Search results

I don't know... But why Diving Griffin?

Oh, agreed, except that the four card rule is more than just a tourney-imposed limit. Using the restricted list is playing Type I, even if it's not tournament play. You could do it in a casual manner, sure. That's not what I'm talking about though. I'm talking about the format known as casual...

No, Chant is past Prophecy. In fact, I'm not sure as to what the reason for Therapy not being in there is. Maybe he thinks that there are enough ways to kill Rector already, but Therapy is the best one, even if it is from a newer set...

I dispute that. The greatest point about Lake is that it taps to produce FOUR mana for the price of a swamp. Being legendary is just icing on the cake. But the card is great... Why not include a Necropotence or something? It looks like that would work...

But it's cool and a fun deck to play...

It was in no danger of being broken... If they meant nontoken, they'd have said it when it was printed. It wasn't left out in any sense except maybe they realized the card would have some use if it were allowed to use tokens. The errata on Great Whale/etc. was to stop them from being broken...

That's why Fork would be so fun: it's a challenge. Regrowth would just be insane though, I'd think. You could keep digging stuff out of your graveyard, so that you could use it whenever, not just during your upkeep...

Yes, increase land count...

I didn't say that the banned/restricted list serves no purpose. What I meant was that it is a list for Type I or Type 1.5. Criticizing someone for posting a casual decklist that uses multiple copies of cards that are restricted in Type I, on that basis, seems to be a bit uncasual though...

I'd imagine some would, if they wanted to... They do have some advantages over dual lands, etc., however minor those might be... What might be more fun though... Restrict mountain!

I gave up on trying to make the game seem realistic...

Balance, Demonic Tutor, Timetwister, Ancestral Recall, Time Walk, Time Warp, Coercion, Hymn to Tourach, Soul Feast, Corrupt, Boomerang, Shahrazad, Abeyance, Lightning Bolt, etc. But what I think would be most interesting, either Fork or Regrowth...

Easy to disrupt and abusive usually don't go together in decks that aren't insanely fast or in situations where they face underpowered opponents. It's definitely fun, but what does it really win against consistently? It's not as though there's some killer deck that the errata kills, it just...

Don't see how... Yeah, Donate and Illusions weren't inteded to work that way. I call it serendipity though. Those kinds of things make the game interesting...

Yeah, then it dies and Death Watch hurts them a lot...

20 Moxen? What is it exactly that from looking at his decklist makes you think he has even one? The format is called casual. Sorry if you've never heard of it. It goes something like this though, you can use cards from Magic: the Gathering because they were meant to be played. It's not...

Trix? Pretty stable, I guess, but it definitely has its weaknesses. Why is that the one that bothers you?

Oh well, neither deck uses Snowfall anyway...

Is is Cyber?

Oh, Thought Prison, I thought you meant Icy Prison, for some reason... I think I lost to this card once, when I was doing badly already. It's not just good against mono-color decks...