Do me a favor?

[orgg]

http://www.garageband.com/song?|pe1|S8LTM0LdsaSvZ1myYQ

Download this .MP3 file of the song, and critique it honestly from any points you can take.

Feel very free to be harsh, complementary, or any mix of the two-- HONESTY is the most important thought, not TACT.

Tact is not that appriciated, as a matter of fact-- directness will be.

Thank ya'll.

 

[Nightstalkers]

would this be your band?

Would you like us to be harsh, or just plain mean?

how big is this file anyways? the thing doesn't respond.

 

[orgg]

I won't say my level of involvement with the band.

However, when you right click and download on the little strip that says "download," the file is about five megs for a five minute song.

 

[TomB]

But overall not too bad. Consider the source, of course, but I think they should pick up the pace a bit. The visual effects were kinda cool...

 

[Almindhra]

Darnit, the dl didn't work for me...

And here I was going to be direct and honest....

 

[Svenmonkey]

Didn't work for me, either.

 

[sageridder]

Ya'll do realize you have an option to just play it instead of download to the right.To me this had a greatfull dead feel, maybe even some neil young infulence.Could see this being proformed somewhere you'd see the flower children dancin round.Good overall. But to be direct there felt like a couple of times the guitarist and drummer should have taken more advantage of oppertunitys to spotlight a little bit more individually.The vocals were good as well but I would have to hear more tracks to give an honest opion on them.All in all I liked it I would love to hear more espically if tunes that get the people movin were added to the mix with mellower tunes like this. A bit more of a southern rock kind of feel.I think this band has the potential to be more than your local bar band.Good luck.