Search results

Limner, you're right, and it's a point I made in a submission to the Dojo a couple of months ago. With the current state of Type 1, they oughta' either restrict everything (Highlander) or they should unrestrict/unban everything, except, of course, the ante cards and things like Divine...

Hey, did anybody notice they didn't post your rebuttal Tony? It seems that the Dojo is perfectly willing to let Mr. Chen have the last word. Amazing, huh? Any ideas on what we should do? TomB CPA Member "I do not teach. I simply reveal." -Daudi, Femeref tutor

Bane, That looks much better. In fact, I'd say it's just terrific. Good work. TomB CPA Member "-I wish I knew how to do stuff like that."

I agree with you, Limner, that the 6E rules changes pertaining to creature damage during combat don't entirely make sense now. While I can live with the idea of a tapped defender doing combat damage anyway, I totally agree with you on the issue of creatures no longer in play still dealing combat...

Maybe he wants us to buy him flowers. TomB CPA Member "I do not teach. I simply reveal." -Daudi, Femeref Tutor

It seems to me, everyone, that Mr. Chen gives lie to what he is saying from the start, when he claims his initial article wasn't targetting our group in the first place. Then, instead of allowing Tony to rebut his statements and let it lie, he launches into another tirade attempting to...

That is an incredible piece of work. If people don't get it now, they're too dense to see the sense. Thank you, Tony TomB CPA Member "I do not teach. I simply reveal." -Daudi, Femeref Tutor

Why bother with guidelines? If someone has a tournament grade deck to submit they'll send it to the Dojo, not here. I don't really have a problem with a casual deck that wins sometimes too. Winning sometimes is actually kinda' fun. Maybe the deck submissions could be sorted through and grouped...

Sorry Dune Echo. The New Wave home page's URL is http://www.newwave.org/. I looked at it earlier tonight but they haven't posted anything about us yet, outside of the Baron's original article. They've usually got some great box prices for Magic ($63.99) and they're singles prices usually aren't...

Repeal, Repeal. Return Waylay to it's much cooler form. And yes, Baron, please forward the tally to WotC. They'll need to get used to the idea of hearing from us. TomB CPA Member "I do not teach. I simply reveal." -Daudi, Femeref Tutor

Actually, nekrataal, he said he "had been THINKING about writing an article like this ever since Bill Rose's letter..." Judging by what he wrote, it sounds to me like he should have given it a little more thought. TomB CPA Member "I do not teach. I simply reveal." -Daudi, Femeref Tutor

Waubers, Casual for the purpose of what, exactly? It was my impression we are a non-exclusive group, dedicated to preserving the game we love to play, and we include everyone who considers themselves casual to be a part of it. I too, occasionally play in store tourneys, but I always try to have...

Did anybody catch Kevin Chen's reply to your reply Tony? He seems to be taking issue with our taking issue with his taking issue with us, and claims he wasn't taking issue with the CPA in the first place! How could anyone read his original article and NOT know it was aimed directly at the CPA...

Hey, I've got an idea! How about a Magic-D&D module to use as a solitare variant for Magic. You make your way through a maze, or a dungeon, killing off monsters using your cards and solving problems along the way. You'd have to memorize (deckbuild) a variety of spells for the different problems...

That's because we, the Vocal Minority of the Forgotten Majority, have migrated here, where we're hoping to be taken seriously. All that seems left to the Dojo Forums are the Deck Techs building for an even more boring Pro Tour (if that's possible!), and the whiners who want anything decent...

Zadok is right. If we're trying to get WotC's attention, the more people we can get signed up and voting the better. If we can form up a significant enough voting block, WotC will have no choice BUT to listen to us. TomB CPA Member "I do not teach. I simply reveal." -Daudi, Femeref Tutor

Put me down as a vote to repeal the Waylay errata. TomB CPA Member "I'll have ketchup on those fries, Ed"

Faxe, It sounds like Spellfire's the game for you! It didn't sell well here in the States, so I'm sure you could work out a deal with WotC to distribute it in Brazil. I'm sure they'd love to get rid of it! Seriously though, TSR tried that with Spellfire and no one liked it. I doubt WotC would...

I'm not so much mad at all the rule changes either. In fact, I was very much in favor of dealing with triggered effects at instant speed, and death at 0 life. The mana pool deal is the way I've always played it. I do have a bit of a problem with the concept of creatures dealing damage even if...

Dune Echo, I agree with you. Part of the package we were presented when they first announced the rule changes was that even though some things would work differently (like triggered effects) we wouldn't care, because the new rules would change the way other cards would work. It was supposed to...