Magic School: How to Sideboard?

C

Crackdown

Guest
As I began playing Friday Night Magic with my son, it became clear that I was building better decks, ones that could even win game one against good players. However, once the sideboarding came in, I died quickly and completely. That sent me scurrying to figure out why I was so bad at this needed Magic skill.

I have spent many hours playing MODO with maindecks, but very few with a sideboard. Partially, the reason is lack of expensive cards. I don't have 4 Oblivion Stones for Black, Death Cloud/Persecute, Cranial Extraction, etc. But that isn't the only story. I have problems figuring out what WW sideboarding to do as well.

It boils down [no pun intended] to this: How does one build a Sideboard and know what substitutions to make?

For illustration purposes, we can look at a deck recently proposed by Jamie Wakefield and one that I've begun testing (with modifications):

4 Bonesplitter
4 Oxidda Golem

4 Frostling
4 Raging Goblin (substituted Ronin Houndmaster)
4 Slith Firewalker
4 Vulshok Sorcerer

4 Glacial Ray
4 Guerilla Tactics
4 Lightning Blast
4 Shock (substituted Electrostatic Bolt)

20 Mountains

Sideboard

3 Bottle Gnomes
4 Boil
4 Molten Rain
4 Sowing Salt

I didn't have the Raging Goblins or Shocks and I wanted to clear away Etched Oracles and Myr Enforcers for my Slith Firewalkers.

Wakefield's deck plays fast and burns hard. It could probably use Lava Spike instead of Lightning Blast for Glacial Ray splicing, but I'm not certain that's better.

The question of sideboarding though dominates. I can figure out the Molten Rain and Salts for Tooth and Nail. Boil for MUC or it's variations. But, what are Bottle Gnomes doing here and what does one take out of the deck to include these when playing the local metagame?

So many articles are written on building decks, but I've found precious few discussing how to build a sideboard (and what to sideboard).

Anyone want to offer advice? Much appreciated.
 
E

evan d

Guest
I can't sideboard worth a %&#^&%$@*


Wish i could help. I will check back her to see waht i can learn.
 
J

jorael

Guest
Whell... Boil looks good against MUC.

Why the molten rains? 4x Sowing Salt looks nasty enough and too much land kill might even be harmful for your deck: it will lose speed.

Sideboarding isn't only choosing which card to board in, but also which cards to take out (I read that somewhere sometime :)). How to do it? I never play tournaments, so I have no idea....
 

Oversoul

The Tentacled One
One important detail is to test your deck with the sideboard taken into account. I usually play only casual games, and don't have to worry much about this. But for tournament decks, you can playtest the deck hundreds of times in various matchups, but if you don't use the sideboard at all in those games, you won't get a good idea of what you're doing. Most of your games take place with sideboarding. It makes sense for most of your playtesting to be with sideboarding as well.

When building a sideboard, keep in mind the decks you'll be playing against, and the ones that you'll need especial sideboarding for. Get an idea of how many cards you can side out in a given matchup. If I have seven of a certain kind of hoser in my sideboard, but can only side out three cards without compromising my deck's consistency, that's just bad.

I wish I could help with the specifics, but I'm not really familiar with the format...
 
N

Nightstalkers

Guest
I don't really sideboard until I start finding problems and cards that might solve the problems I have against some decks...

But looking into interpretation of the Bottle Gnomes in there, I'd have to say that they are there in the case of going against another burn deck or something that hits hard. Think about it for a minute, for 3 mana you get a 1/3 that you can sac at any time for 3 life.

This is all great because you get not only a wall/attacker but you also have the opportunity to boost your life by 3 at any point in time to potentially increase your life expectancy by 1 or more turns.
 

Spiderman

Administrator
Staff member
Oversoul said:
When building a sideboard, keep in mind the decks you'll be playing against, and the ones that you'll need especial sideboarding for. Get an idea of how many cards you can side out in a given matchup
This is pretty much it. First, you try to get lists of common decks or decktypes that you think you'll be playing against and that are in your area. As you playtest your deck against them, you'll find weaknesses against some decks (hopefully not all! :) ) and you'll see that some of your cards are "dead" or less useful against those decks, so you think about what and how you could strengthen your deck against those deck types and the dead and less useful cards are the ones you take out.
 

Oversoul

The Tentacled One
Spiderman said:
As you playtest your deck against them, you'll find weaknesses against some decks (hopefully not all! :) )
Yeah, if it's all, you might want to just stop using my deck and build your own... ;)
 
Top