So far the nominations look pretty good. However, we are looking for a Casual Hall of Fame canidate. Therefore, I took the liberty of loading the whole set into the gatherer, and started "Browse"ing (pun intended!). After many different cards that I looked at and discarded, one jumped out at me.
Ok, here it is, [url="http://www.wizards.com/global/images/magic/alliances/helm_of_obedience.jpg]Helm of Obedience[/URL]!!!
The amount of wording on the card itself is almost enough to get the nomination.
Put the top card of target opponent’s library into his or her graveyard. Repeat this process an additional X times or until you put a creature card into that graveyard, whichever comes first. If the last card put into that graveyard this way is a creature card, sacrifice Helm of Obedience and put that card into play under your control.
However, the game mechanic itself is enough to scream out casual. Again I will call upon the powers that be (the committee I guess) to see the logic behind this. This card will NEVER see a tournament. It is never suggested as a "power card". In fact, it is almost as detrimental to the user as to the opponent.