Mooseman said:
I thought you couldn't respond to the chaosroll?
I don't think there's a stack or priority during the ChaosPhase, which is why you can't play spells or abilities. But I think the Shield Ctrs are mandatory and a replacement effect so they work.
So I have to use 2 Shield Ctrs during your attack since it's two sources dealing dmg.
My ChaosRoll is #29 "Simplicity's Reward" - All players gain 1 life for each basic land they have in play. All players take 1 dmg for each non-basic land they have in play.
I gain 2 but lose 1.
You gain 3.
Untap, upkeep - use Guile, Draw
Ernham Djinn
Done
Your ChaosRoll is #190 "Wanna Bet?" - Pick an opponent and a card they control. They pick one of yours. Flip a coin. Winner gets control of the loser's card.
I'll CounterRoll it.
EnchantWorld #14 "Helm of Awakening" - All spells cost 1 generic mana less to cast.
Spidey: 16
Hand: 2
Library: 47
In Play:
(U) Karplusan Forest (R/G Pain land)
(T) Mt
(T) Forest
Mirri's Guile (At the beginning of my upkeep, I may look at the top 3 cards of my library and put them back in any order)
(T)
Fellwar Stone (T: Add to my mana pool one mana of any color that a land Mooseman controls could produce)
(U)
Winter Orb (As long as ~ is untapped, players can't untap more than one land during their untap step)
(T)
Birds of Paradise (0/1, flying, T: Add one color of any mana to my mana pool)
(S)
Ernham Djinn (4/5, At the beginning of my upkeep, target non-Wall creature Mooseman controls gains forestwalk ueot)
Graveyard: Winter Orb, Blastoderm, Birds of Paradise, Wild Mongrel
RFG:
Mooseman: 17
Hand: 2
Library: 57
In Play:
(UUU) Forest x2
(T)
Squirrel Token (1/1)
(T)
Squirrel Token (1/1)
Graveyard: Wonder, Wonder, Rites of Refusal, Rites of Refusal, Cephalid Coliseum
RFG:Chatter of the Squirrel