Discussion in 'Rules Questions' started by Duel, Apr 14, 2000.
Does trample damage go through Cho-manno? Does my Yavimaya wurm still deal four to the guy?
Yeah, your Wurm does it's trample damage. Cho-Manno reduces damage assigned to it from a non-Lava Burst (inside joke for people who know the rules TOO well) source to 0. So, the Wurm, following the rules for trample, assigns damage equal to the blocker's toughness (in this case, 2) to the blocker. It assigns the remaining 4 to the defending player.
Once damage is assigned, Cho-Manno gets mad, and says 'You can't do that, I don't wanna take damage!' So the damage on Cho-Manno is reduced to 0. The damage already assigned to the player doesn't change, though, so they get to take their 4.
(Fog Bank is different, it doesn't recieve ANY damage, so all the damage tramples through there.)
"Which is why no one plays Fog Bank anymore..."
Actually, trampling damage does NOT go through Cho-Manno. Trample works like this: Whenever the trampling creature assigns combat damage, lethal damage MUST be dealt to the blocking creature by the trampler, THEN the excess power of the trampler hits the opponent. Since all damage dealt to Cho-Manno is reduced to zip, zero, and nada, he absorbs all damage done by the trampler and protects the defender from any damage. Just like Uncle Istvan.
Legend Master, you are mistaken. Lethal damage assignment *assumes* no other effects. It ignores protection from a color, it ignores damage prevention shields, it ignores everything except toughness. You have to assign enough damage to kill the creature without any outside effects coming into play. You can choose to deal more, but the minimum is only the creature's toughness.
Also, Zadok, Fog Bank has been rewritten under 6th Edition (Oracle wordings) to be the same as Cho-Manno, but only for combat damage.
Fog Bank (1U), 0/2
Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt to and dealt by Fog Bank.
Mordecai is right, you take some damage - same as with Protection creatures.
I didn`t know that Fog Bank was errataed.
Neither did I! Neato! Now I can play the thing again...
"Sucky cards, unite!"
Sucky card?? I love Fog Bank!
"Nice Morphling you got there. *yawn*"
I never thought about this!!!
Lava Burst CAN kill Cho-Manno. Why am I not playing with this card in my Multi red deck?
To paraphrase Instanbul...
Nice Righteous Aura you got there. *yawn*
Nice Orim, Sucky Healer you got there. *yawn*
Nice HONORABLE PASSAGE you got there. *yawn*
Separate names with a comma.