Search results

Thanks for the heads-up.

Peer Through Depths and Tenza.

I thought you might have something... I'm done. DF Life: 7 Hand: 2 In Play: (T, T) Island x 2 (T) Swamp Graveyard:Hypnotic Specter,Recoilx2,Rescind,Boomerangx2, Man O Warx2, Doomsday Specter x 2, mind twist, Abyssal Specter,Demonic Tutor, Upheaval, Warped Devotion, Rescind, Island x 4...

Well, there was a third option I listed: I just give you guys shuffled decks and you play on the honor system. But I can give out the draws, no prob... except on weekends when I'm not on.

Why? To me, they come across as scornful, insulting, and condescending. How does that help any critique?

Oversoul: See, now THAT is more like it. Your explanation goes a long way in helping me redefine my "gut feeling". The only thing I have a slight issue with is that I'm not arguing at all that you can't substitute 2 generic mana for a colored mana in multicolored cards - that's just goofy and...

I'm tending to agree. The sentence of the last two paragraphs are a bit unnecessary.

"Gut feeling" says it's overpowered for the cost... I think someone could find a way to use it in a "low cc" deck. And probably should add the clause "shuffle all cards revealed back into the library".

I think it's okay.

Well, I think you and DUke (to a lesser extent) have made the best explanations of how colored mana and generic mana relate to each other in terms of cc and effects.

You get 5 arrows back out of 6.

Looks like it's up to DarthFerret then... :)

Well, seeing how it comes from CHK which does deal with spirits extensively, it seems reasonable that spirits are involved with the Orchard, especially since it's "forbidden". But maybe it's also in the novel that explains the connection.

How do you know FoWS hasn't played enough Magic then at the time(as your statement implies)? Why does "playing enough Magic" make you so certain that colored mana doesn't equal twice the generic (as in this case)? Is it your "gut feeling" also? You're pointing out a "fact" that may not be...

Actually, I think they did... players get "appearance fees" at the upper tiers, so I think that means they get paid if they just show up, not for their performance...

(Actually, there is no "calling shots" in Basic. I just put that in the combat to make it more descriptive since you can't actually see me rolling dice :) )

Just a cloak with a cowl or hood as before. No helm.

They're wearing the same as the other group you encounter: plate and they were carrying shields.

Feral Deceiver

DarthFerret raised a question... how do you want to play the game? Do you want me to give out draws since you guys aren't on that often? Or an Excel spreadsheet that hides the library? Or just give you guys a shuffled library and be on the honor system?