Search results

Huh. Well, I tried to post that weeks ago, but I guess it got eaten by the forum monster. I'll find it again...

And I'm finally getting back to this! I'd needed to crunch some numbers for awarding gold and such, and I'd built up a bit of a backlog. We're at a bit of a vague point now, and I half-expected someone to bump this. Anyway, it looks like we're ready to backtrack to the fountain chamber and...

At the time I posted that, the spreadsheet I saw had no "Oversoul" tab. It was still just the rest of you guys and went up to "Deck 5" on the numbered pools. Either the update hadn't carried over or my PC was displaying an old version of the doc that it had already downloaded. I dunno. Anyway...

So where is the list of cards from which I need to make cuts?

Huh, I can't see your maybeboard on TappedOut. Although maybe only you can see your own maybeboard? I assumed that everyone could see any maybeboards I put on my decks, but it occurs to me that maybe they're hidden. Oh well, I suspected you'd given some thought to some of the cards I was naming...

I've done a lot of testing on Duel Decks, although not as extensively as I'd like. My experience with them is, well, a mixed bag. Some of them would be very difficult for a new player to properly utilize. But what is cool about them in most cases is that one of them is very intricate in its...

Yeah, it's probably not actually worth it in this deck, but I was thinking of ideal scenarios, like canceling out the -1/-1 counters on three different Persist creatures so that they're all "reset" by a spell that costs no mana. But you really want to be going for something like Mikaeus or...

I haven't even seen a Ghave deck in a while and I forget some of the nuances of what was best, but I'm going to throw some ideas out there anyway... Bounty of the Hunt (your deck seems well-positioned to take advantage of it) Diabolic Intent (sure looks a lot better for this deck than Diabolic...

Oh, it's already on TappedOut! Here: http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/gitrog-county-municipal-lake-dredge-appraisal/ I forget if that's completely identical to the latest list on the thread here, but both should be very, very close to the actual decklist as it sits in my deckbox. But as you can...

Heh. Both lists still W/B/G. And the overlap with mine is actually not that prevalent, which probably shouldn't surprise me but might anyway. I've been remiss in updating my own Commander deck, but I want to get to that soon. It deserves an update with the "official" official unbanning of...

Ditch Swamp, Forest, Mulch. UUD, Forest, Boneyard Wurm, done. Spiderman: 24 Hand: 5 Library: 46 Battlefield: (T,T,U,U) Plains x4 Honor of the Pure (White creatures I control get +1/+1) (U) Butcher's Cleaver (Equipped creature gets +3/+0.; As long as equipped creature is a Human, it has...

Since apparently I'm still not inclined to shut up, I'm going to go off on a bit of a tangent here... The new MTGO ban list includes Sol Ring, as I noted in my previous post. What I didn't say was how very much that makes sense, in the context of what else is on there. And yet, for others this...

EOT flashback Forbidden Alchemy. I'll have to wait until I get home to see what cards I find.

UUD, Island, done. Spiderman: 24 Hand: 5 Library: 47 Battlefield: (T,T,U,U) Plains x4 Honor of the Pure (White creatures I control get +1/+1) (U) Butcher's Cleaver (Equipped creature gets +3/+0.; As long as equipped creature is a Human, it has lifelink.; Equip 3) (U) Elite Vanguard...

UUD, Mulch revealing Forest, Forest, Birds of Paradise, Mulch, and Island. Play a Forest, done. Spiderman: 24 Hand: 5 Library: 48 Battlefield: (T,T,T,U) Plains x4 (U) Butcher's Cleaver (Equipped creature gets +3/+0.; As long as equipped creature is a Human, it has lifelink.; Equip 3) (U)...

I don't want to come across as a whiney complainer with only negative dissent to offer, but at this point I'm apprehensive about both options here. On the one hand... Wizards of the Coast, or specifically "the DCI" are crap at generating ban lists for formats. Wait, calling them crap at it...

EOT Forbidden Alchemy ditching Acidic Slime, Llanowar Elves, Llanowar Elves. UUD, Hinterland Harbor, Spider Spawning, done. Spiderman: 24 Hand: 4 Library: 49 Battlefield: (T,T,T,U) Plains x4 (U) Butcher's Cleaver (Equipped creature gets +3/+0.; As long as equipped creature is a Human, it...

And they're rolling it back partially: http://wizardsmtgo.tumblr.com/post/160343614814/update-mtgo-commander Seems like there's been a lot of official waffling lately.

There is a lot to talk about with these changes generally, and I don't even know where to start. The weirdness of the Commander Rules Committee? The huge popularity of a casual multiplayer format format? The prevalence of an official sealed product line (containing tournament-legal cards) meant...

Because I don't normally look for MTGO announcements, I didn't even catch this one yesterday. But now it's blowing up on a lot of websites. People have some, uh, strong opinions on this stuff... http://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/magic-online/1v1-commander-banned-list