Search results

Still waiting for any other input. If no replies by tomorrow, we'll/I'll :) decide something.

Take it.

Clearly you know about this and have done some research, but frankly, what you said pretty much corroborates what I said, in that you may have thought you were "correct" and in the right of its usage but what I read it as was very much different. Exactly. This is probably the closest to...

All right guys. Should we play it "safe" and just have a frontline of three fighters, rotating in when one needs healing, or go "all in" and use four fighters with one trapped and committed? I'm kinda thinking the first option, at least for a couple of rounds to see how it goes, and maybe move...

Oh lordy. More semantics that keep derailing the thread... Actually, no. "Used to" implies that it did work in the past, stopped at some point, and started up again. That's really how everyone talks.

I had to go back and read what was happening, because I was going to ask a question about height advantage, but I see the Shambler is on the wall with us. So my new question is if a Warrior moves next to it, does he get a flanking bonus?

Are you saying if we do not try to go around the wall, only three of us can attack at a time?

Right, that's what I meant :rolleyes: Forgot the "Declare" between the "during" and "attackers" as part of your quote. This is where an actual conversation would be useful, because while I understand the above, that's what I was saying from the beginning. So all you had to do was seemingly...

yes, I know. What I don't know is why you said "but not During Attackers..." Untap, upkeep, Draw Plains Done Spidey: 12 Hand: 3 Library: 49 Battlefield: (U,U) Island x2 (U,U) Plains x2 (U) Field of Ruin (T: Add C to my mana pool.; 2, T, Sac ~: Destroy target nonbasic land that Oversoul...

I'm not sure I understand what you said here. If it was in reply to You can't cast sorceries at any time during the Combat Phase (which includes Declare Attackers). I guess I don't understand what you're saying "but not" in response to. No response to Kari Zev (I'm tapped out after...

Draw and discard Forest Use Elite's ability again. Responses? Spidey: 99 Dmg from Commander: 8/21 Hand: 3 Library: 42 Commander Zone (cast twice): UBRG Battlefield: (T,T) Swamp x2 (T,T) Island x2 (T,T) Mt x2 (T,T) Forest x2 (U) Savage Lands (~ ETB tapped.; T: Add B, R, or G to my mana...

Maximize Velocity on the Packbeast Responses? Spidey: 17 Hand: 6 Battlefield: (T,T) Swamp x2 (T,T) Mt x2 (U) Island (T) Forest (T) Plains (U) Selesnya Guildgate (~ ETB tapped.; T: Add G or W to my mana pool) Street Riot (As long as it's my turn, creatures I control get +1/+0 and have...

turgy22: Ah, okay, I understand now.

Still during your EOT, after all of that resolves, I assume you pass priority since you said Done so I use my Elite's ability. Responses?

Well, there kind of is. It's committing you to the Combat Phase; if I cast it before then. you could still "do stuff" (cast Sorceries mainly) and then go to Combat. Here, since we're in Combat already, you're limited to the instants and similar effects. Yes, I take 1.

When it ETB, targets the Restorer and Challenger. Responses?

Well, if we're getting into the rules explanation, the Combat Phase has five steps: Beginning of Combat Declare Attackers Declare Blockers Combat Damage End of Combat The Beginning of Combat Step is the first opportunity to cast/use effects as appropriate, with the Active Player getting...

"I became displeased with a series of moderator decisions and left." Yes, that's pretty much how I remember it. If this was 2006, it was probably over HOUTS and whether a ban was truly necessary or just "ignore him" so he had nothing to respond to. As it turned out, Ed implemented a new...

Well, I cast on your Declare Attack (Phase - sorry if that wasn't clear - not Declare Attackers). So it would just be the Firebrand who is actually present for the Declare Attackers.

I don't think it's "well-established" - that's what Mueller is trying to find out. I think the evidence that has been made public so far is showing signs leading to it though. Are you referring to Istanbul? I think he more quit because of differences of opinion among the mods here of how to...