Search results

Sounds good to me. That last may be unnecessary. If you're playing a 60-card deck with 30 creatures because you need support for 20 of them, you're probably at a disadvantage against opponents using only 20 creatures. I'm not sure if this would work or not. But I don't care much anyway. I've...

Genesis I was born in the 80's, so no.

Yeah, if you do draw your moxes early, you are lucky. And that luck could allow you to win the game or at least kill an opponent who would normally have kept pace with you. This is exactly why I'd prefer to just go with the Legacy banned list. Most of you haven't even been using Vintage...

No, I got that. I was just being overly particular about Spidey's "no more than 5 cards from the Vintage B/R list." Yeah, same here. I've used it myself and these are casual games after all. If I thought something we were allowing was too good, I'd raise the issue rather than trying to exploit...

Light of Day

Lose the Griffin. Done.

I'd be opposed to people using ANY cards from the Vintage banned list. I don't really feel like arguing over whether your Falling Star hit my creature. Oh, and at one point a while back, it was suggested that we have a "gentleman's agreement" about not using P9 cards, which makes sense to me and...

Thoughtseize (surgical hand removal)

Yeah, we has a label for them here too and I think it was "retard lands." But how was this a cool change? Some changes I've gotten used to, but I still prefer the old basics. They actually say what they do, like any card in the game should. I don't see how a giant mana symbol was supposed to be...

MTGO originally had nothing to do with this. The only thing we did was take the "1/3 of the deck must be creatures of the same type" thing. We were using the Vintage restricted list. Limited put the MTGO Tribal Format banned list up there later in the administration thread. I pretty much ignored...

Yes, almost a month later. I've been a bit irregular about which forums I've actually checked and my browser makes anything that's been inactive for more than 10 days hidden, so I didn't see this thread until I looked at the "old" threads. But I'm still not even sure how they're different. For...

Well, I mean, I didn't do a full count of how many original cards it has (I wasn't bothering to only list the original cards and maybe I should have?), but I'm pretty sure it has more original cards than some small sets. Some of the cards were anxiously picked up when it became a...

Yeah, I also need a deck. We need to figure out what tribes are still available. There are probably a lot, but at first glance, all the good ones look to have been used already...

So I think we have four bowmen. Can we have all four start shooting at these things or are only Kurik and I close enough? If we did manage to all hit a bee, we'd take them out before they got close enough to threaten anyone anyway, although I'm guessing we won't get that lucky...

UUD, Swamp Distress and paying 1 for Initiate's ability. Reveal your hand. Spidey: 19 Hand: 3 Library: 21 In Play: (T,T) Plains x2 (T) Honor Guard (1/1, W: ~ gets +0/+1 ueot) (T) Suntail Hawk (1/1, Flying) (S) Steadfast Guard (2/2, Vigilance) Graveyard: Soaring Hope RFG: Oversoul: 17 Hand...

I am not BigBlue, but let's see if I can do this... Which of these is worthy of the Hall of Shame? Alabaster Dragon Alluring Scent Anaconda Ancestral Memories Angelic Blessing Archangel Ardent Militia Armageddon Armored Pegasus Arrogant Vampire Assassin's Blade Balance of Power Baleful Stare...

Well, it may be what you got out of it. But it's not what I said. I know you can read. So if you want to take what I said and just decide that I must have meant something I never said, I don't know what to tell you. Huh? How does that answer or even come close to addressing my question...

Come on guys. Those gemstones wouldn't be trapped if they were worthless. They're either valuable enough to want to trap or actually important in some way. Well, I suppose it could also be that the DM wants to laugh as we go to all this effort to acquire some sugar crystals, but since the DM is...

Really? Did Apocalypse save me from you? I thought I stood a pretty good chance right before MM's turn where he cast it, since Recurring Nightmare was active and you'd already used Reins of Power (unless you had another one waiting for me). Maybe I misjudged the situation though or I'm...

Thrull Champion