1, 2 life: regenerate)
    (U) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse
    Removed from the Game:
  12. Melkor Active Member

    I'll sacrifice it
  13. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    I'll pay U to regenerate my Spiny Starfish, and sacrifice the Deepwood Ghoul to give the Brine Shaman +2/+2.

    Play Thawing Glaciers

    At the end of my turn, I get a 0/1 token.

    Done

    Melkor 14
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault, Shard Phoenix, Dauthi Mercenary, Foul Familiar
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 13
    Hand Size: 4
    Library: 22
    In Play:

    (UTT) 3x Swamp
    (UTT) 3x Island
    (T) Thawing Glaciers

    (T) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (T) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)
    (S) Starfish token (0/1)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse, Deepwood Ghoul, Control Magic
    Removed from the Game:
  14. Melkor Active Member

    Untap, upkeep, draw

    Cast Storm Shaman

    Done

    Melkor 14
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (U) Island
    (U) Island
    (T) Island
    (U) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (U) Mountain

    In Play:

    Storm Shaman: 0/4; R: +1/+0 until end of turn

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault, Shard Phoenix, Dauthi Mercenary, Foul Familiar
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 13
    Hand Size: 4
    Library: 22
    In Play:

    (UTT) 3x Swamp
    (UTT) 3x Island
    (T) Thawing Glaciers

    (T) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (T) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)
    (S) Starfish token (0/1)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse, Deepwood Ghoul, Control Magic
    Removed from the Game:[/QUOTE]
  15. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Untap, upkeep, draw

    Swamp.

    Done.

    Melkor 14
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (U) Island
    (U) Island
    (T) Island
    (U) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (U) Mountain

    In Play:

    Storm Shaman: 0/4; R: +1/+0 until end of turn

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault, Shard Phoenix, Dauthi Mercenary, Foul Familiar
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 13
    Hand Size: 4
    Library: 21
    In Play:

    (UUUU) 4x Swamp
    (UUU) 3x Island
    (U) Thawing Glaciers

    (U) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (U) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)
    (U) Starfish token (0/1)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse, Deepwood Ghoul, Control Magic
    Removed from the Game:
  16. Melkor Active Member

    Untap, upkeep: Return Shard Phoenix to my hand, draw

    Coercion

    Done.

    Melkor 14
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (U) Island
    (U) Island
    (T) Island
    (U) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (U) Mountain

    In Play:

    Storm Shaman: 0/4; R: +1/+0 until end of turn

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault, Shard Phoenix, Dauthi Mercenary, Foul Familiar, Coercion
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 13
    Hand Size: 4
    Library: 21
    In Play:

    (UUUU) 4x Swamp
    (UUU) 3x Island
    (U) Thawing Glaciers

    (U) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (U) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)
    (U) Starfish token (0/1)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse, Deepwood Ghoul, Control Magic
    Removed from the Game:
  17. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    My hand:
    Spirit Shackle
    Darkling Stalker
    Dream Thrush
    Metathran Soldier

    I'll wait for your pick before taking my turn

    (Before you end of turn phase, I'll activate my Thawing Glaciers to get an Island)

    Melkor 14
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (U) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    In Play:

    Storm Shaman: 0/4; R: +1/+0 until end of turn

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault, Dauthi Mercenary, Foul Familiar, Coercion
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 13
    Hand Size: 4
    Library: 21
    In Play:

    (UUUU) 4x Swamp
    (UUU) 3x Island
    (U) Thawing Glaciers

    (U) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (U) Spiny Starfish (0/1, U:regenerate and get an 0/1 blue Starfish token at end of turn)
    (U) Starfish token (0/1)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse, Deepwood Ghoul, Control Magic
    Removed from the Game:
  18. Melkor Active Member

    Lose the Darkling Stalker
  19. Limited Yes, but we won't care

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Play Doomsday Specter, returning the Spiny Starfish to my hand.
    Play Thawing Glaciers

    Done.

    Melkor 14
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (U) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    In Play:

    Storm Shaman: 0/4; R: +1/+0 until end of turn

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault, Dauthi Mercenary, Foul Familiar, Coercion
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 13
    Hand Size: 4
    Library: 19
    In Play:

    (UUTT) 4x Swamp
    (UUTT) 4x Island
    (T) Thawing Glaciers

    (U) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (U) Starfish token (0/1)
    (S) Doomsday Specter (2/3; Flying; When ~ comes into play, return a blue or black creature you control to your hand. Whenever ~ deals combat damage to a player, look at that player's hand and discard a card from it)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse, Deepwood Ghoul, Control Magic, Darkling Stalker
    Removed from the Game:
  20. Melkor Active Member

    Untap, Upkeep, Draw

    Play Shard Phoenix, response?

    I'm not done.

    Melkor 14
    Hand Size: 3
    Library: 33?
    In Play:

    (U) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Island
    (T) Swamp
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain
    (T) Mountain

    In Play:

    Storm Shaman: 0/4; R: +1/+0 until end of turn

    Graveyard: Lim-Duls Vault, Dauthi Mercenary, Foul Familiar, Coercion
    Removed from the Game:

    Limited 13
    Hand Size: 4
    Library: 19
    In Play:

    (UUTT) 4x Swamp
    (UUTT) 4x Island
    (T) Thawing Glaciers

    (U) Brine Shaman (1/1; T, Sacrifice a creature: Target creature gets +2/+2 until end of turn; 1UU, Sacrifice a creature: Counter target creature spell)
    (U) Starfish token (0/1)
    (S) Doomsday Specter (2/3; Flying; When ~ comes into play, return a blue or black creature you control to your hand. Whenever ~ deals combat damage to a player, look at that player's hand and discard a card from it)

    Graveyard: Rewind, Repulse, Whispers of the Muse, Deepwood Ghoul, Control Magic, Darkling Stalker
    Removed from the Game:[/QUOTE]

Share This Page