Okay, Ransac is pretty busy, so he has asked that we move on without him, but I did receive the other response, so I'll go ahead and post results now.
Everyone but one person got the top two responses, unfortunately, only 6 of the 8 got it "right" since everyone knows who the better captain was...
Answers after that were much more varied.
America - 8
Kirk - 8
Picard - 6
Hook - 4
Morgan - 3
Crunch - 2
Blackbeard - 2
Jack Sparrow - 2
Ahab - 2
Kangeroo - 2
And the 1-point list isn't too long this time:
Silver, Balbosa, Bligh, Sisay, Drake, Marvel
To be honest, I was expecting the final list to knock turgy out of the points since he was part of the 3-way tie and was the only one that had submitted a 1-point answer. However, since the final list doubled up on his 1-point answer, it bumped him up instead of down and we have come to the end of our little game.
Melkor - 28 (5)
turgy22 - 28 (5)
BigBlue - 27 (2)
train - 27 (2)
Mooseman - 26
rokapoke - 26
Modus Pwnens - 23
Spiderman - 21
BudgetPlayerCadet - 9
And the final scores:
running total:
turgy22 - 29 *** Congratulations you generic thinker you ***
Melkor - 16 - nice move at the end, taking 2nd
Mooseman - 13
rokapoke - 12
BigBlue - 10
Spiderman - 8
DarthFerret - 5
train - 5
Ransac - 4
Budget Player Cadet - 1
Modus Pwnens - 0