If you were stranded with one deck...

[Notepad]

If you were stranded on a desert island and could only take one deck with you, what would it be?

And yes, assume there may be another person and they will have a deck, but you have no idea what it is. Oh, and you can't have sex with the other person because it's opposite your orientation, so you may want to pack a few boobie cards in your deck, like Visara.

 

[Spiderman]

My Manabarbs deck.

 

[Notepad]

I would bring the only obvious choice: Rhinoseeker.

 

[train]

The B/W/G/r utility deck I have...

 

[Spiderman]

I know we'd have a good time train, our decks were a good match last time we played

 

[train]

Yep...

I need mana - and it hurts every time I try to use it with a barbs out!...

 

[Killer Joe]

RGW – Powerstone Control a.k.a. “The Seinfeld Deck” (because it about nothing)

Creatures (0)

Spells (40)
1. Abundance
4. Burning Wish
1. Cursed Totem
1. Enlightened Tutor
1. Fire Diamond
2. Gaea’s Blessing
1. Ivory Tower
1. Jayemdae Tome
2. Living Wish
1. Marble Diamond
1. Memory Jar
4. Moment’s Peace
1. Moss Diamond
1. Phyrexian Furnace
4. Powerstone Minefield
2. Rampant Growth
4. Renewed Faith
4. Seal of Cleansing
1. Sol Ring
1. Sylvan Library
2. Sylvan Scrying

Land (21)
3. Forest
1. Kor Haven
2. Mountain
1. Nantuko Monastery
2. Plains
2. Plateau
3. Savannah
1. Shivan Gorge
2. Taiga
2. Windswept Heath
2. Wooded Foothills

SB://
1. Balance
1. Barbarian Ring
1. Decree of Justice
1. Eternal Dragon
1. Fanning the Flames
1. Flashfires
1. Lavaborn Muse
1. Mageta the Lion
1. Meltdown
1. Regrowth
1. Rout
1. Savage Twister
1. Spitting Spider
1. Tsunami
1. Wheel of Fortune

 

[Reverend Love]

A normal deck of playing cards with naked ladies on them.

 

[train]

I do have a set of Magic card backed - playing cards...

Given to original judge newbies...

 

[Istanbul]

I'd create and bring my W/G FattyFat deck from MTGO.

 

[orgg]

I'd bring my 'Richard' deck.

I can't help but love pulling out my Big, Furry Monster and slapping people upside the head with it.

 

[Istanbul]

Originally posted by orgg
I can't help but love pulling out my Big, Furry Monster and slapping people upside the head with it.

Never, ever, EVER post that again in any forum, ever.

 

[orgg]

...but that's most of the fun of my Richard deck-- I pull out my Big Furry Monster and try to hit my opponent with it while I've got a War Chariot's effect on it. One hit and it's game over. Sadly, I've seen it explode in my face WAAAY too many times. Humble, Boomerang one side of it, Unsummon all of it, Reverse Damage it, Eye-for-a-Friggin'-Eye-ing it... So many things have been done to my Big Furry Monster to keep it away from my opponent's heads. I think only three opponents didn't scapegoat any of the damage and had to take it all...

I enjoy my Richard deck quite a bit.

 

[Mr_Pestilence]

Definitely my all foil Dragon deck.

 

[Spiderman]

orgg: It seems you need to give it some untargetability or something... Not sure if Lightning Greaves will work on both parts, so maybe the blanket Dense Foliage or something...

 

[train]

or just run 2 greaves to put on each half...

but rules-wise 1 should work fine for it...

 

[Notepad]

Its one critter. You should only have to use one enchant creature or one equipment. The only time there's two cards involved is in putting the creature card together for casting. I think even usuing bounce will target the creature as a whole, not one half.

Then again, I'm hoping the other person stranded with me is Jon Lovitz, so I can beat him over the head with a coconut. Not much magic playing for me, unless of course I sever his head and paint a WILSON hand-face on it and play Magic against that.

 

[Rooser]

It's and interesting question, but I'll just cheat and say I'll bring my "entire collection" deck.

 

[Notepad]

Hmm, yes, my five color wish deck could do the same thing.

I shall bring my five color wish deck...and its sideboard.

 

[train]

Watch it rooser - someone might play a thief deck - and "steal" the "entire collection deck"