I said I'd elaborate on Arcane Denial's drawback and the perception of it later. Well, it's later now. Wait, what?
Arcane Denial has its fans. A long time ago, I was in a tournament and cast it. My opponent reacted strangely and I interpreted this as him being unfamiliar with the card. I started explaining how it worked, and then he countered my Arcane Denial with his own Arcane Denial. He wasn't confused by an unfamiliar card, but rather surprised that he ran into another Arcane Denial user. Even though I got trounced in that match, it is a memory I regard fondly. We were both playing monoblue control-combo decks. His deck was actually extremely poorly positioned against mine (his deck was too slow to reliably stop my broken Academy deck), but I had such incredibly bad draws (and mulligans) that I was easily beaten in two games. But I found his deck fascinating and never saw another one like it again. It was a disruptive blue deck with Sol Ring, Thran Dynamo, Grim Monolith, and Copy Artifact generating large quantities of mana to power out Braingeyser and Stroke of Genius, eventually winning with Mind over Matter fueling Thran Dynamo mana to deck the opponent with Stroke of Genius. While this is superficially similar to Tolarian Academy combo decks, it requires more turns to set up and is more reliant on control spells. It was creative and smooth. I was impressed and almost glad that his novel concoction advanced in the tournament instead of my lazy, overpowered deck. Anyway, that was my most memorable encounter with another Arcane Denial fan. We are out there. But we're not that common.
Most players seem to consider Arcane Denial a bad card. The reason isn't hard to understand. Two words: card disadvantage. And for competitive Magic players, those are some dirty words indeed. Card advantage is an important strategic consideration in the game. Having card advantage is good. Letting the opponent have card advantage is bad. Card advantage was the secret behind the success of
The Deck. Appreciating card advantage is what separates the skilled players from the n00bz. Card advantage is love. Card advantage is life. All hail card advantage. What's the card advantage on Arcane Denial? Well, the math is simple enough to work out. You counter one spell for one card of your own, then you get one card via "slowtrip" and your opponent gets two cards the same way. Total net card advantage: -1. And that's bad. Case closed.
Force of Will also has a net card advantage of -1. But that one has extenuating circumstances! It can counter a spell for free! That's important. And it's worth the card disadvantage. Counterspell itself costs UU for a net card advantage of 0. But it's still, rightly, considered a good card because of the potency of being able to counter a spell. Changing the cost to 1U, there are other options, but they're all constrained in some way, like Remove Soul (only countering a certain kind of spell) or Mana Leak (giving the opponent the possibility of paying a price to keep the spell from being countered). Arcane Denial is a hard counter with a less severe color restriction than Counterspell. Is that worth the card disadvantage? I contend, in this case, that it is. The particular details of the card disadvantage matter. With Force of Will, you have to throw away a card from your hand, specifically a blue card. Arcane Denial doesn't force you to pay an extra cost, but just gives your opponent two cards to replace the one that was countered. Those two cards come off the top of the opponent's library, so they're random cards. But the spell you countered was presumably something important, not something random. That's the distinction. You're not just handing your opponent a card, but rather stopping a spell that you presumably
needed to stop, and replacing it with something random. And there's another factor. As a counterspell, Arcane Denial is used in one of two ways...
- On your turn to counter an instant played by your opponent.
- On your opponent's turn, to counter something that you really want to stop.
In the first case, if you're successfully countering an opponent's instant, it is very likely being done as a means to ensure that something very important to you happens, either forcing through a spell that could win you the game or stopping a desperate combat trick by your opponent. It's highly likely that an Arcane Denial you're casting on your own turn is either being cast to win you the game on that turn or to protect the card that is going to win you the game soon. And both of those are very much worth giving the opponent the option to draw two cards at the beginning of the next upkeep.
In the second case, which is more common in controlling decks, you are giving your opponent card advantage, but in addition to countering a spell, you're providing your opponent with two card draws and yourself with one
on your own next turn. The majority of cards that your opponent might draw won't do anything for your opponent until the turn after that. But you're very likely to be able to use the extra card that you drew from Arcane Denial. That constitutes tempo advantage for you! It's not anything awe-inspiring. By itself, it's not ordinarily worth the card disadvantage. You wouldn't normally play a spell that just gives you one card and your opponent two cards on your next turn. But it should definitely be considered a mitigating factor. Attached to a hard counter, I'd say it's worth consideration.