Mindmaster Torment: Spidey vs BigBlue

B

BigBlue

Guest
Discard Basking Rootwalla to return my Aven to my hand.
Play Basking Rootwalla for it's madness cost.

I'm sort of guessing you'll bounce the aven and I'll wait 'til after combat to proceed

BigBlue: 20
Hand: 11
In Play

(U) Plains
(U) Mountain
(U) Swamp
(U) Island
(U) Forest

(T) Barbarian Outcast (2/2; If I control no Swamps, Sacrifice ~)
(U) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(S) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf
RfG:

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)
--------------------------------
Spiderman: 15 13?
Hand: 12
In Play

(U) Plains
(T) Island
(T) Swamp
(T) Forest

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(S) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand) Dying?

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life)
RfG:
 
B

BigBlue

Guest
Sucks for you... not for me. :)

You take 2
Play Skywing Aven
Done

Madness.... Simply Madness I tell you... Absolutely Fabulous Madness!

BigBlue: 20
Hand: 10
In Play

(U) Plains
(T) Mountain
(T) Swamp
(T) Island
(U) Forest

(T) Barbarian Outcast (2/2; If I control no Swamps, Sacrifice ~)
(U) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(S) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)
(S) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf
RfG:

--------------------------------
Spiderman: 13
Hand: 12
In Play

(U) Plains
(T) Island
(T) Swamp
(T) Forest

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings
RfG:
 

Spiderman

Administrator
Staff member
Untap, upkeep

Swamp
Sengir Vampire

Done

BigBlue: 20
Hand: 10
In Play

(U) Plains
(T) Mountain
(T) Swamp
(T) Island
(U) Forest

(T) Barbarian Outcast (2/2; If I control no Swamps, Sacrifice ~)
(U) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(S) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)
(S) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf
RfG:

--------------------------------
Spiderman: 13
Hand: 11
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Island
(T,T) Swamp x2
(T) Forest

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(S) Sengir Vampire (4/4, flying, Whenever a creature that's dealt dmg by ~ this turn is put into a graveyard, put a +1/+1 ctr on ~)

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings
RfG:
 
B

BigBlue

Guest
It's all fun and games until someone gets a VAMPIRE out... :eek:

Untap, Upkeep

Play Island
Attack w/ Aven and Outcast

BigBlue: 20
Hand: 10
In Play

(U) Plains
(U) Mountain
(U) Swamp
(UU) Island
(U) Forest

(T) Barbarian Outcast (2/2; If I control no Swamps, Sacrifice ~)
(U) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(U) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)
(T) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf
RfG:

--------------------------------
Spiderman: 13
Hand: 11
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Island
(T,T) Swamp x2
(T) Forest

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(S) Sengir Vampire (4/4, flying, Whenever a creature that's dealt dmg by ~ this turn is put into a graveyard, put a +1/+1 ctr on ~)

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings
RfG:
 
B

BigBlue

Guest
Attack w/ Aven and Outcast
Outcast blocked by Amoeba, you take 2 from Aven
Play Possessed Aven (from memory, on my way out the door for a bit I'll fix it later if it's wrong and include threshold stuff)
Done.

BigBlue: 20
Hand: 9
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Mountain
(U) Swamp
(TT) Island
(U) Forest

(T) Barbarian Outcast (2/2; If I control no Swamps, Sacrifice ~)
(U) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(U) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)
(T) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)
(S) Possessed Aven (3/3; Flying; Threshold stuff)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf
RfG:

--------------------------------
Spiderman: 11
Hand: 11
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Island
(T,T) Swamp x2
(T) Forest

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(S) Sengir Vampire (4/4, flying, Whenever a creature that's dealt dmg by ~ this turn is put into a graveyard, put a +1/+1 ctr on ~)

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings
RfG:
 

Spiderman

Administrator
Staff member
Untap, upkeep

Mt
Balshan Collaborator

Done

BigBlue: 20
Hand: 9
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Mountain
(U) Swamp
(TT) Island
(U) Forest

(T) Barbarian Outcast (2/2; If I control no Swamps, Sacrifice ~)
(U) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(U) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)
(T) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)
(S) Possessed Aven (3/3; Flying; Threshold stuff)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf
RfG:

--------------------------------
Spiderman: 11
Hand: 10
In Play

(U) Plains
(T) Island
(T,U) Swamp x2
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(U) Sengir Vampire (4/4, flying, Whenever a creature that's dealt dmg by ~ this turn is put into a graveyard, put a +1/+1 ctr on ~)
(S) Balshan Collaborator (2/2, flying, B: ~ gets +1/+1 ueot)

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings
RfG:
 
B

BigBlue

Guest
Untap, Upkeep

Play Swamp
Attack w/ Outcast & Aven

BigBlue: 20
Hand: 9
In Play

(U) Plains
(U) Mountain
(UU) Swamp
(UU) Island
(U) Forest

(T) Barbarian Outcast (2/2; If I control no Swamps, Sacrifice ~)
(U) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(U) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)
(T) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)
(U) Possessed Aven (3/3; Flying; Threshold - gets +1/+1, is black, and gains "2B,T: Destroy target blue creature".)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf
RfG:
--------------------------------
Spiderman: 11
Hand: 10
In Play

(U) Plains
(T) Island
(T,U) Swamp x2
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(U) Sengir Vampire (4/4, flying, Whenever a creature that's dealt dmg by ~ this turn is put into a graveyard, put a +1/+1 ctr on ~)
(S) Balshan Collaborator (2/2, flying, B: ~ gets +1/+1 ueot)

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings
RfG:
 
B

BigBlue

Guest
Pump up rootwalla
Play Spirit Flare (Target my Rootwalla & your Vampire)
Responses?
Any other responses?
Damage on Stack?


BigBlue: 20
Hand: 9
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Mountain
(TU) Swamp
(TT) Island
(T) Forest

(T) Barbarian Outcast (2/2; If I control no Swamps, Sacrifice ~)
(U) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(T) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0) 3/3 until eot
(T) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)
(U) Possessed Aven (3/3; Flying; Threshold - gets +1/+1, is black, and gains "2B,T: Destroy target blue creature".)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf, Spirit Flare (Flashback: 1W, 3 Life)
RfG:
--------------------------------
Spiderman: 11
Hand: 10
In Play

(U) Plains
(T) Island
(T,U) Swamp x2
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(U) Sengir Vampire (4/4, flying, Whenever a creature that's dealt dmg by ~ this turn is put into a graveyard, put a +1/+1 ctr on ~)
(S) Balshan Collaborator (2/2, flying, B: ~ gets +1/+1 ueot)

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings
RfG:
 

Spiderman

Administrator
Staff member
I thought you had a trick :)

In response to your Spirit Flare, I will pay W for Pay No Heed (Prevent all dmg a source of my choice would deal this turn), preventing the Rootwalla's dmg.

Responses to that? Responses to after Pay No Heed resolves but Spirit Flare is still on stack? Dmg on stack?
 
B

BigBlue

Guest
Allow Pay no Heed & Spirit Flare to resolve
Activate the Restorer to untap my plains
Flashback the Spirit Flare and tap my Possessed Aven to deal 3 to your Vampire.
Damage on the stack?

BigBlue: 17
Hand: 9
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Mountain
(TT) Swamp
(TT) Island
(T) Forest

(T) Barbarian Outcast (2/2; If I control no Swamps, Sacrifice ~)
(T) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(T) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0) 3/3 until eot
(T) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)
(T) Possessed Aven (3/3; Flying; Threshold - gets +1/+1, is black, and gains "2B,T: Destroy target blue creature".)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf
RfG:Spirit Flare
--------------------------------
Spiderman: 11
Hand: 9
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Island
(T,U) Swamp x2
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(U) Sengir Vampire (4/4, flying, Whenever a creature that's dealt dmg by ~ this turn is put into a graveyard, put a +1/+1 ctr on ~)
(S) Balshan Collaborator (2/2, flying, B: ~ gets +1/+1 ueot)

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings, Pay no Heed
RfG:
 
B

BigBlue

Guest
Discard Stupefying touch to return Aven to my hand.
Damage Resolves?
Vampire Dies
Outcast Dies
I've no further responses and I'm done after the combat phase.

BigBlue: 17
Hand: 8
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Mountain
(TT) Swamp
(TT) Island
(T) Forest

(T) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(T) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)
(T) Possessed Aven (3/3; Flying; Threshold - gets +1/+1, is black, and gains "2B,T: Destroy target blue creature".)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf, Stupefying Touch, Barbarian Outcast
RfG: Spirit Flare

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)
--------------------------------
Spiderman: 11
Hand: 9
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Island
(T,U) Swamp x2
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(U) Sengir Vampire (4/4, flying, Whenever a creature that's dealt dmg by ~ this turn is put into a graveyard, put a +1/+1 ctr on ~) Dead?
(S) Balshan Collaborator (2/2, flying, B: ~ gets +1/+1 ueot) Dead? (Probably not :) )

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings, Pay no Heed, Sengir Vampire
RfG:
 

Spiderman

Administrator
Staff member
While dmg is still on the stack, I'll tap B to save my Collaborator

Untap, upkeep

Swamp
Krosan Restorer

Done

BigBlue: 17
Hand: 8
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Mountain
(TT) Swamp
(TT) Island
(T) Forest

(T) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(T) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)
(T) Possessed Aven (3/3; Flying; Threshold - gets +1/+1, is black, and gains "2B,T: Destroy target blue creature".)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf, Stupefying Touch, Barbarian Outcast
RfG: Spirit Flare

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)
--------------------------------
Spiderman: 11
Hand: 8
In Play

(T) Plains
(U) Island
(U,U,U) Swamp x3
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(U) Balshan Collaborator (2/2, flying, B: ~ gets +1/+1 ueot)
(S) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings, Pay no Heed, Sengir Vampire
RfG:
 
B

BigBlue

Guest
Figured as much... :)

Untap, Upkeep

Play Swamp
Play Grotesque Hybrid
Play Skywing Aven
Done

BigBlue: 17
Hand: 6
In Play

(T) Plains
(T) Mountain
(TTT) Swamp
(TT) Island
(T) Forest

(U) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)
(U) Basking Rootwalla (1/1; 1G: +2/+2 until eot only use once per turn; Madness:0)
(U) Possessed Aven (3/3; Flying; Threshold - gets +1/+1, is black, and gains "2B,T: Destroy target blue creature".)
(S) Grotesque Hybrid (3/3; Discard a card: ~ gains flying, protection from White, Protection from Green until eot)
(S) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Bigblue's hand)

Graveyard: Enslaved Dwarf, Stupefying Touch, Barbarian Outcast
RfG: Spirit Flare
--------------------------------
Spiderman: 11
Hand: 8
In Play

(T) Plains
(U) Island
(U,U,U) Swamp x3
(T) Forest
(T) Mt

(U) Aquamoeba (1/3, Discard a card: Switch ~'s power and toughness ueot)
(U) Balshan Collaborator (2/2, flying, B: ~ gets +1/+1 ueot)
(S) Krosan Restorer (1/2; T: Untap Target Land; T: Untap up to 3 target lands - Threshhold)

(Hand) Skywing Aven (2/1; Flying; Discard a card: Return ~ to Spidey's hand)

Graveyard: Deep Analysis (FB: 1U, 3 Life), Far Wanderings, Pay no Heed, Sengir Vampire
RfG:
 
Top