Mindmaster Kaladesh: Spidey vs Mooseman

[Spiderman]

That's 2

Forest
Salivating Gremlins

Done

Spidey: 15
Hand: 11
Energy Ctrs: EEEEEE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(U) Plains
(T) Mt
(T) Forest

(T) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(T) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(S) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 18
Hand: 11
Battlefield:

(U) Plains
(T) Swamp
(T) Island
(T) Mountain

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation
Exile:

 

[Mooseman]

UU
Forest
Attack with Bruiser
Block/response?

Spidey: 15
Hand: 11
Energy Ctrs: EEEEEE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(U) Plains
(T) Mt
(T) Forest

(T) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(T) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(S) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 18
Hand: 11
Battlefield:

(U) Plains
(U) Swamp
(U) Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation
Exile:

 

[Spiderman]

Take it

 

[Mooseman]

That's 3
Bastion Mastodon
done

Spidey: 12
Hand: 11
Energy Ctrs: EEEEEE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(U) Plains
(T) Mt
(T) Forest

(T) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(T) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(S) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 18
Hand: 10
Battlefield:

(T) Plains
(T) Swamp
(T) Island
(T) Mountain
(T) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)
(S) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation
Exile:

 

[Spiderman]

Untap, upkeep

Attack with the Hawk for 1
Plains
Consulate Surveillance

Done

Spidey: 12
Hand: 10
Energy Ctrs: EEEEEE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Mt
(T) Forest

Consulate Surveillance (When ~ ETB, I get EEEE.; Pay EE: Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to me this turn by a source of my choice)

(U) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(U) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(U) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 17
Hand: 10
Battlefield:

(T) Plains
(T) Swamp
(T) Island
(T) Mountain
(T) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)
(S) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation
Exile:

 

[Mooseman]

I believe the hawk is tapped?

Untap, upkeep
Island
Attack with Brusier and Mastodon
Block Response?

Spidey: 12
Hand: 10
Energy Ctrs: EEEEEE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Mt
(T) Forest

Consulate Surveillance (When ~ ETB, I get EEEE.; Pay EE: Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to me this turn by a source of my choice)

(U) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(T) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(U) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 17
Hand: 10
Battlefield:

(U) Plains
(U) Swamp
(UU) Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)
(T) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation
Exile:

 

[Spiderman]

Yeah, the Hawk is tapped.

No block.

 

[Mooseman]

no response either (since you didn't say)?
take 7?


Spidey: 12
Hand: 10
Energy Ctrs: EEEEEE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Mt
(T) Forest

Consulate Surveillance (When ~ ETB, I get EEEE.; Pay EE: Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to me this turn by a source of my choice)

(U) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(T) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(U) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 17
Hand: 10
Battlefield:

(U) Plains
(U) Swamp
(UU) Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)
(T) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation
Exile:

 

[Spiderman]

Well, you have priority first During Blockers... but I will use the Consulate and pay EEEE to prevent the damage from either.

 

[Mooseman]

Since I asked, then I had to pass priority to you.
Of course you do the energy dance
Done


Spidey: 12
Hand: 10
Energy Ctrs: EE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Mt
(T) Forest

Consulate Surveillance (When ~ ETB, I get EEEE.; Pay EE: Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to me this turn by a source of my choice)

(U) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(T) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(U) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 17
Hand: 10
Battlefield:

(U) Plains
(U) Swamp
(UU) Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)
(T) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation
Exile:

 

[Spiderman]

Dance, dance

Untap, upkeep

Island
Bastion Mastodon
Responses?


Spidey: 12
Hand: 11
Energy Ctrs: EE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Mt
(T) Forest
(T) Island

Consulate Surveillance (When ~ ETB, I get EEEE.; Pay EE: Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to me this turn by a source of my choice)

(U) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(U) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(U) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)
(S) Bastion Mastodon (4/5; W: ~ gains vigilance ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 17
Hand: 10
Battlefield:

(U) Plains
(U) Swamp
(UU) Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)
(T) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation
Exile:

 

[Mooseman]

Failed Inspection (UURG)

 

[Spiderman]

Arg.

Attack with the Hawk
Responses/blocks/take it?


Spidey: 12
Hand: 11
Energy Ctrs: EE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Mt
(T) Forest
(T) Island

Consulate Surveillance (When ~ ETB, I get EEEE.; Pay EE: Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to me this turn by a source of my choice)

(U) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(T,A) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(U) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks, Bastion Mastodon
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 17
Hand: 8 - had to discard from Failed Inspection
Battlefield:

(U) Plains
(U) Swamp
(UU) Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)
(T) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation, Failed Inspection
Exile:

 

[Mooseman]

Take it

 

[Spiderman]

That's 1

Done


Spidey: 12
Hand: 11
Energy Ctrs: EE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Mt
(T) Forest
(T) Island

Consulate Surveillance (When ~ ETB, I get EEEE.; Pay EE: Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to me this turn by a source of my choice)

(U) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(T) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(U) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks, Bastion Mastodon
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 16
Hand: 8 - had to discard from Failed Inspection
Battlefield:

(U) Plains
(U) Swamp
(UU) Island
(U) Mountain
(U) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)
(T) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation, Failed Inspection, card from hand
Exile:

 

[Mooseman]

Since I couldn't draw a card, I don't believe I have to discard a card. "(Draw a card, then discard a card.)

EOT: Create a Thropter
UU
Forest
Attack with Brusier and Mastodon
Block/Response?

Spidey: 12
Hand: 11
Energy Ctrs: EE
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Mt
(T) Forest
(T) Island

Consulate Surveillance (When ~ ETB, I get EEEE.; Pay EE: Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to me this turn by a source of my choice)

(U) Night Market Lookout (1/1; Whenever ~ becomes tapped, Mooseman loses 1 life and I gain 1 life)
(T) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(U) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks, Bastion Mastodon
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 16
Hand: 7
Battlefield:

(U) Plains
(U) Swamp
(UU) Island
(U) Mountain
(UU) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Embraal Bruiser (3/1, ETB tapped. Embraal Bruiser has menace as long as you control an artifact.)
(T) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)


Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation, Failed Inspection, MT
Exile:

 

[Spiderman]

I thought it was we tried to do as much on the card as we could? You couldn't draw, but you still discard... but no biggie if that's not how you understand it.

Also, I think you only had two mana left after casting Failed Inspection, so not enough to create a Thopter (I should have tapped the lands, sorry)

Both available block the Bruiser.

 

[Mooseman]

I thought it was we tried to do as much on the card as we could? You couldn't draw, but you still discard... but no biggie if that's not how you understand it.

I believe that since this game doesn't have mandatory card draw, since the first part cannot be done, then the second wouldn't be required (It's the "Then" that gets me there)
If it were, "Counter target spell. Draw a card. Discard a card. " Then you try to do all you can.
But we can look into this ruling later
I do have a MT, so since it's a useless card, I'll discard it.

Also, I think you only had two mana left after casting Failed Inspection, so not enough to create a Thopter (I should have tapped the lands, sorry)

Yes, you are correct, edited the post

Damage?

 

[Spiderman]

Pay EE to prevent the Mastodon dmg. That's it.

 

[Mooseman]

The Lookout dies and the bruiser too
Glint-Sleeve Artisan with counter
Done

Spidey: 12
Hand: 9
Energy Ctrs:
Battlefield:

(T) Swamp
(T,U) Plains x2
(T) Mt
(T) Forest
(T) Island

Consulate Surveillance (When ~ ETB, I get EEEE.; Pay EE: Prevent all dmg that would be dealt to me this turn by a source of my choice)

(T) Eddytrail Hawk (1/2; Flying; When ~ ETB, I get EE.; Whenever ~ attacks, I may pay E. If I do, another target attacking creature gains flying ueot)
(U) Salivating Gremlims (2/3; Whenever an artifact ETB under my control, ~ gets +2/+0 and gains trample ueot)

Graveyard: Welding Sparks, Bastion Mastodon, Night Market Lookout
Exile:
=========================================================================
Mooseman: 16
Hand: 7
Battlefield:

(T) Plains
(U) Swamp
(UT) Island
(U) Mountain
(UT) Forest

(U) Whirlermaker (A,4, Tap: Create a 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature token with flying.)

(U) Ruinous Gremlin (1/1,2R, Sacrifice Ruinous Gremlin: Destroy target artifact.)
(T) Bastion Mastodon (4/5,W: Bastion Mastodon gains vigilance until end of turn.)
(S) Glint-Sleeve Artisan (3/3, Fabricate 1) ~1 +1/+1 cntr~

Graveyard: Kambal, Consul of Allocation, Failed Inspection, MT, Embraal Bruiser
Exile: