Mindmaster Apocalypse: Spiderman vs Limited

Limited

Yes, but we won't care
Before we start bidding life, I have a question:

What happens if somebody plays a Whirlpool creature? Do you lose your hand (is it shuffled into your no-existent library and never see them again) or do we ignore the effect?

Opinion?
 

Spiderman

CPA Man in Tights, Dopey Administrative Assistant
Staff member
Ignore the effect since there isn't a library.

PMed my bid to Ransac
 

Ransac

CPA Trash Man
Spiderman bids 2 life
Limited bids 3 life, will start at 17 and play first.


Ransac, cpa trash man
 

Limited

Yes, but we won't care
Excellent!

Island, Ceta Disciple

Done

Limited 17
Handsize 14
In play:

(T) Island

(S) Ceta Disciple (1/1 - R, T: target crit gets +2/+0 ueot. G,T: Add one mana of any color)

Graveyard:

Spiderman 20
Handsize 15
In play:


Graveyard:
 

Spiderman

CPA Man in Tights, Dopey Administrative Assistant
Staff member
Good luck!

Swamp, Done

Limited 17
Handsize 14
In play:

(T) Island

(S) Ceta Disciple (1/1 - R, T: target crit gets +2/+0 ueot. G,T: Add one mana of any color)

Graveyard:

Spiderman 20
Handsize 15
In play:

(U) Swamp

Graveyard:
 

Limited

Yes, but we won't care
You too!

Attack with Disciple

Mountain
Whirlpool Warrior

Done.

Limited 17
Handsize 14
In play:

(T) Island
(T) Mountain

(T) Ceta Disciple (1/1 - R, T: target crit gets +2/+0 ueot. G,T: Add one mana of any color)
(S) Whirlpool Warrior (1/1 Whirling)

Graveyard:

Spiderman 19?
Handsize 15
In play:

(U) Swamp

Graveyard:
 

Spiderman

CPA Man in Tights, Dopey Administrative Assistant
Staff member
Take it.

Untap, upkeep

Forest
Llanowar Dead

Done.

Limited 17
Handsize 14
In play:

(T) Island
(T) Mountain

(T) Ceta Disciple (1/1 - R, T: target crit gets +2/+0 ueot. G,T: Add one mana of any color)
(S) Whirlpool Warrior (1/1 Whirling)

Graveyard:

Spiderman 19
Handsize 14
In play:

(T) Swamp
(T) Forest

(S) Llanowar Dead (2/2, T: add B to your mana pool)

Graveyard:
 

Limited

Yes, but we won't care
Untap, Upkeep

Swamp

Attack with Whirlpool Warrior

Blocks? Responses?

Limited 17
Handsize 14
In play:

(U) Island
(U) Swamp
(U) Mountain

(U) Ceta Disciple (1/1 - R, T: target crit gets +2/+0 ueot. G,T: Add one mana of any color)
(T) Whirlpool Warrior (1/1 Whirling)

Graveyard:

Spiderman 19
Handsize 14
In play:

(T) Swamp
(T) Forest

(S) Llanowar Dead (2/2, T: add B to your mana pool)

Graveyard:
 

Limited

Yes, but we won't care
You take 1 damage.

After combat, I'll play Mind Extraction, sacrificing the Whirlpool Warrior.
You reveal your hand and discard all blue cards

*Limited crosses fingers to see a Cromat*

After that, I'm done.

Limited 17
Handsize 12
In play:

(T) Island
(T) Swamp
(T) Mountain

(U) Ceta Disciple (1/1 - R, T: target crit gets +2/+0 ueot. G,T: Add one mana of any color)

Graveyard: Whirlpool Warrior, Mind Extraction

Spiderman 18
Handsize 14
In play:

(T) Swamp
(T) Forest

(S) Llanowar Dead (2/2, T: add B to your mana pool)

Graveyard:
 

Spiderman

CPA Man in Tights, Dopey Administrative Assistant
Staff member
Crap, that's a heck of a lot of cards. You got Temporal Spring (I wasn't sure if that was going to work anyway - probably not), Living Airship, Jilt, Jaded Response, Squee's Revenge, Minotaur Illusionist, and AEther Mutatation.

Untap, upkeep, Plains, tap out and the Dead for Angelfire Crusader, Done.

Limited 17
Handsize 12
In play:

(T) Island
(T) Swamp
(T) Mountain

(U) Ceta Disciple (1/1 - R, T: target crit gets +2/+0 ueot. G,T: Add one mana of any color)

Graveyard: Whirlpool Warrior, Mind Extraction

Spiderman 18
Handsize 6
In play:

(T) Swamp
(T) Forest
(T) Plains

(T) Llanowar Dead (2/2, T: add B to your mana pool)
(S) Angelfire Crusader (2/2, R: ~ gets +1/+0 ueot)

Graveyard: Temporal Spring, Living Airship, Jilt, Jaded Response, Squee's Revenge, Minotaur Illusionist, AEther Mutatation
 

Limited

Yes, but we won't care
Lucky guess on my part :D

I actually get to see your other cards as well.

I think the Temporal Spring should work; its kinda like Condemn (which does work) only a heck of a lot better. The original article referred to keeping true to the idea of card.. so Condemn removes an attacking creature and Temporal Spring removes a permanent.

Perhaps we should make some rules concerning library interaction. Like, you start out with a library with no cards. Everytime you would draw a card, you may choose a basic land card from outside the game and put it into your hand.
This way, if cards end up in your library, you are able to get them back. But, then again, this might be too nasty with cards that put your stuf on the bottom of your library.

I'll wait to see the rest of your hand before taking my turn
 

Spiderman

CPA Man in Tights, Dopey Administrative Assistant
Staff member
Hmmm... we can try it. Maybe then the "draw card" cards won't be as dead in the game. Just start out with a library of 0.

Here's my whole pack since it doesn't matter:

Anavolver
AEther Mutation
Minotaur Illusionist
Squee's Revenge
Angelfire Crusader
Consume Strength
Glade Gnarr
Jaded Response
Jilt
Last Caress
Living Airship
Llanowar Dead
Savage Gorilla
Tahngarth's Glare
Temporal Spring
 

Limited

Yes, but we won't care
Untap, Upkeep

Plains

Coastal Drake.

Done.

Limited 17
Handsize 12
In play:

(T) Plains
(T) Island
(T) Swamp
(U) Mountain

(U) Ceta Disciple (1/1 - R, T: target crit gets +2/+0 ueot. G,T: Add one mana of any color)
(S) Coastal Drake (2/1, 1U,T: Return target Kavu to its owner's hand)

Graveyard: Whirlpool Warrior, Mind Extraction

Spiderman 18
Handsize 6
In play:

(T) Swamp
(T) Forest
(T) Plains

(T) Llanowar Dead (2/2, T: add B to your mana pool)
(S) Angelfire Crusader (2/3, R: ~ gets +1/+0 ueot)

Graveyard: Temporal Spring, Living Airship, Jilt, Jaded Response, Squee's Revenge, Minotaur Illusionist, AEther Mutatation
 

Spiderman

CPA Man in Tights, Dopey Administrative Assistant
Staff member
Untap, Upkeep

Swamp
Attack with the Crusader... response/blocks?

Limited 17
Handsize 12
In play:

(T) Plains
(T) Island
(T) Swamp
(U) Mountain

(U) Ceta Disciple (1/1 - R, T: target crit gets +2/+0 ueot. G,T: Add one mana of any color)
(S) Coastal Drake (2/1, 1U,T: Return target Kavu to its owner's hand)

Graveyard: Whirlpool Warrior, Mind Extraction

Spiderman 18
Handsize 6
In play:

(U) Swamp
(U) Forest
(U) Plains

(U) Llanowar Dead (2/2, T: add B to your mana pool)
(T) Angelfire Crusader (2/3, R: ~ gets +1/+0 ueot)

Graveyard: Temporal Spring, Living Airship, Jilt, Jaded Response, Squee's Revenge, Minotaur Illusionist, AEther Mutatation
 

Spiderman

CPA Man in Tights, Dopey Administrative Assistant
Staff member
Tap BGW for Consume Strength, giving your Disciple -2/-2 and my Crusader +2/+2. Damage resolves?
 
Top