Search results

I think it's a good idea. However: 1) Who's gonna volunteer to choose each "classic" article? 2) It sounds like it's gonna be taken from previous articles submitted to the CPA. Which I hate to say, but I think the number of articles to choose from is gonna be pretty low (which may be okay if...

I don't care either Melkor. You make the call :)

I agree. This is all from my perspective. But then, there also can't be complaints that the nominating pool is so small...

Take it. Untap, upkeep Mt Ordruun Commando Done Spidey: 19 Hand: 12 In Play: (T) Forest (T) Plains (T) Swamp (T) Mt (U) Watchwolf (3/3) (S) Ordruun Commando (4/1, W: Prevent the next 1 dmg that would be dealt to ~ this turn) Graveyard: Clinging Darkness RFG: Mooseman: 17 Hand: 12 In...

But that usually doesn't happen with the second nomination. It's just "I second the nomination of <this card>." That doesn't give any additional info to me and thus no additional weight when considering.

Yeah, sorry, I lost my deck and have to re-create it... I'll get it in tomorrow.

Done. Spidey: 20 Hand: 13 In Play: (U) Forest (T) Plains (T) Swamp (T) Watchwolf (3/3) Graveyard: Clinging Darkness RFG: Mooseman: 17 Hand: 13 In Play: (U) Plains (T) Island (T) Swamp (S) Lurking Informant, (1/2, 2, T: Look at the top card of target player's library. You may put that...

Attack with the Watchwolf Responses/blocks? Spidey: 20 Hand: 13 In Play: (U) Forest (T) Plains (T) Swamp (T) Watchwolf (3/3) Graveyard: Clinging Darkness RFG: Mooseman: 20 Hand: 13 In Play: (U) Plains (T) Island (T) Swamp (S) Lurking Informant, (1/2, 2, T: Look at the top card of target...

Whoa. That was a quick first game.

Yeah, I take 2. Untap, upkeep Plains Pyrotechnics all of your guys Attack with the Dragonfly and Horseman for 3 Done DarthFerret Life: 16 Hand: 11 In Play: (T,T) Swamp x 2 (T) Plains (T) Forest (T) Island Enchant: Gaseous Form (prevent all combat damage dealt to and from <this>)...

As a member, I've never considered a card nominated multiple times any different from a card nominated a single time. But I obviously can't speak for any other committee member... :)

Apparently you posted at the same time as turgy22. If you equip the Sword, it gives Finkel pro-blue and thus the Treachery comes off...

No prob...

Untap, upkeep Swamp Clinging Darkness your Wight Responses? Spidey: 20 Hand: 13 In Play: (U) Forest (T) Plains (T) Swamp (U) Watchwolf (3/3) Graveyard: Clinging Darkness? RFG: Mooseman: 20 Hand: 13 In Play: (U) Plains (T) Island (T) Swamp (U) Roofstalker Wight (2/1 Zombie 1U: Roofstalker...

Untap, upkeep, Draw Attack with the Spirit Responses/blocks? Flying White (28) Limited's library: 41 Oversoul's library: 40 Limited's hand: 4 Oversoul's hand: 7 Limited's in-play: (UUUTT) 5x Plains (U) Marble Diamond (tap to add W) (U) Marble Diamond (tap to add W) Empyrial Armor [Enchanted...

But that would mean the committee is basically useless, as "outside" people would get a vote (or near to it). All a nomination should be is just a card. I think even if you like the current nominees, either you refrain if you don't like any of the other cards from the set (or don't think of...

I think the main problem is that there's not enough cards being nominated (and some nominations are doubled, which doesn't make sense to me since a card is just listed in the nominations as once, not twice, and has no bearing on the vote. So the second nomination might as well be for another...

In response, I'll tap RGU and cast Flames of the Blood Hand, targeting you. Responses? Resolves?

Rocky Interview...

Yeah, I think turgy22 thought the roll of 6 was for you also. I corrected it. My right guy moves down. Rolled a 1 for Mooseman