Search results

I am strongly opposed to this. Vintage is the format that restricts cards rather than banning them outright because it's the format where players are supposed to be able to use all of their cards. That's not what we're doing here. I think that what will happen when you allow the broken cards we...

Really? I'll take one!

I'd still rather just go with the Legacy banned list. I don't really feel like debating whether Crop Rotation or Lotus Petal might be broken in this format. And the same goes for Mind's Desire and Black Vise.

What a ripoff! How's the fae pie, anyway?

Actually, I think there are a couple of picks Modus could make that could dramatically alter the face of this format. I believe in you, BigBlue. Yeah. The bad news is that I am indeed insane. The good news is that I caught it later when I went back and read what you said again? Same here.

So, how much for a sliver pie?

Yeah, those two and Sol Ring as well. And in conjunction with Tinker and Memory Jar, I'd think. But there'd be other options too. Cut out enough cards that have synergy with it and even Memory Jar won't be broken. Even without Scourge, there are still plenty of options. Like Al0ysiusHWWW...

So half the people in the T8 gave their decks the wrong name?

Windfall costs 2U.

Maybe it's a regional thing? I mean, there are three other decks in the T8 for this tournament that use the same creatures and they're all labeled UGW Faeries. Swans are awesome. If I were to play in Extended right now, I'd be sorely tempted to play this deck. Alas, my love for storm is too...

Phantom Warrior

No. I didn't tap my Gemstone Mine because I still had B floating from Dark Ritual.

Done.

Tinker will probably be banned. It's banned in Legacy, which is the list I've been wanting us to go by. If it is allowed for some reason, then we'll all be using it, artifact lands or no. Blocking Mirrodin seems like a bad reason for picking a set, but I'm cool with it: I like Fifth Dawn anyway.

Nothing is restricted so far, since we never got any consensus on banned/restricted lists in the first place. Let's not get ahead of ourselves. As for restrictions mattering, they definitely would in certain cases. If someone picks a set with Brainstorm, people building decks with any blue cards...

Well, the first list I posted was just the Legacy banned list, but I did also post, for convenience, the list of cards that are restricted in Vintage but not banned in Legacy (as of now, the only cards in our format that are in this category are Crop Rotation and Regrowth). My suggestion in the...

I'm not incredibly up on Extended, but I might be able to help. What kind of decks did you have in mind? I mean, I'm a huge fan of Tendrils of Agony, if my sig didn't make that clear enough. Here's a winning Tendrils build from Extended this month... 4 Desperate Ritual 2 Electrolyze 4...

I know!

Update... Standalone 1: Tempest (Spiderman) Expansion 1: Urza's Legacy (DarthFerret) Expansion 2: Scourge (Oversoul Core: Revised (Al0ysiusHWWW) Expansion 3: Ransac Expansion 4: Melkor Expansion 5: BigBlue Standalone 2: Modus Ice Age - Alliances, Coldsnap Mirage - Visions, Weatherlight Tempest...

For once I actually checked the announcement before you posted it here! I have to say it's about what I expected. I still wish they'd unban certain cards in Legacy, but it apparently isn't happening for now and the format's pretty healthy anyway...