L
Limited
Guest
Damage on the stack?
Mindmaster Exodus: Spidey vs Limited
- Thread starter Spiderman
- Start date
L
Limited
Guest
You can't do that.. you've played robe of mirrors on the frog, right?
L
Limited
Guest
You still have the Shield Mate, because you weren't allowed to play the ability in the first place.
After combat, I'll discard Onslaught to return E to my hand, and I'll play it again.
Mountain.
They I'll play Skyshroud Elite.
Done
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(T,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,T) Swamp x2
(T,T) Mt x2
(T) Forest
(U) Shield Mate (1/1, sac ~: target creature gets +0/+4 ueot)
(U) School of Piranha (3/3, at the beginning of my upkeep, sac ~ unless I pay 1U)
(U) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(T) Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
(U) Whiptongue Frog (1/3, U: ~ gains flying until eot) - enchanted with Robe of Mirrors (cannot be the target of spells or abilities)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(S) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(S) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst
RFG:
Limited 6
Hand: 5
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Wood Elves (1/1)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught
RFG:
After combat, I'll discard Onslaught to return E to my hand, and I'll play it again.
Mountain.
They I'll play Skyshroud Elite.
Done
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(T,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,T) Swamp x2
(T,T) Mt x2
(T) Forest
(U) Shield Mate (1/1, sac ~: target creature gets +0/+4 ueot)
(U) School of Piranha (3/3, at the beginning of my upkeep, sac ~ unless I pay 1U)
(U) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(T) Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
(U) Whiptongue Frog (1/3, U: ~ gains flying until eot) - enchanted with Robe of Mirrors (cannot be the target of spells or abilities)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(S) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(S) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst
RFG:
Limited 6
Hand: 5
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Wood Elves (1/1)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught
RFG:
My Frog (and Robe of Mirrors) is supposed to be in my graveyard after that combat.
Untap, upkeep - pay 1U, attack with all except the Assassin and Keeper.
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(U) Forest
(T) Shield Mate (1/1, sac ~: target creature gets +0/+4 ueot)
(T) School of Piranha (3/3, at the beginning of my upkeep, sac ~ unless I pay 1U)
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(T) Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors
RFG:
Limited 6
Hand: 5
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Wood Elves (1/1)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught
RFG:
Untap, upkeep - pay 1U, attack with all except the Assassin and Keeper.
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(U) Forest
(T) Shield Mate (1/1, sac ~: target creature gets +0/+4 ueot)
(T) School of Piranha (3/3, at the beginning of my upkeep, sac ~ unless I pay 1U)
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(T) Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors
RFG:
Limited 6
Hand: 5
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Wood Elves (1/1)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught
RFG:
L
Limited
Guest
Carnophage blocks Shield Mate
Ephemeron blocks School of Piranha
Wood Elves blocks Merfolk Looter
Pygmy Troll blocks Charging Paladin
Zealots En-Dal blocks Rootwater Alligator
Unblocked:
Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(U) Forest
(T) Shield Mate (1/1, sac ~: target creature gets +0/+4 ueot)
(T) School of Piranha (3/3, at the beginning of my upkeep, sac ~ unless I pay 1U)
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(T) Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors
RFG:
Limited 6
Hand: 4
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Wood Elves (1/1)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught
RFG:
Ephemeron blocks School of Piranha
Wood Elves blocks Merfolk Looter
Pygmy Troll blocks Charging Paladin
Zealots En-Dal blocks Rootwater Alligator
Unblocked:
Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(U) Forest
(T) Shield Mate (1/1, sac ~: target creature gets +0/+4 ueot)
(T) School of Piranha (3/3, at the beginning of my upkeep, sac ~ unless I pay 1U)
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(T) Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors
RFG:
Limited 6
Hand: 4
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Wood Elves (1/1)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught
RFG:
L
Limited
Guest
Sure. Damage on the stack
Do you have effects?
Do you have effects?
L
Limited
Guest
Kor Chant. I'll redirect the damage from Pygmy Troll to the Dauthi Cutthroat
L
Limited
Guest
Damage resolves?
Yep, so this is what I have:
You take 1 from the Cutthroat.
The only creature who dies from your side is the Wood Elves.
My Shield Mate & School of Piranha die.
Forest, Done.
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(U) Forest
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(T) Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors, Forest, Shield Mate, School of Piranha
RFG:
Limited 5
Hand: 4
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught, Wood Elves
RFG:
You take 1 from the Cutthroat.
The only creature who dies from your side is the Wood Elves.
My Shield Mate & School of Piranha die.
Forest, Done.
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(U) Forest
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(T) Dauthi Cutthroat (1/1, shadow, 1B,T: destroy target creature with shadow)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors, Forest, Shield Mate, School of Piranha
RFG:
Limited 5
Hand: 4
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught, Wood Elves
RFG:
L
Limited
Guest
The Cutthroat also dies; is has two damage redirected to it.
Oops, right, Still Done.
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(U) Forest
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors, Forest, Shield Mate, School of Piranha, Dauthi Cutthroat
RFG:
Limited 5
Hand: 4
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught, Wood Elves
RFG:
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(U) Forest
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors, Forest, Shield Mate, School of Piranha, Dauthi Cutthroat
RFG:
Limited 5
Hand: 4
In Play:
(TT) 2x Swamp
(TU) 2x Forest
(TU) 2x Plains
(TTT) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(S) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(S) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught, Wood Elves
RFG:
L
Limited
Guest
Actually, you aren't allowed to play anymore lands. You can only play ten per game..
Untap, Upkeep - paying 1 life -
Attack with E and Carnophage
Blocks?
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors, Forest, Shield Mate, School of Piranha, Dauthi Cutthroat
RFG:
Limited 4
Hand: 3
In Play:
(UU) 2x Swamp
(UU) 2x Forest
(UU) 2x Plains
(UUU) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(T) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(T) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(U) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught, Wood Elves, Kor Chant
RFG:
Untap, Upkeep - paying 1 life -
Attack with E and Carnophage
Blocks?
Spidey 10
Hand: 1
In Play:
(U,U) Plains x2
(T,U,U) Island x3
(T,U) Swamp x2
(U,U) Mt x2
(T) Merfolk Looter (1/1)
(U) Mogg Assassin (2/1, T: You and I each choose a target creature that the other controls. Flip a coin. Whoever wins the flip destroys the target creature they chose)
(U) Keeper of Light (1/2, W,T: I gain 3 life. I can only play this ability if I have less life than you)
(T) Charging Paladin (2/2, when ~ attacks, it gets +0/+3 ueot)
(T) Rootwater Alligator (3/2, sac a forest: regen ~)
Graveyard: Aether Tide, Dauthi Jackal, Rootwater Mystic, Sonic Burst, Whiptongue Frog, Robe of Mirrors, Forest, Shield Mate, School of Piranha, Dauthi Cutthroat
RFG:
Limited 4
Hand: 3
In Play:
(UU) 2x Swamp
(UU) 2x Forest
(UU) 2x Plains
(UUU) 3x Island
(U) Mountain
(T) Carnophage (2/2, upkeep: tap or pay 1 life)
(U) Pygmy Troll (1/1, G:regen, gets +1/+1 for each blocker)
(U) Zealots En-Dal (2/4, upkeep - if all nonland permanents you control are white, you gain 1 life)
(T) Ephemeron (4/4 flying, discard a card: return to hand)
(U) Skyshroud Elite (1/1)
Graveyard: Thrull Surgeon, Cursed Flesh, Allay, Robe of Mirrors, Onslaught, Wood Elves, Kor Chant
RFG:
L
Limited
Guest
Damage on the stack?