Search results

But what about those other things I mentioned in post #46? Surely you're not saying that cost-benefit analysis falls entirely under the umbrella of "opinion."

Sen Triplets looks fun...

UUD, Serra's Embrace on Highway Robber, done. Spidey: 9 Hand: 1 Library: 43 In Play: (T,U,U) Plains x3 (T,U,U,U) Island x4 Armored Ascension (Enchanted creature gets +1/+1 for each Plains I control and has flying) (U) Honor Guard (4/4, flying, W: ~ gets +0/+1 ueot) *Ascended* *Contaminated* (U)...

What do people think of these borderposts? They seem decent.

Thraximundar has a cool name and could be a lot of fun. Time Sieve is the one that's caught my eye, though. How to break it...

Uh, I'm not sure what you mean. Would you agree that it's possible for something to be all about opinion, not at all about opinion, or about opinion and some combination of other things?

And one of my points was that opinion doesn't vanish with increasing sample size. Increasing the sample size would solve problems associated with one or two oddballs skewing things. And I absolutely agree that it would give better results. But it wouldn't be lessening the effect of opinion at...

You're quoting snippets from a comparatively large post. I'd like to think I said more than that. But I do believe I flat-out stated, at least once, in an earlier post that the process is subjective. I don't know about "revolving" around opinions. I'm not quite sure what that means. What I did...

Yeah, I could see that. If someone were to consider the tiny group we have here doing a hall of fame/shame rather silly, I make no argument against that. It's all in good fun anyway, though. I mean, no one's losing sleep over this or anything. Well, that's all in where the standard is set. It...

UUD, Highway Robber (which will hit you for 2 and have me gaining 2 unless you counter it, which might happen because I see that you have a card in your hand) paying 1 for Smolder Initiate's ability to make you lose 1 life, done. Spidey: 9? Hand: 1 Library: 44 In Play: (U,U,U) Plains x3...

That leaves Mooseman and Al0ysius...

Well yeah, I think we both want more people here. I think anything we do like this, though, be it hall of shame, hall of fame, CPA notables, or whatever pretty much comes with the caveat that there's never really a big community here. Well, that's certainly different from having a differing...

UUD, Plains, done. Spidey: 12 Hand: 0 Library: 45 In Play: (U,U,U) Plains x3 (U,U,U,U) Island x4 Armored Ascension (Enchanted creature gets +1/+1 for each Plains I control and has flying) (U) Honor Guard (4/4, flying, W: ~ gets +0/+1 ueot) *Ascended* *Contaminated* (U) Drowner Initiate (1/1...

Anyone see anything particularly good? I suppose Nemesis of Reason could be used in a milling deck, but I don't really care for it. Soulquake just seems too expensive. Aven Mimeomancer could combo with some stuff, but the color combination might make it not worth the effort. Bituminous Blast is...

The part where it actually ties up the opponent's mana at all. He can hit it with a removal spell like any other creature, play something that can block it that you can't kill, play three creatures and have Mogg Squad die automatically, or do nothing for some reason (outrageously mana-screwed or...

Suntail Hawk, done. Spidey: 12 Hand: 0 Library: 46 In Play: (U,U) Plains x2 (U,U,U,U) Island x4 Armored Ascension (Enchanted creature gets +1/+1 for each Plains I control and has flying) (U) Suntail Hawk (1/1, flying) (U) Honor Guard (3/3, flying, W: ~ gets +0/+1 ueot) *Ascended*...

Damage on the stack. Both die?

Well, I wasn't expecting counters from two different people, but this doesn't work. I'll of course be paying the mana for Mooseman's Mana Leak, which means there is no Avenger...

*Cugel will collect some of the food items in small sacks, if possible, and bring them with him.*

So you kill every creature that your opponent plays and beat him to death with Mogg Squad. It wouldn't work marvelously, but it could potentially work. You know what would work better? Just burning your opponent with the burn spells. Or using another creature that does more damage (yes, most of...