D
DarthFerret
Guest
Why don't i just roll over and die for ya....i am playin horribly this round....
Yeah, as far as i am concerned, everything resolves....
Yeah, as far as i am concerned, everything resolves....
Mindmaster Legends: Spidey vs DarthFerret
- Thread starter Spiderman
- Start date
Island
Wall of Vapor
Done
DarthFerret
Life: 11
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T,T) Swamp x 2
(T,T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x 2
(U,U) Island x 2
(T) Mountain
Enchant: Gaseous Form (prevent all combat damage dealt to and from <this>)
(U) Jacques le Vert (3/4, All green creatures I control gain +0/+2)
(U) Fallen Angel (3/3, flying, Sac a critter for +2/+1)
Graveyard: Vampire Bats, D'Avenant Archer, Emerald Dragonfly, Venarian Gold, Alabaster Potion
RFG:
Spiderman
Life: 16
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T) Mt
(T,U) Forest x2
(U,U,U) Swamp x3
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Island
(U) Emerald Dragonfly (1/1, flying, GG: ~ gains first strike ueot)
(U) Headless Horseman (2/2)
(U) Cat Warriors (2/2, forestwalk) **Gassed**
(T) Lord Magnus (4/3, first strike, creatures with forestwalk or plainswalk can be blocked as though they don't have it)
(U) Abomination (2/6, whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked by a white or green creature, destroy that creature at end of combat)
(T) Ghosts of the Damned (0/2, T: Target creature gets -1/-0 ueot)
(S) Wall of Vapor (0/1, defender, Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to ~ by creatures it's blocking)
Graveyard: Pyrotechnics, Active Volcano
RFG:
Wall of Vapor
Done
DarthFerret
Life: 11
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T,T) Swamp x 2
(T,T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x 2
(U,U) Island x 2
(T) Mountain
Enchant: Gaseous Form (prevent all combat damage dealt to and from <this>)
(U) Jacques le Vert (3/4, All green creatures I control gain +0/+2)
(U) Fallen Angel (3/3, flying, Sac a critter for +2/+1)
Graveyard: Vampire Bats, D'Avenant Archer, Emerald Dragonfly, Venarian Gold, Alabaster Potion
RFG:
Spiderman
Life: 16
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T) Mt
(T,U) Forest x2
(U,U,U) Swamp x3
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Island
(U) Emerald Dragonfly (1/1, flying, GG: ~ gains first strike ueot)
(U) Headless Horseman (2/2)
(U) Cat Warriors (2/2, forestwalk) **Gassed**
(T) Lord Magnus (4/3, first strike, creatures with forestwalk or plainswalk can be blocked as though they don't have it)
(U) Abomination (2/6, whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked by a white or green creature, destroy that creature at end of combat)
(T) Ghosts of the Damned (0/2, T: Target creature gets -1/-0 ueot)
(S) Wall of Vapor (0/1, defender, Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to ~ by creatures it's blocking)
Graveyard: Pyrotechnics, Active Volcano
RFG:
D
DarthFerret
Guest
Untap, upkeep, Ichneumon Druid, Osai Vultures, done.
DarthFerret
Life: 11
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T,U) Swamp x 2
(T,T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x 2
(U,U) Island x 2
(U) Mountain
Enchant: Gaseous Form (prevent all combat damage dealt to and from <this>)
(U) Jacques le Vert (3/4, All green creatures I control gain +0/+2)
(U) Fallen Angel (3/3, flying, Sac a critter for +2/+1)
(S) Osai Vultures (1/1, flying, gets counter when a creature bites the big one, remove 2 counters to gain +1/+1 until EOT)
(S) Ichneumon Druid (1/1, every instant spell beyond the first that opponent plays deals him 4 damage)
Graveyard: Vampire Bats, D'Avenant Archer, Emerald Dragonfly, Venarian Gold, Alabaster Potion
RFG:
Spiderman
Life: 16
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T) Mt
(T,U) Forest x2
(U,U,U) Swamp x3
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Island
(U) Emerald Dragonfly (1/1, flying, GG: ~ gains first strike ueot)
(U) Headless Horseman (2/2)
(U) Cat Warriors (2/2, forestwalk) **Gassed**
(T) Lord Magnus (4/3, first strike, creatures with forestwalk or plainswalk can be blocked as though they don't have it)
(U) Abomination (2/6, whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked by a white or green creature, destroy that creature at end of combat)
(T) Ghosts of the Damned (0/2, T: Target creature gets -1/-0 ueot)
(S) Wall of Vapor (0/1, defender, Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to ~ by creatures it's blocking)
Graveyard: Pyrotechnics, Active Volcano
RFG:
DarthFerret
Life: 11
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T,U) Swamp x 2
(T,T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x 2
(U,U) Island x 2
(U) Mountain
Enchant: Gaseous Form (prevent all combat damage dealt to and from <this>)
(U) Jacques le Vert (3/4, All green creatures I control gain +0/+2)
(U) Fallen Angel (3/3, flying, Sac a critter for +2/+1)
(S) Osai Vultures (1/1, flying, gets counter when a creature bites the big one, remove 2 counters to gain +1/+1 until EOT)
(S) Ichneumon Druid (1/1, every instant spell beyond the first that opponent plays deals him 4 damage)
Graveyard: Vampire Bats, D'Avenant Archer, Emerald Dragonfly, Venarian Gold, Alabaster Potion
RFG:
Spiderman
Life: 16
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T) Mt
(T,U) Forest x2
(U,U,U) Swamp x3
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Island
(U) Emerald Dragonfly (1/1, flying, GG: ~ gains first strike ueot)
(U) Headless Horseman (2/2)
(U) Cat Warriors (2/2, forestwalk) **Gassed**
(T) Lord Magnus (4/3, first strike, creatures with forestwalk or plainswalk can be blocked as though they don't have it)
(U) Abomination (2/6, whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked by a white or green creature, destroy that creature at end of combat)
(T) Ghosts of the Damned (0/2, T: Target creature gets -1/-0 ueot)
(S) Wall of Vapor (0/1, defender, Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to ~ by creatures it's blocking)
Graveyard: Pyrotechnics, Active Volcano
RFG:
Untap, upkeep
Attack with Magnus
Responses/blocks?
DarthFerret
Life: 11
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T,U) Swamp x 2
(T,T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x 2
(U,U) Island x 2
(U) Mountain
Enchant: Gaseous Form (prevent all combat damage dealt to and from <this>)
(U) Jacques le Vert (3/4, All green creatures I control gain +0/+2)
(U) Fallen Angel (3/3, flying, Sac a critter for +2/+1)
(S) Osai Vultures (1/1, flying, gets counter when a creature bites the big one, remove 2 counters to gain +1/+1 until EOT)
(S) Ichneumon Druid (1/3 due to Jacques, every instant spell beyond the first that opponent plays deals him 4 damage)
Graveyard: Vampire Bats, D'Avenant Archer, Emerald Dragonfly, Venarian Gold, Alabaster Potion
RFG:
Spiderman
Life: 16
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T) Mt
(T,U) Forest x2
(U,U,U) Swamp x3
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Island
(U) Emerald Dragonfly (1/1, flying, GG: ~ gains first strike ueot)
(U) Headless Horseman (2/2)
(U) Cat Warriors (2/2, forestwalk) **Gassed**
(T) Lord Magnus (4/3, first strike, creatures with forestwalk or plainswalk can be blocked as though they don't have it)
(U) Abomination (2/6, whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked by a white or green creature, destroy that creature at end of combat)
(U) Ghosts of the Damned (0/2, T: Target creature gets -1/-0 ueot)
(U) Wall of Vapor (0/1, defender, Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to ~ by creatures it's blocking)
Graveyard: Pyrotechnics, Active Volcano
RFG:
Attack with Magnus
Responses/blocks?
DarthFerret
Life: 11
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T,U) Swamp x 2
(T,T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x 2
(U,U) Island x 2
(U) Mountain
Enchant: Gaseous Form (prevent all combat damage dealt to and from <this>)
(U) Jacques le Vert (3/4, All green creatures I control gain +0/+2)
(U) Fallen Angel (3/3, flying, Sac a critter for +2/+1)
(S) Osai Vultures (1/1, flying, gets counter when a creature bites the big one, remove 2 counters to gain +1/+1 until EOT)
(S) Ichneumon Druid (1/3 due to Jacques, every instant spell beyond the first that opponent plays deals him 4 damage)
Graveyard: Vampire Bats, D'Avenant Archer, Emerald Dragonfly, Venarian Gold, Alabaster Potion
RFG:
Spiderman
Life: 16
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T) Mt
(T,U) Forest x2
(U,U,U) Swamp x3
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Island
(U) Emerald Dragonfly (1/1, flying, GG: ~ gains first strike ueot)
(U) Headless Horseman (2/2)
(U) Cat Warriors (2/2, forestwalk) **Gassed**
(T) Lord Magnus (4/3, first strike, creatures with forestwalk or plainswalk can be blocked as though they don't have it)
(U) Abomination (2/6, whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked by a white or green creature, destroy that creature at end of combat)
(U) Ghosts of the Damned (0/2, T: Target creature gets -1/-0 ueot)
(U) Wall of Vapor (0/1, defender, Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to ~ by creatures it's blocking)
Graveyard: Pyrotechnics, Active Volcano
RFG:
D
DarthFerret
Guest
Block with Everything I got...(that will hopefully be enough to kill the guy...)
D
DarthFerret
Guest
Sure, which one dies?
D
DarthFerret
Guest
Yes....
D
DarthFerret
Guest
Yup
D
DarthFerret
Guest
Not to be picky, but First Strike damage should still be classified as combat damage. Darkness has to be played before any combat damage is assigned, right?
When the first strike damage resolves, the damage is applied and the creature killed by the damage is in the graveyard. THEN, normal damage goes on the stack.
In short, once damage has resolved, it cannot be prevented. As much as I hate to say it, Spidey wins out in this case.
Ransac, cpa trash man
In short, once damage has resolved, it cannot be prevented. As much as I hate to say it, Spidey wins out in this case.
Ransac, cpa trash man
D
DarthFerret
Guest
That is not what I was asking. I am thinking he cannot play the darkness, because we are already in the combat damage step. It states that it has to be played before combat damage phase....
L
Limited
Guest
Heck, you can even play Darkness during your end of turn step. I probably won't do anything, but there aren't additional rules for playing damage prevention spells. If a spell can only be played during a specific phase, it has to say so.
So, what Spidey did is correct (and nasty)
So, what Spidey did is correct (and nasty
)
D
DarthFerret
Guest
Ok, ok, that sux....
DF, are you looking at the original wording for the card or something that says I should have played it before the combat dmg phase?
I'm done.
DarthFerret
Life: 11
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T,U) Swamp x 2
(T,T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x 2
(U,U) Island x 2
(U) Mountain
Enchant: Gaseous Form (prevent all combat damage dealt to and from <this>)
(U) Fallen Angel (3/3, flying, Sac a critter for +2/+1)
(S) Osai Vultures (1/1, flying, gets counter when a creature bites the big one, remove 2 counters to gain +1/+1 until EOT)
(S) Ichneumon Druid (1/1, every instant spell beyond the first that opponent plays deals him 4 damage)
Graveyard: Vampire Bats, D'Avenant Archer, Emerald Dragonfly, Venarian Gold, Alabaster Potion, Jacques le Vert
RFG:
Spiderman
Life: 16
Hand: 7
In Play:
(U) Mt
(U,U) Forest x2
(T,U,U) Swamp x3
(U,U) Plains x2
(U) Island
(U) Emerald Dragonfly (1/1, flying, GG: ~ gains first strike ueot)
(U) Headless Horseman (2/2)
(U) Cat Warriors (2/2, forestwalk) **Gassed**
(T) Lord Magnus (4/3, first strike, creatures with forestwalk or plainswalk can be blocked as though they don't have it)
(U) Abomination (2/6, whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked by a white or green creature, destroy that creature at end of combat)
(U) Ghosts of the Damned (0/2, T: Target creature gets -1/-0 ueot)
(U) Wall of Vapor (0/1, defender, Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to ~ by creatures it's blocking)
Graveyard: Pyrotechnics, Active Volcano, Darkness
RFG:
I'm done.
DarthFerret
Life: 11
Hand: 8
In Play:
(T,U) Swamp x 2
(T,T) Plains
(T,T) Forest x 2
(U,U) Island x 2
(U) Mountain
Enchant: Gaseous Form (prevent all combat damage dealt to and from <this>)
(U) Fallen Angel (3/3, flying, Sac a critter for +2/+1)
(S) Osai Vultures (1/1, flying, gets counter when a creature bites the big one, remove 2 counters to gain +1/+1 until EOT)
(S) Ichneumon Druid (1/1, every instant spell beyond the first that opponent plays deals him 4 damage)
Graveyard: Vampire Bats, D'Avenant Archer, Emerald Dragonfly, Venarian Gold, Alabaster Potion, Jacques le Vert
RFG:
Spiderman
Life: 16
Hand: 7
In Play:
(U) Mt
(U,U) Forest x2
(T,U,U) Swamp x3
(U,U) Plains x2
(U) Island
(U) Emerald Dragonfly (1/1, flying, GG: ~ gains first strike ueot)
(U) Headless Horseman (2/2)
(U) Cat Warriors (2/2, forestwalk) **Gassed**
(T) Lord Magnus (4/3, first strike, creatures with forestwalk or plainswalk can be blocked as though they don't have it)
(U) Abomination (2/6, whenever ~ blocks or becomes blocked by a white or green creature, destroy that creature at end of combat)
(U) Ghosts of the Damned (0/2, T: Target creature gets -1/-0 ueot)
(U) Wall of Vapor (0/1, defender, Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to ~ by creatures it's blocking)
Graveyard: Pyrotechnics, Active Volcano, Darkness
RFG: